Stories that make the reader sympathize with a crazy person are few, and fewer still are stories that are told from the point of view of the crazy person – the crazy person being the narrator; William Faulkner’s “A rose for Emily”, and Edgar Allan Poe’s “A tell-tale…
Miss Emily Grierson of Faulkner’s tale belonged to a once rich family, but her mansion is now old and decayed through time and neglect (perhaps because she is too poor to spend money on it?). Maybe once there were people who came to visit, but now with Miss Grierson, or Miss Emily as she is referred to in the tale, turning into a recluse, there is nobody who goes inside the house, except for her Negro servant Tobe. We see in the beginning of the story how curious everyone is to see what is inside her house when they enter it at her funeral.
Poe adds more mystery to his story by telling it through the crazed person, thereby ensuring that we never find out where exactly he lives, though we do get a feel of the house, and since most of the story happens after night has fallen, we are left with a sense of dark and mysterious surroundings.
The violent and macabre occurrences in the stories are accompanied by a sense of a similar kind not only through the personalities of the protagonists, but via the ambiance or settings as well. That is to say not only did the stories hold a sense of mystery because of the complex central characters, but the dark and desolate environment of the houses where they took place also added to the Gothic effect that the writers were trying to create.
It will not be remiss to say that the settings mirrored the lead characters of the tales. Miss Emily’s house, like her, was an unchanging symbol in changed times. It had been constructed when the family was rich, so it had an allusion to grandeur, albeit there were no riches to keep it in its pristine condition. So with changing times the neighborhood did not remain noble or “august” anymore and the area was taken over by garages and cotton gins, however, Miss Emily refused to give her house up; it remained, as Faulkner puts it, “an eyesore among eyesores.” Murky, dusty and decayed, just like ...
Cite this document
(“The Tell-Tale Heart and A Rose for Emily, gothic but with a twist Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/miscellaneous/385951-the-tell-tale-heart-and-a-rose-for-emily-gothic-but-with-a-twist
(The Tell-Tale Heart and A Rose for Emily, Gothic But With a Twist Essay - 1)
“The Tell-Tale Heart and A Rose for Emily, Gothic But With a Twist Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/miscellaneous/385951-the-tell-tale-heart-and-a-rose-for-emily-gothic-but-with-a-twist.
Throughout this narrative, using a first person, the narrator tries to convince the reader that he is not insane or mad; indeed, he feels that it takes a lot of skill and cunning, to commit a murder. The story starts in a location that remains undisclosed to the reader, which one can assume to be possibly a prison or even a mental home.
The narrator seems insane due to the fact that every man on earth has the inner struggle about right and wrong acts. He, on the other hand, pictured this moralist of his inside as a real man of flash and blood which actually manifested him to weight his capabilities which were no less than any average man of intellect.
In the story ‘The tell tale heart’ he has integrated his views regarding the functioning of human brain and how the thought processes work together. The narrator of the story is depicted as an insane man who cannot control his inner thoughts and manifests his inner struggles as a real man.
The Tell-Tale Heart,” is one of Edger Allan Poe’s well known short stories and was first published in January, 1843. The short story is a psychological portrait. It is narrated by a mad man who commits homicide. It is a horror story, and a psychological thriller, which is presented in a native style.
In the tale, Poe uses suspense to make the narration interesting. In his descriptions, Poe uses simple language to describe characters in his story. The characters of the story have scary features, but the writer uses suspense and other literal stylistic devices such repetition and figurative language to paint his characters.
The narrator in Edgar Allan Poe's short story "The Tell-Tale Heart" reveals absolutely no interest in proving his innocence of the murder of the old man, but rather is obsessed with proving his sanity. Every aspect of the story he relates about how he came to commit heinous murder fulfills the traditional literary definition of irony because while the intent is to prove his sanity what he ultimately accomplishes is proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that he is clearly insane.
e, in the two stories “A Rose For Emily” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”, the settings, if not completely Gothic in appearance, are not wanting in the Gothic-ism of their effect on the characters.
Faulkner set his short story “A Rose For Emily”
Setting is the most characteristic element of the Gothic fiction which normally includes dusty halls, shadowy landscapes, and whispering people and the stories by Poe illustrate the significance of setting as a Gothic element. For example, Poe begins with an
Poe’s story is a profound and a timeline story that is ambiguously investigating the paranoia of a certain man. The intensity of the story is well developed on the manner the narrator portrays and talks about his victim. Poe portrays his main
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic The Tell-Tale Heart and A Rose for Emily, gothic but with a twist for FREE!