Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Should society recognize animal rights, even to the extent of disallowing the use of animals in scientific and medical experiments? - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : legrosfelicita

Summary

These animals are being used to develop vaccines for AIDS, malaria and other disorders. The article discusses a report sponsored by the…

Extract of sample
Should society recognize animal rights, even to the extent of disallowing the use of animals in scientific and medical experiments?

The comment on this report concludes that to some extent there may be grounds to support the argument for the use of monkeys in medical research, however no blanket decisions can be made because each case must be evaluated individually to assess the beneficial effect of the medicine as opposed to the harm caused to the animals.
Evidence that is provided in this article includes figures on number of animals used in medical experiments, as well as the percentages of animals used in toxicology studies. It also provides information on the development of vaccines, as well as providing evidence of other methods that may be used for the same purpose that does not involve the use of animals. The article also provides evidence on cell and molecular biology, in-silico technology, computer modeling, microdosing and the use of transgenic mice.
The author of this report is David Weatherall. Although this author has commented on and explained the contents of a report that was sponsored by the Medical Council, he is himself the Chairman of the working group which actually produced and prepared the report on the use of non human primates in research, which was sponsored by the Medical Council. The author has clarified that the comments he has made are not necessarily those that reflect the view of the report’s sponsors.
The Report which is the subject of this article was published by the Wellcome Trust and the Academy of Medical Sciences, however this particular report on the article was published in the Lancet, a reputed newspaper. Therefore, this is a report published by a reputed publisher and sponsored by a reputed body.
This report is very timely in the context of the controversies that have been raging over the use of animals for purposes of scientific and medical research. The report has also undertaken a comprehensive analysis of the various methods ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Should Society recognize animal rights, even to the extent of disallowing the use of animals in scientific and medical experiments?
But in the context of pain suffered by animals, Gallistel (1989) has advocated the unrestricted use of animals for research purposes, especially in the study of the nervous system. He points out that studies on the nervous system may involve the destruction or stimulation of a part of the system to examine the ramifications of use of certain drugs and could cause pain and temporary distress to the animals used. He argues that restricting research on animals would restrict the progress in human understanding of the nervous system. It would interfere with the process of providing a moral and…
4 pages (1004 words)
Animal Rights
In simple words Animal Equality urges people to stop using animals to fulfill their own needs and wants. Speciesism here refers to a form of discrimination which is used against species which are non-human. Animal Equality tries to urge people to stop exploiting animals by making them aware about the concepts of Speciesism. Similarly Veganism is a concept of urging people to consume a diet which is more associated to plants and does not in any way exploit animals. Both these concepts together are the basis for this organization in providing the animals with their rights.…
1 pages (251 words)
Animal Rights
While, because of its many practical and historical considerations, it is difficult to take “sides” in this argument. As a matter of ethical stance the argument of Regan and Singer presents a clearer more definitive philosophical/ethical case, while Baxter’s hyper-utilitarian defense rings arrogant, unethical, and morally bankrupt.…
3 pages (753 words)
Animal Rights
Therefore, these animals’ purpose is for the nourishment of human beings. However, even if these animals are to be slain to serve as food, those who do the slaughtering must also take necessary measures so that these animals’ lives are taken at the most minimal pain possible. Perhaps it would be prudent to emphasize that this should be done only for animals that were actually raised for the purpose of being consumed. Therefore, our moral code and ethics dictate that animals that were not raised to become food should, consequently, not be consumed.…
1 pages (251 words)
Animal Rights versus Animal Welfare
The difference between animal right and animal welfare is the principles followed by the two groups. Animal rights reject the use of animals while animal welfare groups allow animal use but humane treatment should be accorded tot them. When human and animal rights conflict, animal rights activist prioritize the rights of animals, while animal welfare activists prioritize human life. Animal welfare promotes controlled use of animals for agricultural purposes such as farming and protein production while animal right activists avoid the use of animal products (Guither 203).…
2 pages (502 words)
Animal rights in islam - Animal Law
Animals should not be exploited under any circumstances1. Whether animals can talk or whether they can reason cannot be a matter of consideration, because animals have equal capacity like human beings to feel pain, sorrow, love, frustration, fear and pleasure. As human beings, people have the moral obligation to think twice before engaging in any sort of activities that will damage the environment and basic needs of animals2. People who support the rights of animals believe that animals have worth that is inherent and it is completely separate from their usefulness and service to human beings.…
36 pages (9036 words)
Animal Rights
Studies suggest that, in the last century or so, almost every medical breakthrough that is relevant to both the animal and human world has had significant contributions from animal research. Such breakthroughs range from antibiotics, chemotherapy, blood transfusions, and organ transplants among others (Jessen). These experiments have contributed significantly towards the quality and length of human life by handling some of the most difficult moments in human life known as disease and health conditions and complications. The above is due to the potential use of animal research in treating heart…
8 pages (2008 words)