Carriage Trade Medicine - Case Study Example

What kind of information search did Charlotte engage in? Were there information sources she might have used but didn’t?Answer: After a thorough study of available health care options, she comes close to engage one out of the doctor's Smith, Jones, Williams, and Connors in line with the criterion mentioned in Table-A. In spite of that, she could not decide which option she should adopt best suited for her health care. The reason being she developed her mind to allocate 100 points as per the criteria at the cited table but could get only 45 points out of it.

She can have HMO affiliation or state-owned health care facilities being cheaper as compared to the other available options. In fact, she wanted to have two things a) best medical facilities b) best doctors to treat her. The mentioned two can be available provided her wallet-size permits her to do so which is not possible due to her low income. In my opinion, she should go to state-sponsored medical facilities. She considered and reconsidered the options available which include free health care state plan wherein all contributions covered by the state, contrary to that HMO required monthly contribution from Charlotte, Plan ‘A’ requires a monthly contribution of 32.

75 USD, and Plan ‘B’ requires 41.05 USD. After a thorough study of the available health care options, she comes close to Plan ‘B’. In spite of that, she could not decide which option she should adopt best suited to her health care.Q.3: Should Charlotte use a compensatory or non-compensatory decision rule in this situation. Support your answer?Answer: Yes, Charlotte should opt for the compensatory decision rule-keeping in mind the manifold expenses on this count. She has no other choice but to rely on those plans which she can afford and get the best available medical facilities.

The health care facilities in America put American citizens into different buckets in terms of their capacity to pay. The quality and quantity are something they have to look upon keeping in mind their wallet size. It is quite natural that if someone wants to see the specialist for his / her treatment he/she has to bear the expenses of quality health care facilities. It is crystal clear that available health care facilities in the US vary from patient to patient keeping his / her absorbing capacity.Q.4: What doctor will she choose if she uses lexicographic rule, a conjunctive rule ( use cutoffs of 7 for recommendations, 6 for locations and office hours) Think carefully about how to handle yes / no answers.

What would you do with those? Answer: As far as the ratings of Table-A and the conjunctive rule is concerned she would decide in favor of Doctor Smith. There cannot be two opinions that by selecting the mentioned doctor for her treatment she would get the best medical facilities in hand. There is an adage that “to gain something you have to lose something” She would select a state-sponsored health care plan or HMO affiliation being somewhat at par in terms of medical facilities that are cheap and affordable as compared to other plans for her health care once she takes into account other factors that are in the way.

She has to consider beforehand if opts for HMO affiliation, location of the facilities, convenient hours (when she off the hook from office works), lab facilities, and x-rays. The other way round, it would cost her more which she can’t afford after meeting other necessities of life. Q.5: If Charlotte uses a compensatory model, which doctor would she choose?Answer: Charlotte would choose Dr. Smith for her treatment being manifold facilities available under the compensatory model. The selection of Dr.

Williams is due to multiple benefits i.e. location, office hours, services, and the Plan-B as evident in the chart ‘A’ for “Evaluation of Doctors”.