The Argument Against the Existence of God - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
The Argument Against the Existence of God

The theologian embraces three propositions - God is omnipotent, God is good and evil exists. Mackie's brilliant argument for the problem of evil has shown that the first two propositions cannot be true while the third exists. He has made use of two additional premises to drive the point home. He calls these "quasi-logical rules connecting the terms 'good', 'evil', and 'omnipotent'" (Mackie 78). These additional propositions state that good is in a state of opposition with evil and seeks to eliminate it and that omnipotence is without limits. Therefore Mackie's argument and the problem of evil has decimated the very core of theistic belief by claiming that "the several parts of the essential theological doctrine are inconsistent with one another, so that the theologian can maintain his position as a whole only by a much more extreme rejection of reason" (Mackie 77). Thus his argument calls for a complete reconstruction of the theological doctrine as we know it.
At the onset Mackie outlines certain adequate solutions to the problem of evil that is also consistent with the essential theistic propositions or which rejects one or more of the propositions. He makes it clear that only those who believe that God is omnipotent and wholly good are confounded by this problem. ...
Download paper


J.L Mackie's, "Evil and Omnipotence" is an argument against the existence of an omnipotent and wholly good God on the basis of the problem of evil. According to theological doctrine, God is omnibenevolent but this belief is rendered inconsistent by the presence of evil in the world and the theologian can subscribe to it only by divorcing himself from reason…
Author : cyrusrutherford

Related Essays

Essay on belief: does God exist?
My family gave me a moral code by which to live by which included the potential outcomes from a judgmental God. This vision of a more wrathful God led me to pursue new explanations because my personal faith would not allow me to see a supreme being in just one light. I have always felt that my family's viewpoint on God and religion was narrow-minded and needed a more flexible outlook. No information is available which proves God exists, therefore my beliefs are faith-based.This faith is built on an argument from one author who incorporates the lessons of St. Augustine when saying, "Since God...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Does God Exsist
Aquinas' five reasons for the existence of God are: the principle of motion, efficient cause, possibility and necessity, gradation of things and finally the governance of the world. These principles are used to counter two earlier mentioned objections as to the existence of God. These objections question the probability of an all-good God allowing evil in the world and whether or not God is the true source of creation. The main argument for the existence of God is that the source of all in existence is best explained by an original source with no limits and that is God. This paper aims to...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
The Case Against Evolution
In order to understand the dangers of teaching evolution, it is first necessary to define the term. Evolution refers to the attempt to establish the origins of life on Earth. This approach is based upon the scientific and naturalistic theories of narrow-minded scientists. The approach is most often espoused by astrophysicists, geologists and biologists (Creation-Evolution Controversy). The scientific method is the sole method of analysis. Morals and the supernatural are irrelevant. Evolutionists argue that the universe was created instantaneously from nothing, that life forms developed slowly,...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Touman Model Argument about the Environment
Touman Model Argument about the Environment
5 pages (1255 words) Term Paper
Aquinas' fifth way argument: is it valid? can we deduce from it that god exists?
sion presents a summation of Aquinas’ Fifth Way argument promoting a grand designer and examines points of view from David Hume, John Hicks, and Douglas Geivett among others regarding the validity of its reasoning regarding the existence of God. As it is imperative to understand the context of Aquinas’ Fifth Way argument, a brief description of the first four ways (all based on the study of natural events) will be presented.
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
To what extent does the 'cosmological' argument establish the existence of God?
1. Thomas Aquinas adapted Aristotle and Avicenna’s thinking to form his cosmological argument in which he states that the universe is the result of a ‘first cause’ that is itself uncaused, and this ultimate cause according to him, is God. The premise of his argument basically states that every thing that was once non existent has a cause. Since, according to the second premise –something that is finite and dependent (contingent) cannot create itself. In his third premise Aquinas stated that a causal chain cannot stretch back into eternity. This is why Aquinas argues -there must be a...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Existence of God
I feel that this argument is the strongest because it is the one that is seen most often, especially in a religious setting. It is something that is entirely based off of faith; it is the one argument does not require evidence for a person to believe that such a thing as God does exist, which, in my opinion, makes it one of the strongest arguments.
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!