Legal Status in USA for Illegal Immigrants - Essay Example

Hinojosa argues that the act was responsible for the later economic progress, of these immigrants, and the overall economy. In this sense, they could seek for better jobs, establish businesses, and improve their communities. Eventually, this contributed to the health of the USA’s economy. It is vital to note that the author critiqued the lack of flexibility of the reform act as regards the control of immigration.

The second article argues that illegal immigrants should not attain legal status in particular countries. He states that the USA can attain lessons from Europe in terms of granting amnesty to illegal immigrants. Paul Belien, the author, argues that several European countries accorded legal status to illegal immigrants in the 2000s. Countries, such as Italy and France, opened the floodgates for more immigrants that became unmanageable. This is because many undiscovered immigrants showed up for certification.

In the analysis of Hinojosa's article, he must provide three perspectives to the same. The first two arguments support the authors’ view of providing legal status to immigrants. The third article highlights the loophole of the IRCA Act of 1987. The first argument highlights that legalized immigrants progress more economically. It is vital to note that the paper provided statistics, from the labor department, to prop this position. The hourly wages of legal immigrants had increased at an average rate of 15.1 percent from 1987 to 1992 (Hinojosa-Ojeda 2). In the same period, the female immigrants had improved their wages at a rate of 20.5 percent. On the other hand, there had been an increase of 13.2 percent. These statistics correlated with the fact that a percentage of 38, of Mexican men, had adjusted to better-paying occupations.

The paper argues that this translates to economic progress because the immigrants possess better bargaining powers (Belien 22). However, it only stresses the economic benefits such as businesses, income, and houses. This contributes to overall economic progress in terms of tax revenues for the government. It is crucial to note that the paper is comprehensive in noting that the IRCA Act did not provide policies for managing uncontrolled immigration.

In the analysis of Paul Bisien’s article, it is vital to note that he provides examples for his case. It is vital to note that the paper entails a significant history that exemplifies the hurdles of allowing immigrants into countries. The Western Europe has granted legal status to five million immigrants. She was a minister of Justice in the Dutch government. The country confirmed that she had attained her status under fraud circumstances. She had attained political asylum on the pretext of having fled Somalia. In this sense, Holland moved to tighten its immigration policy after it discovered the danger of according to legal status to illegal immigrants. Read More