Philosophical View of "High Noon" Movie (Ethics) - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Philosophical View of "High Noon" Movie (Ethics)

The difference is that in deontology, an act may not be beneficial to most of the people. With these views, we construct a dichotomy with Kane on one side and the townsfolk on the other.
Ethically, we can view Kane’s insistence on staying through the lenses of deontology. He chose to stay because he considered it fit and proper to do what is right and that is to make sure that the criminal does not harm anybody. This he did even though he was not the Marshal anymore. One can argue that Kane was actually motivated by self preservation because he feared that Miller would pursue him and his wife unrelentingly. Therefore, he was not motivated by doing what is right as a civil officer but was forced to do so to save his own life. However, he could have run off and left the town under the mercy of a gun wielding crazy criminal but he did not. He chose to stand by his code of honor which is to protect the citizenry. Furthermore, the doctrine of deontology states that happiness is not the goal. For certain, Kane’s goal was not happiness for death was the only prospect facing him with a gun fight with four seasoned gunslingers. Knowing death is inevitable and still having the right intentions characterized Kane’s actions.
For the townsfolk part, we see their decision of not supporting Kane as characteristic of utilitarianism especially in the reasons they forwarded for not doing so. This was especially true in the Church scene where Kane did not get any support because they consider it bad for the development’s of the town’s economy. A gun battle would make the town look uncivilized and unfit for commercial trading. If they just boot Kane out of the town then they can avoid such an event from happening thereby ensuring prosperity for the town. One can see the act of townsfolk as a way of avoiding retribution from Miller’s gang. If they support Kane ...
Download paper

Summary

In the High Noon movie, we witness how Will Kane is abandoned by the townsfolk as Frank Miller – a criminal he sent to jail – returns to town to get revenge. In spite of the great deeds that Kane had done for the people, he finds nobody to support him in the face off with a…
Author : elmer02

Related Essays

Philosophical Theories
Effects of acupuncture would not be explained through traditional medical models and patients have experienced stress reduction by using acupuncture. The physiological effects of acupuncture can also be theoretically supported with evidence and in this essay I would argue which model of philosophy best fits in with our own belief systems and how this claim could be justified or established....
6 pages (1506 words) Thesis
Philosophical Studies
Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy whose primary focus is to respond to the enquiry 'What is there' In a collection of his works, the most detailed treatise on the general topic of things ta phusika (from which English derives 'physics'). Since the Greek for 'after' is meta, this treatise is titled 'Metaphysics'. The metaphysics takes into account the material as well as immaterial objects like, property, subject, change, being essentially or accidentally....
4 pages (1004 words) Article
Philosophical Analogy
While Plato was Aristotle's mentor, Foucault was once Derrida's teacher. Derrida and Foucault are both French philosophers who are part of 20th-Century-Western Philosophy. As would be expected, the latter philosophers would have a considerable amount of study on the works or references of the earlier theorists. Derrida's work Plato's Pharmacy is an attack to Plato's famous work Phaedrus. While Foucault counters Aristotle's "enduring substances" with his claim that everything is "historically contingent"....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Kierkegaards Philosophical Viewpoints on Ethics and Critics of his Work
The aim of this paper is to divulge into Ethics and provide more information on a chosen philosopher of this field of philosophy. For the purpose of this paper was chosen Soren Kierkegaard. Danish born he firmly supported the involvement of religion in philosophy. His ideas are progressively developed and critics, among which Hegel and the Romantics, of his ideas are laid out....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Business Ethics High School Essay
The greatest intellectual strength is the inclusion of arguments made against their own point. If the authors had failed to include opposing arguments, their article would have been very one-sided and un-credible. It is important for readers to understand both sides of an argument before understanding which side is right or wrong (if there are, in fact, objectively right and wrong sides). This strength of the article, however, also proved to be somewhat of a weakness, because some of the opposing arguments were left unchallenged by the authors....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Philosophical Ethics - Utilitarianism.
There are drawbacks to seeing things from Mill’s perspective, first of all because Mill lived in a society which was much different and much less global than today’s society. Secondly, there are problems in equating society at the beginning of the industrial revolution, in terms of quality and safety of the workplace. So, many of the early uses of the philosophy have been supplanted by new uses, in which authors like Bentham expand definitions of utility, in two basically positivist representations of utilitarianism by these authors....
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!