StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Baseball as a Protected Business: Antitrust Law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the paper "Baseball as a Protected Business: Antitrust Law" tells, scandals like steroids come and go and the national pastime tends to prevail.  Why does the national pastime prevail, unchallenged and financially secure, despite changes in national opinions and popular trends?  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Baseball as a Protected Business: Antitrust Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Baseball as a Protected Business: Antitrust Law"

One reason, the focus of my speech today, is the special protection that baseball (Major League Baseball) has been afforded by Congress.  This protection comes in the form of antitrust law and, to a significant extent, insulates owners and other interested stakeholders from competition within the baseball industry. 

            As an initial matter, it is important to define what is meant by antitrust law, a topic frequently foreign to baseball aficionados.  Antitrust law is an umbrella designation that includes a number of laws dealing with the fair competition; more specifically, because America deems itself a free market capitalist economy, there exist a number of laws designed to prevent such things as monopolies and unfair methods of competition.  Strangely enough, baseball has for quite some time been exempt from a number of antitrust laws.  As stated by Bartee, “professional sports are a textbook example of a bilateral cartel made up of club owners and unionized players engaged in intrastate and interstate commerce. The club owners exercise monopoly power in the product market” (2008: n.p.).  Baseball, like steel or agriculture in certain respects, is a protected industry.  It is not a monopoly per se but a competitive cartel in which owners compete with the unionized players.  We read all of the time about competition between owners and players.  There are disagreements about such things as free agency, salary caps, and collective bargaining agreements.  The irony is that while the owners and the players often trade accusations about the other using unfair methods or misleading financial formulas the truth is that both reap the rewards of a non-competitive industry because of the antitrust exemption granted to Major League Baseball by the United States Congress.  In addition, in a 1972 case called Kuhn v. Flood and decided by the United States Supreme Court, it was also decided that “baseball and its reserve system are also exempt from state antitrust laws. The exemption was therefore not only left intact, it was again extended” (Bartee, 2008: n.p.).  Baseball, in short, is exempt from both federal and state antitrust laws and therefore entitled to behave as a cartel. 

            Interestingly, other professional sports have not been granted an antitrust exemption.  Neither the National Football League nor the National Basketball Association benefits as a protected industry under American antitrust law.  For this reason, competition is more severe and threatening in financial terms.  There have, for example, been many threats to the National Football League whereas Major League Baseball remains secure.  There is a Canadian Football League, and an Arena Football League, and a couple of decades ago Donald Trump and other wealthy investors started a professional football league to challenge the National Football League.  Trump’s league was even successful in stealing top draft picks, such as Steve Young and Hershel Walker, from the National Football League.  Baseball faces no such threats because its antitrust exemption allows the owners to control the product and the players’ union to bargain as the sole representative of the players.  Entry into the market is virtually impossible without the cartel’s approval. 

            In the final analysis, baseball has long been the national pastime and, for the most part, a profitable business enterprise for owners, and more recently, for players.  It would be wrong, however, to view baseball’s successes as the product of astute business acumen or a superior product; to be sure, the product is excellent, but it is also protected and insulated from competition in substantial ways.  What might happen to Major League Baseball if its exemptions from federal and state antitrust laws were rescinded?  Perhaps the league would splinter, perhaps competitors would arise, and perhaps baseball as we have come to know it would cease to exist.  Perhaps, given that baseball is our national pastime, it is fair to grant the exemptions.  Perhaps.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Information Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Information Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547881-information
(Information Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Information Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547881-information.
“Information Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547881-information.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Baseball as a Protected Business: Antitrust Law

NBA Lockout: Public Argument

The author of the "NBA Lockout: Public Argument" paper analyzes the lockout situation with the three stakeholders, the owners, players, and the local community, applies the six principles in Freeman's doctrine, and finds that all of them have been violated.... ... ... ... The players on the other end wanted to decertify the union which also changes the process of the negations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

William A. Shea and His Impact on New York

Shea was a renowned American attorney who partnered in a famous law firm, Shea & Gould.... Shea was a renowned American attorney who partnered in a famous law firm, Shea & Gould.... While in New York University, Georgetown University and Harvard law School, Shea had a huge interest in Basketball and was a team member in these institutions.... Shea graduated from the Harvard law school and worked for insurance bureaucracies after which he entered into private practice....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Contemporary recreation, sports, or tourism legal issue

There exists variation as to the way the law is defined.... One school of thought holds the view that law is a congregation of regulations and rules that govern a particular action. ... There exists variation as to the way the law is defined, one school of thought hold the view that a law is a congregation of regulations and rules that govern a particular action.... port law refers to the application of existing laws to recreation and sports....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

International Marketing: industry

In this case, Japanese owners would avoid possible problems and antitrust legislation followed by Major League Baseball.... On the hand, economists underline that: "the owners are like the keiretsu that once lorded over the business landscape: They have grown too cozy with one another to operate efficiently" (Japanese Baseball, 2006).... Every industry including baseball market needs strategy to compete on the global scale.... baseball market is one of the most popular leisure and sports segment in the USA and Japan. ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Basic Economics - Prices and Markets

The author of the paper "Basic Economics - Prices and Markets" outlines that a decision can be economic even if there is no money involved.... Economics is a way of making the most out of an option that has been presented to us in life.... It involves allocating time and resources efficiently.... ...
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Effectiveness of Copyright Law in Modern Internet Age

In this paper, 'Effectiveness of Copyright law in Modern Internet Age' the author discussed the effectiveness of copyright law preventing infringement in piracy in a modern internet age.... As with the increasing use of the internet, the issue of copyright infringement has also become a major issue of the era....
40 Pages (10000 words) Dissertation

William A. Shea and His Impact on New York

hile at New York University, Georgetown University, and Harvard law School, Shea had a huge interest in Basketball and was a team member in these institutions.... Shea graduated from the Harvard law school and worked for insurance bureaucracies after which he entered into private practice.... These ties enabled him to build Shea & Gould, which is New York's most influential and largest law firm.... The most outstanding contribution that Shea made to New York was restoring the baseball league after the departure of two teams, the Giants and the Dodgers to California....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Why the NCAA Should Be Taxed

The NCAA advertising, merchandising and television programs' revenues must, therefore, be considered without reasonable doubt as unrelated business taxable income since they consist of income from business and trade that is not substantially related to NCAA's performance of its functions and mandate as the charitable organization....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us