Studentshare
Subjects
Miscellaneous
Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution

Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution - Research Paper Example

Summary

It limited the power of the government over the people (Cluskey, 186). Currently, present-day courts in America are debating the “Original meaning of the…

Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful

Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution

Read Text Preview

Subject: Miscellaneous
Type: Research Paper
Level: College
Pages: 4 (1000 words)
Downloads: 4
Author: alvenasipes

Extract of sample "Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution"

Download file to see previous pages

urt Justice Antonin Scalia did not agreed with the idea of changing the interpretation, while Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer wants it to change. The constitution should not be interfered with because it is the founding document of the United States. The Founding Fathers originally made the document for government and believed over time that the world will change, also the nation was built on and the foundation the U.S stands strong on. This paper will argue that Justice Breyer is correct.

The Founding Fathers wrote a flexible document that would grow over the centuries. The U.S constitution was put together by several men—framers such as Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Paine and John Adams. However, James Madison was known to be the father of the constitution because he wrote the constitution in 1778. Madison believed that a consitution should have a fixed and stable meaning. He believed that the time in which this constitution was created was special and that in the future people should reference it when interpreting the laws (Sunstein, 1).

In todays world thinking about the constitution has changed in some respects (although there are still people who agree with Madison). According to the Supreme Court Justice Stephen, “in finding the meaning of the constitution, judges cannot neglect to consider the probable consequences of different interpretations.” (Breyer, 74) Scientifically we do not have the technology go back in time and ask our Founding Fathers what exactly they meant word for word about the constitution. We do understand why they wrote it that way, so that people in our society can have a better life.

Breyer makes his case very intelligently. He says, "The court should reject approaches to interpreting the Constitution that consider the documents scope and application as fixed at the moment of framing . . . Rather, the court should regard the Constitution as containing unwavering values that must be applied flexibly to ever-changing

...Download file to see next pages Read More

Cite this document

APA
MLA
CHICAGO

(“Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution Research Paper”, n.d.)
Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572849-should-the-courts-see-the-original-meaning-of-the-constitution

(Should the Courts See the Original Meaning of the Constitution Research Paper)
Should the Courts See the Original Meaning of the Constitution Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572849-should-the-courts-see-the-original-meaning-of-the-constitution.

“Should the Courts See the Original Meaning of the Constitution Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572849-should-the-courts-see-the-original-meaning-of-the-constitution.

Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the courts see the original meaning of the constitution

Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent

Justice Scalia Antonin insists that Original intent determines the meaning of the constitution.... Theoretical debates on the adjudication of the constitution have been there for a long time.... Originalists say that reading strictly of any text can only be found by giving an interpretation of the constitution by using the original intent of that particular constitution.... This means that Scalia's originalist method is more of statutory interpretation of the text than the living interpretation of the constitution....

4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Conflict between the Legislative and Judicial Branches

This power, known as judicial review, enables the Court to invalidate both federal and state laws when they conflict with its interpretation of the constitution.... "Applying the plain meaning of the text furthers important rule of law values, such as predictability, certainty, and objectivity.... The Court decides if a law or government action violates the constitution.... 3 Overrides usually occur when the meaning of a text is skewed and it was misinterpreted by the Court or not ruled on fairly....

6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Legal Concepts Worksheet

Criminal and CivilSources of law - the courts, the statutes and caselawLegal sanctionsFor criminal conduct - jail time, a penalty or probationFor tortious conduct - monetary finesOrganization of the court systemState courts - each state has its own laws which apply to the state only.... constitution, Article I, Section 8.... constitution, Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3.... constitution and granted by law for original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium of expression....

2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Law of International Dispute Resolution

he role of the European Court of Justice in developing the legal means for the integration process and constructing a constitution from the Treaty of Rome... y considering the fact that supremacy is ultimately perceived throughout national courts to be a monolithic holy concept which bears tremendous implications if removed or limited, the question is then raised as to how Member States receive the 'supreme nature' of Community Law.... Furthermore, I will observe the Constitutionalisation of the Treaty system, looking at the interplay of the doctrine of direct effect and doctrine of supremacy; under what conditions Member States might be provoked to challenge the authority of the ECJ; the expanding competence of the ECJ which now includes a political and judicial interplay of decision-making; and conclude with a look at what the Constitutional Treaty would have signified in terms of legalizing the doctrine of supremacy and how the rejection has started questioning whether the Community law should be considered above and beyond national laws and if it has gone too far already....

15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Criminal Justice Process

These unconstitutional laws are laws that are contrary to the constitution.... the constitution is perceived as the most important law of a country.... Some of the unconstitutional laws claim that the constitution violates stipulations in the bill of rights.... … According to the report The criminal justice system comprises of three major components that work together to see the criminal justice process throughout the beginning to end....

8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Amending and Revising the Constitution

The paper "Amending and Revising the Constitution" discusses that marriage should not be restricted to some sexual orientations but instead spare space for all, and while changes to the provisions of the constitution remain inventible, modifications should not have implications on rights.... he author points out the failure of the constitution to define the terms 'amendment' and 'revision', an element that frustrates lawmakers in decision-making.... hellip; The author did well to urge the reader to see the need of having the best approach to use in changing the provisions offered by the constitution....

6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Search and Seizures Under the Fourth Amendment of the US

It's hardly arguable that the framers of the constitution cherished liberty more than security.... 155) The past generation though has witnessed an erosion of the liberties found within the Fourth Amendment as well as other aspects of the constitution.... The paper "Search and Seizures Under the Fourth Amendment of the US" states that the Fourth Amendment was inserted into the constitution so that no citizen would be subject to unreasonable searches of their person, property or papers without showing cause that a crime was being committed....

7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The American State Court System: History and Organization

Prior to the Revolutionary War— actually, prior to the constitution of the United States being ratified in 1789—state law administration and enforcement were as diverse as the character of the people who settled the colonies.... the constitution of the United States was formally ratified in 1789 and brought with it a very different set of considerations upon which to found the notions of justice and judicial procedure.... Despite the fact that many modern Americans tend to see the Supreme Court as the primary emblem of the nation's judicial system, that “Court is only one tribunal among many and both lower federal courts and state courts contribute significantly to the operation of our federal system…[as they] perform the painstaking tasks necessary to the day-by-day adjustment of federal-state judicial relations (Wendell, 1949, p....

7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment