StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas

This law, otherwise known as the 'February 23, 2005' law, was passed quietly in February of 2005, but came to prominence in the autumn when there was an overwhelming vote by conservative deputies against a bid to revoke the phrase. This touched off on a debate about whether France, whose empire ended in bloody wars in Indochina and Algeria, had learnt from its colonial experience.
The trouble started in February when lawmakers quietly slipped a clause into a bill requiring schools to "recognize in particular the positive character of the French overseas presence, notably in North Africa."
Some of the key players in this situation would be: President Jacques Chirac of Paris, Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin, Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, Gilles Manceron, and Olivier Petre-Grenouilleau - a respected historian who was accused of making statements in an interview which implied that the slave trade was not a crime against humanity. (In fact, he said that it didn't constitute genocide). Gilles Manceron noted that for some historians, the treatment of the harkis exemplifies how France has basically failed to deal with aspects of its past, saying "The state put them in military camps or in isolated camps in forests, cut off from the rest of the French population. This isolation is comparable to the treatment of indigenous people in the colonies." (Gehmlich, 2006). Hamlaoui Mekachera, junior minister for veterans' affairs who is also of Algerian origin and in fact actually fought for the French army during the Algerian war, praised the law, saying it was "a historic moment for people of all origins who have been repatriated." He went on to say, "The current debate must not allow us to forget the real range of measures (the law) contains." (Geimlich, 2006).
Who Wants a Repeal of the law and who Does not, and why
More than 1000 historians, writers and intellectuals have signed a petition demanding the repeal of this law. "In retaining only the positive aspects of colonialism this law imposes an official lie on massacres that at times went as far as genocide on the slave trade, and on the racism that France has inherited," says the petition, which has also been signed by one of France's best-loved humorists, Guy Bedos, and a leading film director, Patrice Chereau.
The principal objection to the law is ...Show more


Hardly had the fires died down in the suburbs of Paris, as the November rioting by immigrant youths petered out, than the flames of another conflict fed by France's colonial past began to sweep through France's political landscape.
The law of February 23, 2005, as it is known, was intended to recognize the contribution of the 'harkis', the 200,000 or so Algerians who fought alongside France's colonial troops in their country's war of independence, from 1954-62, before being abandoned to a dreadful fate when the French withdrew - "about 130,000 were executed as traitors." (Henley, 2005)…
Author : maxie73
The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

The Philosopher's Way: The Presence of the Common Law
In turn, the uniqueness of each philosophy book is based on the fact that every philosopher has his own distinct worldview. It is for this same reason that The Philosopher's Way by John Chaffe has been acclaimed as not only being an interesting read, but as key to understanding philosophical concepts and worldviews that are parallel to the ones people have largely acquired mainly through non-inquisitive elements of acculturation.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Positive and negative rights: a matter of controversy
In fact, these rights considerably vary from negative rights. The negative rights usually involve the autonomy and freedom to do something. It may include the right to wear what one likes or the right to protection from torture. Quoting from the work of Beauchamp, Keridge et al (2005, p.98) write that a positive right is a right to well-being, which involves the right to receive goods or services.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Discuss The Controversy Surrounding The Chapman Brothers Rectified Works of Francisco Goyas Disasters of War Series
Jake and Dinos Chapman’s Insult of Injury is more like an imitation of Francisco Goya’s The Disasters of War, but the fact that they differ in terms of aesthetics, ethics, semiotics and religious sacrilege has made the work of the Chapman brothers to be highly criticized and this has made people to believe that the Chapman brothers’ Insult to injury strayed from the original message of The Disasters of War.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
This term can be used in various situations in everyday context. When used in the context of internet, it gives a slightly different perspective or meaning. The term “Web presence” is used to denote both website as well as the web servers. When one talks about presence in the web, it denotes the website and when one focuses on physical presence, it is the web servers.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Debating Rococo's Role in the French Revolution
Pastel colors and light and airy scenery characterized Rococo art. With regard to the French Revolution, Rococo art was the motivation, the precursor, and the decoration that characterized French society in the early 18th Century. II. Rococo Art: Motivation for a Revolution Rococo art was definitely one motivation for the French Revolution.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
It is generally determined to be an exploration of finding solutions to scientific and social problems through defined objectives and systematic analysis. With the rapid development of technology and the emergence of globalisation in one business operating area, it has been viewed that competitors are increasing at an alarming rate.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Background on the Controversy Surrounding Freedom of Choice versus Smoking Ban
X. The harms of smoking are such that it is imperative to pass a ban on public smoking as a means of discouraging the habit and limiting its harms, irrespective of arguments claiming that doing so would be a violation of inalienable human freedoms. In social, political and legal environments which uphold freedom of choice and personal liberty, the decision of some governments and local authorities to ban smoking in public places has been a subject of controversy and debate.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Violent content in media and controversy surrounding it
Concerning this view, the work at hand covers the relevant controversies associated with violent content in the media with primary consideration of the case of animated films or TV programs. There are divided opinions concerning the impact of violent content of
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
At present there are a number of solutions that can be implemented so as to resolve the current controversy surround the provision of healthcare within the United States. These
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The capital of New Zealand is Wellington and Auckland is the most populous city of the country. The population of the nation is approximately 4.5 million as per the estimates on June, 2014 in which 29% inhabitants are youth in age; thus ensuring a sound
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us