StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Ferdinand Tonnies - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Ferdinand Tonnies

The theme is haunted by wartime profiteering at the cost of soldiers' lives and the sheer contrast is shown by the brothers Chris and Larry, one abhors ill-begotten wealth and another kills himself for his father's crime.
Class issues have never been appreciated in America a country that loves to live as a capitalist. Larry's death is a hovering presence of morality and regret in the play. It represents universality, living for one another, and dying for distant people. Chris says: "Once and for all you can know that there is a universe of people outside and you are responsible to it, and unless you know that, you threw away your son because that is what he died,"
The concept of capitalism in the play is totally opposite to the philosophy of Marx, even though it somehow connects to it here and there. It is a play of conflict and agreement where at one point, the capitalist is the gainer while labour does not gain, but need not shoulder the responsibility, because he lives in the world of work alienation. "For Marx the modern wage worker's labour was alienated in the sense that his work was repetitive, routine, fragmented and dull, and the worker was merely 'an appendage to the machine'" Blumburg (1969, p.299). Yet, the benefit in the play is that though the faulty cylinders were made by the labour, along with the profit, capitalist shoulders the responsibility of the fault too. It is because the labour gets paid (perhaps underpaid) for his work and gets ticked off and he need not shoulder the eventual responsibility of the faulty pieces that will later kill a group of pilots.

"In fact, therefore, the worker has exchanged his commodity, labour power, for other commodities of all kinds and that in a definite ratio. By giving him two marks, the capitalist has given him so much meat, so much clothing, so much fuel, light, etc., in exchange for his day's labour. says Marx"

Still, it is not possible for the worker to live without his life-activity, as it is what supports his life. He might not be responsible for the faulty parts, because he was ordered to make them, and he would not blow up his brains for it; still he cannot get away from the vicious circle. "But the exercise of labour power, labour, is the worker's own life-activity, the manifestation of his own life. And this life-activity he sells to another person in order to secure the necessary means of subsistence. Thus his life-activity is for him only a means to enable him to exist" (ibid).

Having said that, Marx says that worker does not belong to either the employer. This could be conflicting when we realise that the pilots, who are the employers of the State, died for the state. They die either due to faulty parts or due to the war, decided by their employer. So, Marx's following statement cannot jell well here. "The worker belongs neither to an owner nor to the land, but eight, ten, twelve, fifteen hours of his daily life belong to him who buys them. The worker leaves the capitalist to whom he hires himself whenever he likes, and the capitalist discharges him whenever he thinks fit, as soon as he no longer gets any profit out of him, or not the anticipated profit".Reading 2.

Pilots can hire themselves, but cannot leave their State if they decide to do so, like an ordinary worker. They suffer for the State's faulty decisions, for the faulty war-profiteering work of the capitalist who creates capital out of the ...Show more
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Compare Contrast Social Issue Found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Essay)
“Compare Contrast Social Issue Found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times


There are many comparisons and contrasts between Miller and Marx. Miller in his play 'All My Sons' based upon a true story which is about a woman, who informed on her father who was a sales man of faulty parts to the military during Second World War and the subsequent events…
Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Ferdinand Tonnies
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Ferdinand Tonnies"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Karl Marx
One of the most imperative reasons behind making an investigation into the topic afore-mentioned includes the evaluation of the political ideology articulated by Marxist perspective while seeking its association with Marx’s viewpoint on historical developments man has observed since the primitive times till the Marx’s era of Industrial Revolution.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Karl Marx
Marx asserts that the human being has a natural productive capacity: that they are natural workers and have an innate ability to sustain an economy of profit. After exploring this idea in many of his essays, Marx elaborates upon it in the Communist Manifesto by identifying the conditions that are most conducive to the promotion of the natural productive capacity of workers.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Compare and contrast the theories of Karl Marx (the class motive) and John Stuart Mill (the happiness motive) with reference to the issue of oppression in moder
n in Marx’s work, as he struggles to analyze the origins and supports for class oppression, Mills was more concerned with the idea of the struggle for an individual’s happiness against institutions which oppressed and restricted that happiness. Political individualism is
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Arthur Miller
The author points out that through understanding of the various types of work Miller has engaged in, it is possible to discuss the aspects of Miller’s work that have made him famous some of which are the reasons he stands out as being an outstanding author. Miller is known for his work as a playwright and some notable works in other areas as well.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Compare and contrast Karl Marx's and Max Weber's ideas about capitalism. Which points does Weber against to Marx
Social inequality will only be leveled when the blue-collar and underclass revolt replacing individual ownership with collective ownership of production facilities. Weberism views inequality as a multifaceted segment within the societal
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Compare / Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx / Ferdinand Tonnies
It is considered to be a criticism of American dream that could eventually crash in a nightmarish conclusion projecting myth of money, capital and
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Compare and Contrast : The Lover of Horses by Tess Gallagher and The Misfits by Arthur Miller
This collection of the stories is the platform for Gallagher to prove that she well adept for fiction and poetry as well. A large number of stories in this collection appear with an autobiographical intonation and speak about the concern
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Karl marx
It is the basis for comprehending the theory of what a capitalist state was, written on the basis of English politics by Marx. The main objective of the writing composition was to help the world understand the kind
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Classical Social Theory - Karl Marx

According to the paper, Marx’s understandings into actors and organizations must be understood in the setting of his assessments on human nature, which is the source for his critical study of the inconsistencies of capitalism. In his opinion, an illogicality exists concerning our human nature and efforts in the capitalist organization.

3 pages (750 words) Essay
Karl Marx
And he time and again adhered to a thorough obligation to open experiential examination of the whole story. Marx individual goals were thus certainly framed by means of his ambition to make scientific investigation of the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare Contrast Social Issue found in Arthur Miller and Karl Marx Ferdinand Tonnies for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us