Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

The New Deal and the Great Society - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : unique68

Summary

Historians on the left denounce Roosevelt for rescuing capitalism when the opportunity was at hand to nationalize banking, railroads and other institutions…

Extract of sample
The New Deal and the Great Society

Historians on the left denounce Roosevelt for rescuing capitalism when the

opportunity was at hand to nationalize banking, railroads and other institutions.(Conkin) Liberal

historians argue that Roosevelt restored hope and self respect to tens of millions of desperate

people, built labor unions, upgraded the national infrastructure and saved capitalism in his first

term, when he could have destroyed it and easily nationalized the banks and rail roads(Sitkoff)

Historians on the right complain that he enlarged the powers of the federal government, built

up labor unions, slowed long term growth, and weakened the business community. Historians on the

left have denounced the New Deal as a conservative phenomenon that let slip the opportunity to

radically reform capitalism.

Since the 1960’s, “new left” historians have been among the New Deal harsh critics. Barton

J. Bernstein, in a 198 essay, compiled a chronicle of missed opportunities and inadequate responses

to problems. The New Deal may have saved capitalism from itself, Bernstein charged, but it failed

to help – and in many cases actually harmed – those groups most in need of assistance. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Compare and Contrast two cultures
This does not mean that she is an entirely close-minded person. She is exactly the opposite. She has very clear ways of thinking, expressing herself on general matters and is capable of sticking to her own viewpoint mulishly. Only when it comes to personal and emotional issues, it is almost impossible to get a word from Lisa. Her opinions, when they are mildly expressed, lean more towards prudish and conventional mould. But socially she is known to be a liberal to the point of generosity. She cannot tolerate people suffering socially with any kind of stigma. Her prudishness is mainly applied…
7 pages (1757 words)
compare and contrast two leaders
In this context, words of Konrad Heiden hold true. "For years, Mein Kampf stood as a proof of the blindness and complacency of the world. In its pages Hitler announced -long before he came to power-a program of blood and terror in a self revelation of such overwhelming frankness that few had the courage to believe itThat such a man could go so far towards realizing his ambitions-that is a phenomenon the World will ponder for centuries to come" (Konrad 1969). Mohandas Gandhi was born on October 2, 1869, to Karamchand Gandhi, at Porbandar, an obscure town in Gujarat. He had a very good childhood…
11 pages (2761 words)
Two agglomeration economies: conditions needed for their formation and benefits that allow them to thrive
The concept of agglomeration in economics has always been confined to urban economies. The theory describes the advantages which firms experience when they settle in a closed regional periphery in proximity to each other. Agglomeration economies justifies the clustering of firms together by focusing on lower the cost of production resulting from easy availability of multiple suppliers and scope for specialization of labor according to their skill-set. Owing to agglomeration economies, people and firms give attention to a particular region of operation or a specific geographical region.The…
13 pages (3263 words)
Improving the Human Conditions
Any program designed for AIDS prevention must consider the stigma associated with the disease and with homosexuality. The World Health Organization intended to provide simple local access to those needing treatment by providing clinics in areas of high leprosy incidence. However, without prior investigation, they could not know that, because of the social stigma, utilization of clinical facilities was not a matter of simple distance or lack of transportation (Campbell, 2003).…
4 pages (1004 words)
New Deal and Welfare Reforms: Just How New Is It
5). Since then, reforms in the National Health Service, housing, personal social services and social security have been introduced and put into place. The Government believes employment to be the "best route out of poverty (Building on New Deal, 2004, intro, par. 2). For this reason, two efforts in 1997 at bringing this about were the appointment of the first Minister of Public Health and a health strategy developed to break the cycle of ill health due to poverty and deprivation. In addition, the Welfare Reform and Pensions Act of 1999 required all benefit claimants to attend interviews to…
6 pages (1506 words)
The New Deal and the Great Society
Historians on the left denounce Roosevelt for rescuing capitalism when the opportunity was at hand to nationalize banking, railroads and other institutions.(Conkin) (Sitkoff) Historians on the right complain that he enlarged the powers of the federal government, built up labor unions, slowed long term growth, and weakened the business community. Historians on the left have denounced the New Deal as a conservative phenomenon that let slip the opportunity to radically reform capitalism. Since the 1960’s, “new left” historians have been among the New Deal harsh critics. Barton J. Bernstein,…
4 pages (1004 words)
Report
Both the New Deal and the Great Society were programs that were supported by social activists. Roosevelt faced an economy in severe disarray, while Johnson became president during a period of prosperity. The New Deal was almost exclusively aimed at correcting the economic woes that faced America, while the Great Society also meant to correct racial injustice and environmental problems brought on by a changing demographic and new technologies (Johnson, ch. 28). Roosevelt faced high unemployment and extreme poverty when he took office. His programs, such as the Tennessee Valley Authority and the…
3 pages (753 words)