StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Is the ICC dangerous to democracy and doomed to fail - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Is the ICC dangerous to democracy and doomed to fail

One of the controversial issues, however, in regard to the existence of ICC is that it threatens democracy, the given reason why the United States withdrew its signature in the Rome Statute in December 2000.
The United States is highly suspicious of multilateral agreements and that the mandate of the ICC further heightened this uncertainty. With the provisions contained therein, ICC would have jurisdiction over American citizens and try them according to the international law, drafted according to a collaboration of international legal principles. This is seen as dangerous because the American jurisprudence is at significant points highly divergent with the ICC’s. For instance, protections that are considered core requirements for a fair trial in the United States are greatly diluted or absent entirely. According to Carpenter (2002), instead of having a right to trial by an impartial jury, a defendant faces the prospect of trial by a panel of judges appointed by majority vote of member-states and could come from countries where there is no concept of independent jury or from a regime hostile to his or her government. (p. 197)
In addition to the above factor, there is also the fact that some statutes that would govern the ICC are overly broad. Consider these examples: there is the genocide definition that covers offenses relating to the commission of serious “mental harm” to members of any national, racial, ethnic or religious group; then, war crimes would include committing outrages upon personal dignity, in particular humiliating or degrading treatment. (p. 197) With the seriousness of the crimes in question, it is a legitimate argument to say that the broadness of definitions and provisions may be wittingly or unwittingly interpreted differently than what was intended or taken advantage with. There is just a lot of room for a ...Show more


Through the Rome Statute drafted and signed in 1998, states have created a world body and empowered international jurists and prosecutors to assess criminal culpability and, henceforth, punish guilty offenders. The International Criminal Court (ICC), which has evolved from the…
Author : jlegros
Is the ICC dangerous to democracy and doomed to fail essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Is the ICC dangerous to democracy and doomed to fail"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Gender and development projects which focus only on women are doomed to fail
We will discuss a few development projects actually designed and implemented in Latin America. For this purpose we will take the example of the projects conducted by World Bank
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
The word “democracy” may categorically be considered a universal word just like the word “love” which is used in different contexts. To cite some examples, “Mussolini claimed that his Italian Facism is a realization of a “true democracy”; Nazis, speaking through Herr Goebbels, presented the National socialist state as the “most ennobled form of a modern democratic state and finally, not to forget Stalin announced that the Soviet Constitution of 1936 is the only constitution democratic to the limit” (Lewis, p.467 ).
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Democracy The word ‘Democracy’ is derived from the two Greek words ‘Demos’ and ‘Kratos’ which mean ‘People’ and ‘Rule’ respectively. So, it can be described as the rule of the people. According to Sir John Seeley, democracy can be defined as “a government in which everyone has a share”.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Simmel's Stranger and ICC
The concepts used in this marvelous piece of writing have been the chief source of deriving the complex synthesis and implementation of intercultural communication. The major focus will be on effective communication. Introduction “Intercultural communication” is a diverse topic of in-depth research which gained its significance during 1960s and has been a major subject matter of different fields of study like Philosophy, Sociology, Anthropology, Economics and various other branches of social sciences (Scollon, Scollon and Jones, 2012, p.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
In America, democracy comes from status Vivendi where the people are more superior to the government while in Russia democracy stems from the understanding that people identify with both the government and its sovereignty. In America, democracy helps the citizens constantly analyze the reaction of the government towards its people.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Robert Dahl, arguably the most influential American political scientist of the 20th century reckons that democracy is a utopian concept that is not found anywhere in contemporary geo-politics. In its stead, leading industrial societies of the world, including the United States have a ‘Plutocracy’, where power is shared and wielded by various major public institutions.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Now they can leave home and be independent. These new independents may apply for a job and do what they had long wanted to do and buy what they had wanted to buy because their parents forbade them not to do or buy before. Democracy can also be defined as the right to vote in any organization.
18 pages (4500 words) Essay
Using examples from AT LEAST (a) TWO organisations OR (b) TWO projects run by one large organisation (e.g. World Bank), write an essay on the following: 'Gender and development projects which focus exclusively on women are doomed to fail'
In this paper we will start with the theoretical approaches regarding women and development. Various gender and development projects especially those directed only towards women will also be discussed. We will restrict our study to Latin America only. We
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Lord Bryce states that democracy is “the form of government in which the ruling power is vested not in a particular class but in all the persons of a state”. Abraham Lincoln defined it as “democracy is the government of the people, by the people and
3 pages (750 words) Essay
The limitations of democracy are common, but its benefits can be attained in the end. American legal system and laws are increasingly defective. Democracy principle bends towards the benefit of the wider society. Democracy’s inadequate skill is not detrimental, however, as the errors are correctable.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment