StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Corporate Crime - Compliance or Deterrence - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Corporate Crime - Compliance or Deterrence" highlights that generally speaking, compliance regulatory strategy can be the apt strategy that can be implemented in sweatshops to prevent corporate crimes, particularly employee rights violations…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Corporate Crime - Compliance or Deterrence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Corporate Crime - Compliance or Deterrence"

Criminology – Corporate Crime: Compliance or Deterrence? In the current competitive business environment, organizations not only had to be economically successful, but also ethically correct. That is, it has to carry out ethically correct business practices, like aptly taking care of its employees, following fair trade practices with the customers, environment friendly practices, etc. Instead, if the organization and its management carry out unethical and unfair business practices, most of the times, it will constitute as a corporate crime, leading to problems from all sides. Corporate crime in any industrial sector including sweatshops is characterized as illegal as well as harmful acts, which could be committed by the leaders and even the employees of the corporations, with the intention to promote their personal as well as corporate interests, to the detriment of many stakeholders. As these crimes could wreck the corporation, shrinking its profits, destroying its brand image, negatively impacting employees’ livelihood and in worst case scenarios total shutting down of the corporation, constructive steps will be normally taken, both by the corporations themselves as well as external stakeholders like governments. On those lines, corporate crimes can be prevented by implementing regulatory strategies or policies, which border on compliance and deterrence. Although, both these policies have advantages as well as disadvantages, compliance would be a better strategy to combat corporate misconduct particularly in sweatshops. Compliance regulatory strategy puts the onus on the sweatshops themselves, while deterrence regulatory strategy brings in the role of external prosecution agencies. Compliance strategy concentrates on the power of regulatory agencies to encourage corporations or sweatshops “to comply with the law before crimes are committed”, on the other hand, deterrence strategy “rely on criminal prosecutions to prevent corporate crime after the crime has already been committed.” (Coleman, 2008). Thus, the basic difference as well as advantage is, compliance strategy through regulatory agencies as well as self-regulation could preempt and prevent the crime as well as other violations from taking place, while deterrence focuses on aftermath of those crimes or violations. In line with the old adage of “Prevention is better than Cure”, it would be better to prevent crimes as well as human or employee rights’ violations, and that is particularly applicable to sweatshops, which employs sizable number of employees and where chances of violation of employee rights is more than finance based corporate crimes. Sweatshops in both the “parent” country as well as in the outsourced countries could employ high number of employees, and as it is the norm in the sweatshops, the working environment could be dangerous, unhealthy, thereby breaching basic human rights. Thus, in order to facilitate or even force sweatshops to function in an ethical manner, governments, or parent corporations, or sweatshops themselves, or all these main stakeholders together, will establish a compliance regulatory under which a set of regulations for ethical behavior will be formulated for implementation, and also an external player will be involved to audit whether those regulations are aptly implemented. (Rosen, 2002). The advantage with this process of involving all the key stakeholders in the formulation as well as the implementation of the compliance strategy is, as all the stakeholders have participated in the formulation, they have to naturally implement it. “This is an example of a number of transnational areas in which codes have been developed through co-operation and negotiation between industry players, trade unions and other interested NGOs”, with the government actors playing a key supportive role, thereby actualizing “a mixed system of public-private regulation”, which is a “hallmark of successful industry self-regulation initiatives.” (Bartle, & Vass, 2005). This strategy of implementing self-regulatory compliance is visible in majority of the sweatshops, and with all the key stakeholders making an active contribution instead of confrontation; it is bound to be successful. The development of compliance based corporate codes suggested a slight shift in the locus of political struggle to the market. (Fudge, 2001) Along with the above discussed reasons, the reason why compliance strategy could be the preferred strategy because if compliance is encouraged among the sweatshops, and prosecution is used as the last resort, then the management inside the sweatshops would place more respect and importance on the regulations, thereby implementing it without fail. The other thinking that could arise among the management in favor of the compliance strategy is, sweatshops could “actually benefit from increased regulation because without it they would face more civil suits from workers or consumers, and possibly avoid the possibility of criminal prosecution.” (Coleman, 2008). In addition, external regulatory agencies can be involved as part of overseeing as well as auditing the day to day operations of the sweatshops particularly any chances of violations or crimes. The reason why these external regulators can be involved as “watchdogs agencies”, instead of bringing in the criminal prosecutors at a later stage is, these regulators or regulating agencies being specialized experts would have better understanding of the way sweatshops will function. “Regulators would be visible entities within the organization with inside knowledge of its business practices, increasing the likelihood that illegal activity by corporate executives would be detected.” (Coleman, 2008). Although, these regulators have less power than the federal prosecutors, as mentioned above, they have in-depth knowledge about the business process as well as resources needed for monitoring those processes. The other limitation is, there has been criticism among the business community including sweatshops that compliance regulatory strategy could create “tension between laissez faire principles and the free market in which business operates”, with sweatshops complaining that “too much regulation serves as a barrier to the pursuit of free enterprise.” (Coleman, 2008). However, this limitation can be managed, if these compliance regulations are formulated in such an optimal way, so there is a fine and effective balance between the interests of the sweatshops as well as the employees, public, etc. From the above analysis, it can be assumed that compliance regulatory strategy can be the apt strategy that can be implemented in the sweatshops to prevent corporate crimes particularly employee rights violations. Although, there are some limitations with this policy, those can be managed or solved with apt correction strategies. As the compliance strategy could preempt and prevent crimes or violations from taking place, involves all the key stakeholders, utilize equipped and effective external regulators, etc., it can be the best strategy for sweatshops. References Bartle, I & Vass, P. (2005). Self-Regulation and the Regulatory State. Retrieved from: http://www.bath.ac.uk/management/cri/pubpdf/Research_Reports/17_Bartle_Vass.pdf Coleman, K. (2008). Controlling Corporate Crime: An Analysis of Deterrence versus Compliance. Retrieved from: http://www.cics.northwestern.edu/documents/nilr/v1n1Coleman.pdf Fudge, J. (2001). “Consumers to the Rescue? Corporate Campaigns against Labour Abuse.” In S. B. Boyd, D. Chunn and B. Menzies, eds., Abusing Power (146-59). Fernwood. Rosen, E. I. (2002). “Apparel Retailing in the United States.” In Making Sweatshops. University of Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 9”, n.d.)
Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 9. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1640435-criminology
(Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 9)
Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 9. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1640435-criminology.
“Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 9”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1640435-criminology.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Corporate Crime - Compliance or Deterrence

Criminalizing Corporate Governance Failures

There are legitimate considerations about criminalizing corporate governance failures, mainly from social pressures related to the protection of public interest or the protection of minority rights, as well as considerations that adopt the rhetoric of deterrence through harsh legal sanctions, signaling deterrence to directors.... This essay "Criminalizing corporate Governance Failures" talks about a need to compel corporate officers to protect their fiduciary duties through criminal proceedings, like as aspect that looks at criminalizing corporate governance failures as a step to severe....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Death Penalty: Fair Solution or Moral Failure

At the very forefronts of the debate of the death penalty lies deterrence theory, that has long been a cornerstone that many researchers and scholars have used to argue for the death penalty.... deterrence theory has several times been quoted by judges, persecutors, officials and legal authoritative people to justify the death penalty (Gerber and Johnson, 2007, p.... The basic consensus of the deterrence theory is that the death penalty serves a general deterrence to crime....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Structuring Corporate Plea and Settlement Agreements

The following memoranda set the guidelines of a plea agreement between the government prosecutor and the corporation investigated for a corporate crime.... his memorandum requires the accused corporation to plead guilty to the charge and its provisions ensure 'punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, and compliance with the agreement.... The deterrence mechanism of this policy comes in hefty fines, mandatory restitution, and compliance measures....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Study of Corporate Crimes: Precepts and Significance

The author of the paper titled "The Study of Corporate Crimes: Precepts and Significance" examines the subject matter of corporate criminology, and attempts to understand the criminological precepts and legal concepts associated with corporate crime.... Even as there is an increasing awareness of the financial, human, and social costs of corporate wrongdoings among academics, politicians, social activists, and the public, researchers suggest that there is also a growing appreciation of the difficulties with holding companies accountable for their wrongs....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Ethics and Small Business: Fraud and White Collar Crime

An essay "Ethics and Small Business: Fraud and White Collar crime" claims that business officials likewise fall into this category of officials likely to be subjected to the challenges of veering off the temptations to engage in these practices of misconduct (Friedrichs, 2002).... These official jobs are usually referred to as white collar jobs, thereby implying that the criminal liability in this class of operations is referred to as a white-collar crime.... The performance of the national economy heavily relies on the level of crime and investor confidence that is likely to be affected by irregular practices among business people....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Theories of Punishment and Abolishing Punishment

This paper analyses the objectives of institutional punishment, merits, abolitionist arguments, retribution, reformation, prevention, and deterrence.... (Taft, 1964, 21) Cumulatively, criminologists typically agree that punishment has three primary purposes, the prevention of crime, maintaining the 'moral of conformists' and for rehabilitating the offender.... (Cragg, 1992, 1-7) In short, each of these theories has as the purpose the containment of crime by one theoretical framework or another....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

White Collar and Corporate Crime in the UK Legal System

This coursework "White Collar and corporate crime in the UK Legal System" argues that the UK legal system should address this deficiency if it is to pose a serious deterrent to white-collar and corporate crime.... Both major parties, indeed, have supported the need for up-to-date legislation on corporate crime, well-resourced government agencies to tackle white-collar crime and robust penalties for those found guilty of these crimes.... This paper will argue that the UK legal system should address this deficiency if it is to pose a serious deterrent to white-collar and corporate crime....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

The Private Sector and Further Perpetration

This report "The Private Sector and Further Perpetration" attempts to answer the question of whether increased severity of penalties is a catalyst for a reduction in corporate crime, bearing the view that in reality, the magnitude and number of such crimes are steadily rising.... Apparently, the increasingly tougher penalties meted out by government agencies have not helped in reducing the rates and magnitudes of corporate crime.... This paper attempts to answer the question of whether increased severity of penalties given to the corporates is a catalyst for a reduction in corporate crime, bearing the view that in reality, the magnitude and number of such crimes are steadily rising....
6 Pages (1500 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us