Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

a critical response paper. - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : robertolynch

Summary

Swift, in 1729, wrote a satirical essay titled A Modest Proposal. He described ways to control the poor population by selling children from poor families to landlord and rich families who can then cook up these children and serve to the guests. He gave numerous benefits for…

Extract of sample
a critical response paper.

Mr. Swift felt deeply for the poor people of Ireland and did not like to see them in the professionally poor conditions that they had come to be in. He wished they would learn better ways to live their lives and this was the main focus of this proposal. Mr. Swift chose a satire to get his point across which according to the age must have been quite a shock to the people.
The writer gave a proposal and then supported it by giving a long list of arguments. As we read through the first impression is of disgust, but on and on we realize a write up which hits on the kingdom which is very irresponsible of its poor populations’ fate. A look into Mr. Swift’s life and we see a shining light. Mr. Swift lived in Ireland, which “was a poor country and was deliberately kept poor by England. It was overpopulated and desperately poor, heavily taxed, with no say in its own affairs. English absentee landlords owned most of the Irish land and crippled its infrastructure deliberately so that there would be no threat from the country” (Cody). Seeing the predicament Mr. Swift was angry and frustrated. His anger at the ‘owners’ of Ireland is evident when he says, “the remaining hundred thousand may at a year old be offered in sale to the persons of quality and fortune through the kingdom, always advising the mother to let them suck plentifully in the last month, so as to render them plump and fat for a good table. A child will make two dishes at an entertainment for friends; and when the family dines alone, the fore or hind quarter will make a reasonable dish, and seasoned with a little pepper or salt will be very good boiled on the fourth day, especially in winter” (Swift).
The writer seemed to make very irrational statements. The very essence of the ‘modesty’ of the article is the irrationality of the prolific use of the positive outcomes of a single event that will cause the poor to prosper. Mr. Swift succeeded ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Critical Response paper
No male dictator in history has ever had that much control. Women have been suppressed, but still contributed to the history of the whole human race. The history of women is very important, because this history has not only shaped women of today, but also the men.…
2 pages (502 words)
critical response paper
She later moved to Edmonton to work with abused children and teens in the child welfare system.…
2 pages (502 words)
critical response paper:"charlotte's web"
One of the solutions to this are different types of characters. Throughout all cultures, characters exist. There are many ways we come to know characters. Sometimes from how they describe themselves, how they appear, sometimes from how others describe them or treat them. In Charlottes Web two characters that contrast well and bring out a great deal of each others qualities are Wilbur, the pig, and Templeton, the rat.…
2 pages (502 words)
Complete the Critical Response Paper
The rule of the majority is indeed the very premise of democracy and this is the reason why it is successful. The different kinds of democracy are representative and direct. Direct democracy deals with a political system where citizens can have their say through voting in public affairs while the indirect form of democracy is that form of the democratic government which sees that the people elect their representatives to rule for their own interests and hence participate in elections to select a government of their own (Sen 1999). One should believe that the democracy that exists within…
1 pages (251 words)
Critical Response: Paper 2
For one, the French were present in the war long before the United States was. Second, Eisenhower was elected on a pledge to stop the Korean War, so it does not make much sense that he would want to hop right into the Vietnam War. In fact, Eisenhower was initially very hesitant to join the war at all, and did not want to do so unless proper support from the other Western societies was provided (Karnow 1997, 197).…
1 pages (251 words)
Critical Response Paper
It is imperative for the country to balance the opinions of the different religions and integrate them in the formation of the government. This is because the relationship between the government and the religion is very fluid; the religion and/or the politics change in response to history and its interpretation. According to Brown-Foster and Goldstein (2010), circumstance and history determines the evolvement of the relationship between the state and the religion.…
1 pages (251 words)
Critical Response Paper (And the Injun goes “How!”: Representations of American Indian English in white public space)
A noteworthy information essential to the reader is to know how movies portray the lifestyle of the American Indians through imitating how they converse English.…
3 pages (753 words)