Insanity and Criminality in Literature - Book Report/Review Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Insanity and Criminality in Literature

. . are seen as contestable, but those of science as inconvertible" (6). In earlier times the reverse was true: religion was inconvertible and science was contestable. Although the shift that granted science technical status as "the accurate reading of Nature's book with eyes undistorted by social interest or cultural prejudice'" occurred over a long period of time (Wright and Treacher 4), in the narrow context of insanity and culpability the shift from moral conceptions of insanity to physiological conceptions of insanity occurred during the nineteenth century when voluntarist discourse, with its assumptions of free will, individual responsibility, and self-discipline, conflicted with determinist/fatalist discourse, with its assumption of inevitability and the inescapability of predetermined fate.
The conflict between these different worldviews led to confusion regarding normal versus abnormal human behaviour and, indeed, to debate over sanity versus insanity. The question became whether humans freely chose their path and was their path imposed upon them. Needless to say, the implication here was that man's status in the universe and his role in his society/world were all questioned. ...
Download paper


The nineteenth century was a period of socio-political turmoil. Technological advances, rapid cultural changes and the evolution of alternate worldviews all combined to inspire a reconsideration of the human condition and man's status in the world and vis-vis others…
Author : carterdelta

Related Essays

African literature
The recent boom in the publishing of contemporary African literature,which has occurred side by side with the developments in the study of oral literature in Africa,has been instrumental in the analysis of the relationship between oral African poetry and written African poetry. Although motivated by quite disparate circumstances, the effects of both these phenomena have shed light on the cultural aspects of the land. In spite of the harmful effects of the education of Africans in the languages and ideas of colonial nations which destroyed the traditional culture of the land, the recent...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Insanity Defense
Following a brief comparative definition and discussion of each, this essay will argue in favour of ALI as the better of the three models....
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Lucian John Robert Lee, whose poetry has always evinced great flexibility of subject, register and style, has been moving conspicuously towards an increasingly uncompromising lyricism of personal Christian confession and ritualised testimony." (Scott, 238) In a reflective exploration of the poem "Vocation", it becomes lucid that John Robert Lee's poetry demonstrates great flexibility of subject, register and style and the poetic devices used in the poem effectively highlights the central themes of the poem....
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
World Literature
Set in Corinth in Greece, the whole play is enacted in a single scene in front of Medea's house. The nurse and chorus act as conscious-keepers of Medea and the attenders and messengers are employed by the playwright to depict scene shifts through their speech. In fact, the very opening of the play sets the tone of the horrific nature of events to follow. With a voice of doom of one of the nurses of Medea clearly indicates that her mistress, a victim of fate, is out to contrive some untoward scheme. The nurse acts as a foreteller of deeds to ensue. Through her speech we learn how in love she...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Insanity defense :
Yet, the insanity defense has come under attack numerous times since its inception because of its very malleable nature – some who are obviously insane, such as Charles Guiteau who shot President Garfield in 1881, are found incontrovertibly guilty while others, such as John Hinkley who shot President Reagan in 1981, are found not guilty by reason of insanity. “There is a very strong perception in America that defendants are abusing this defense to escape murder charges in the nation’s courts” (Gado, 2005). In terms of the defense actually being used, reports indicate that the insanity...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Known as the “Son of Sam”, Berkowitz killed six people and wounded seven others (Reamer, 11). Berkowitz believed his neighbors dog was giving him orders to kill. Although, Berkowitz heard voices and technically qualified for the insanity defense, he pleaded guilty without a trial. Some have speculated the Berkowitz was schizophrenic, but the vigilante atmosphere in New York did not make his prospects during a trial look good....
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Women were further forced into the stereotypical passive housewife role” (Frick, 2002). Those women who found this role difficult to assume were often the subjects of harsh treatments or otherwise controlling methods that were designed to bring them back into their socially accepted, and therefore considered natural, roles. “Cures included bed rest, seclusion, bland food, refrain from mental activities (such as reading), daily massage, and sensory depravation. Though these treatments do not seem too appalling, they were comparable to solitary confinement and would often drive a woman to...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!