Case Law Study in Ratio Decidendi

High school
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 10 (2510 words)
Download 0
The principle of Ratio Decidendi is very important in judgments and can make the difference between justice being dispensed and injustice being perpetrated. In the case of R v AS, a serious travesty of justice transpired and but for the timely and effective judgment of the Supreme Court of Queensland would have not been set aside.

Introduction


After this the type of effect that this case has on the Magistrates' Courts of Queensland is discussed and explained. Subsequently, the question of law that the court had to address is discussed, along with the reason as to how the Court reached its decision. After this the steps that the police could have taken in their investigation are discussed.
Finally, the far reaching results of this decision and the events of this case are discussed. Throughout the discussion relevant case law is discussed to elucidate the subject matter. In the case of R VS AS, in the early hours of the 10th of November 2001, a male person entered Ms W's residence in Lowood and made an attempt to rape her.
However, she was successful in repulsing his attacks and her attacker after punching her in the eye, escaped from that place. Ms W described her attacker as being a tall aboriginal wearing a yellow T shirt and pants which were of some heavy material like jeans.
Further, she stated that she had seen this person in the driveway of the flats and that she had been informed his name as being AS prior to being attacked. After being attacked she went to Ms D's premises for help.
Later on Jason Crowther the police sergeant arrived and he described the morning as being overcast with drizzling rain. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Contract Law. Case study.
A court of law usually enforces the contract as long the offeree proves that he posted the letter. A relevant case studied is that of:-…
law course (case study)
This puts Renault in a safe albeit embarrassing position. Nonetheless, Lyon's decision to sue Sherman for breach of contract may have some merit. On his part, Sherman could use the argument that he is not under any legal obligation to sell his business only to Lyon. He could strengthen his case if he has included the clause that the counteroffer is subject to cancellation by the present owner of…
business law case study
The nature of the transaction is dependent upon the agreement between the parties. A novation also takes place when the original parties continue their obligation to one another, but a new agreement is substituted for the old. In order for the novation to be legally binding and enforceable, it must be agreed between all the parties involved and must be in writing as required by law.…
Employment Law: Case Study
If all goes well and the individual is found suitable, the company makes an offer of employment explaining some of the requisite details. The worker is then supposed to go through the details and agree to it, before joining the work in the company. At times, it so happens that both the concerned parties agree to some kind of informal arrangement in the beginning, which needs to be formalised in…
Commercial Law case study
It did not lead Rein AJ to doubt the general veracity of the plaintiff.…
Property Law Case Study
It certainly is true that the legal owner has the sole right to dispose of any fixtures to another party. Nonetheless this is not the same thing as meaning that the 'purchaser' of kitchen cupboards obtained under a subsisting hire purchase agreement would also have the same rights, since whilst s/he might romantically think of the chattel as 'belonging to' him/her upon receipt of it, under English…
Case Law Study in Ratio Decidendi
After this the type of effect that this case has on the Magistrates' Courts of Queensland is discussed and explained. Subsequently, the question of law that the court had to address is discussed, along with the reason as to how the Court reached its decision. After this the steps that the police could have taken in their investigation are discussed.…