Critically discuss the strengths and weaknesses of New Public Management in the UK and another country, illustrating your answer with examples from one public s - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Critically discuss the strengths and weaknesses of New Public Management in the UK and another country, illustrating your answer with examples from one public s

The characteristics f this bureaucratic state were set out most clearly by the German sociologist Max Weber in 1920, with strong echoes f earlier writings by the American Woodrow Wilson (Hughes, 1998):
Further refinement f the traditional model f public administration came through the application f private sector based ideas f 'scientific management', which introduced efficient operational methods based on standardization f tasks, 'one best way' f fitting workers to tasks, and systematic control f tasks, processes, and workers (Hughes, 1998,33-34). These principles were easily adapted to bureaucratic structures. A final addition to the traditional model was the application f the insights f social psychology, in a 'human relations' approach which is often contrasted with the scientific management approach, but in practice sought to achieve greater efficiency f performance too, though by paying attention to the need to motivate workers rather than merely control and direct them (Hughes, 1998, 35-6).
Unfortunately, the ideal bureaucr ...
Download paper


The traditional model f public administration is based on the bureaucracy theory. It is characterized as "an administration under the formal control f the political leadership, based on a strictly hierarchical model f bureaucracy, staffed by permanent, neutral and anonymous officials, motivated only by the public interest, serving any governing party equally, and not contributing to policy but merely administrating those policies decided by the politicians." The traditional model f administration was an improvement compared to the earlier one, which was regarded as the replacement f personal administration with an impersonal system based on rules…
Author : lew79

Related Essays

New Public Management (NPM) as a framework for the comparative analysis of public administration
Having said this the study will now move on to summarise Pollitt (2001)....
13 pages (3263 words) Article
New Public Management Bachelor Essay
There are primarily two views that are discussed here concerning the significance of NPM as a framework, the argument that there is now a global movement that has resulted in transformed structural changes across the international community and that of adaptive changes across individual nation states, each with a degree of variance depending on cultural and historical traditions and values. In discussing this second view this paper concentrates on the debate surrounding the convergence of NPM across the western capitalized states and does not draw on the models that are emerging throughout the...
11 pages (2761 words) Essay
Public Management
But in recent time, the emphasis on New Public Management/ Public sector management approaches has forced public organizations to pay closer attention to their services delivery as con summers have begun to expect and demand more for their tax dollars". In this instance, no consumer of public goods and services are content with grumbling about poorly- produced goods and services and the under-qualified, untrained employees who render these services to them. Hence, as societies become more critical and litigious, public service organizations must seek all possible avenues for improving their...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Does U.S public opinion facilitate or constrain U.S foreign policy-makers? Illustrate your answer with reference to at least one country.
Whether or not public opinion facilitates or constrains US foreign policy makers depends first and foremost on the level of importance given to the surrounding issue by the US public. If the issue is of great importance to the public and there is a common consensus as to how the problem may be resolved between a majority of the public and policy makers, policy makers are likely to be facilitated in their foreign policy aims. The most recent and significant example of this is the US incursion into Iraq in 2003. When an issue is of lesser importance, resulting in a less educated public, the...
16 pages (4016 words) Essay
With reference to the UK and another country of your choice, critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of two models of cross-cultural comparative analysis. What are the implications of these for managers?
The former scientist considers culture from a pragmatic perspective. He claims that culture integrates such aspects of human activities as human ability to solve problems with regard to time constraints and external environment (Trompenaars, 1993)....
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Compare Public Management Reform in the UK with one other country of your choice. What does the comparison tell you about the factors that shape public management in each country?
The objective is to understand deeper the specific circumstances confronted by each country in public sector management....
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
Compare the management of a public service in the UK to that of one other country of your choice. What does the comparison tell you about the factors that shape public management in each country?
igned to provide specified benefits, financial risk cover, and improved access to health services with the goal of improving the health outcomes (Baum, 2009). The healthcare programs are not meant to provide coverage for all people of the country and neither are they meant to provide treatment for all ailments. The healthcare policies are decided by three important dimensions. These refer to the people who are covered, the services that are covered along with the extent of costs that are covered. The topic of healthcare is selected since it affects all citizens of a nation. While rich people...
15 pages (3765 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!