StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Compare Mencius theory of Human Nature as Good with Xunzis Theory of Human Nature as Evil - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Compare Mencius theory of Human Nature as Good with Xunzis Theory of Human Nature as Evil

He said when people follow their original morality, they show exceptional goodness that has been bestowed on them by nature. According to him people are unhappy when others suffer and would like to save them from such sufferings and that is the side of goodness and he showed the example of all people rushing to save the child, which is about to fall into a well. According to him, the original good nature of man gets hit by disappointments and difficulties like trees on mountain slopes being targeted by horrendous winds and he gives examples of once beautiful, now bedraggled trees of Niu Mountain.
"Mencius belonged to one of those philosophical schools and all these schools were competing among themselves for disciples and for the favour of rulers which would bring wealth, power and positionsMencius was therefore, in a position that he had to explain more clearly than Confucius why every man should strive to be a 'superior man'" Hwang (1979, p.205).
His arguments are termed as too idealistic, far from reality, far removed from real life happenings and he argues a kind of mysticism beyond comprehension and belief. He is also criticized that all people cannot be endowed with such superfluous goodness as he supposed. Funnily, in spite of criticism, Mencius' theory continued to exist and is quite relevant even today.


"Mencius, on the other hand, is more truly a mystic. Not only does he believe that a man can attain oneness with the universe by perfecting his own moral nature, but he has absolute faith in the moral purpose of the universe. His great achievement is that he not only successfully defended the teachings of Confucius against the corrosive influence of new ideas but, in the process, added to Confucianism a depth that it did not possess before," Lau (1970, p.46).


He stressed upon ethical predispositions of mind and heart. He argued that any budding evil could be controlled by self-reflection and self-cultivation. His ethical ideal was benevolence humaneness.


Xunzi lived towards the end of Warring States Period (453-221 BCE) and along with Mencius and Confucius, was one of the three main architects of Confucius school of Philosophy in China. This period saw great philosophical flowering in China that enveloped almost all spheres of life, society, politics, ruling, warfare, defense etc. He lived in a 'cutthroat' age and it is not surprising that his philosophy is based on human evil. He also felt the need of human education and moral training.

"Human nature is evil; what is good is artifice. Now, human nature is as follows. At birth there is fondness for profit in it. Following this, contention and robbery arise, and deference and courtesy are destroyed," Goldin (1999, p.6).


Xunzi was directly opposite to Mencius in assuming that human nature starts with evil and not with goodness. His thought clashes with that of Mencius on the fundamentals itself.

"But it flatly contradicts the view of Mencius, who taught that man is naturally inclined to goodness and in later centuries, when Mencius' view came to be regarded as the orthodox one, it led to an unhappy clouding of Hsun Tzu's entire system of thought," Watson (1967, p.5).


He thought man is prone to evil dispositions, and ethical rules of society are invented to prevent this natural process. His philosophy says that Man is naturally an evil, ...Show more

Summary

Mencius is called the second sage of Chinese philosophy. Those were the days when philosophical theories made great impact on people and good and evil form the basis of philosophy, sociology, religion, politics, law, psychology and culture of any society. China had adopted an ecological way of living, and people preferred to be peace-loving and kind…
Author : cummeratakane
Compare Mencius theory of Human Nature as Good with Xunzis Theory of Human Nature as Evil essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Compare Mencius theory of Human Nature as Good with Xunzis Theory of Human Nature as Evil"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Personal Theory of Psychology (Human Nature)
On the other hand, in accordance to the nurture view, ideas that define an individual are obtained through experiences and interactions. One of the supporters of the nurture view, British philosopher, John Locke, suggested that when a newborn infant is born, his mind is a tabula rasa, a Latin word for “blank slate” (Griffin, 2010).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Human Nature
For his everyday and lifetime realization of his dreams, a person must then choose his actions and reactions for his environment. Every action he takes or he misses to take will be a great deal for his future and a barricade for what he wishes to be. The idea that human beings have an inherent sense of right and wrong has been debated since the dawn of our species.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Evil And Angel Nature Of Human Being
The debate of evil and angel nature of human being is an ancient pondering. Different philosophical schools of thought have explicated their views in varied approaches. It is normally believed that human beings are created having good and bad characteristics at the same time.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Human nature
Yes, I agree with their believe that cruelty is part of human nature; however, I do not agree with their explanation that it is because subjects in the Milgram’s experiment acted as they did, and why none of the 38 people who witnessed and heard Kitty Genovese call for help did not respond to help or even call the police.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Human Nature
'Every human is indeed a slave of circumstances.' An honest man commits cruel or socially unacceptable acts mostly when situations compel him. Nobody steals things out of instinct or out of fashion. They do so for one fundamental reason that is they need it badly.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
The Essence of Human Nature and the Fight between Good and Evil
An understanding of Nietzsche's work relies on a solid grasp of his views on truth and language, his metaphysics and conception of the will to power. At the very bottom of Nietzsche's philosophy lies the conviction that the universe is in a constant state of change, and his hatred and disparagement of almost any position can be traced back to that position's temptation to look at the universe as fixed in one place.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
What was new about Darwin's theory of Human Nature
The transmutation of species was accepted by many scientists before 1859, but the publication of Charles Darwins On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection provided the first cogent theory for a mechanism by which evolutionary change could occur:
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Personal Theory of Psychology (Human Nature)
On the other hand, in accordance to the nurture view, ideas that define an individual are obtained through experiences and interactions. One of the supporters of the nurture view, British
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Human Nature
Using a landing force, they decide to cripple U.S. invasion fleet involving 1200 ships via attacks on the sea and in the air. William Manchester analysis the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Human Nature
The sole characteristics of what I tend to believe in the consists of human nature; I personally believe are part of what is making it improbable to determine if there exist any other
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation