A qualitative research critique - Essay Example

Extract of sample
A qualitative research critique

Concerning these challenges, there are various guidelines developed in the past few years that can be utilised while examining a qualitative research paper, such as the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) framework (Mack & et. al., 2010). There are various aspects which needs utmost consideration while critiquing a qualitative research. For instance, the coherence of the topic being critiqued should be appropriate for the qualitative enquiry (Boswell & Cannon, 2010). It is also vital for the literature review to be consistent with the methods that has been selected for the study. The article chosen for the critique also needs to possess sufficient account regarding the informants, the chosen subject matter as well as the researcher(s). In addition, there must be adequate description regarding the methods applied for information assembling as well as information analysis. It is significant for an effective critique to possess a sound conclusion (Forchuk, & Roberts, 1993). With due regards to these aspects, the purpose of this discussion is to demonstrate how a particular qualitative research paper can be critiqued by using CASP framework. The article that will be examined is “Like a Trip to Macdonald: A Grounded Theory Study of Patient Experiences of Day Surgery” by Anne Mottram. ...
Download paper

Summary

A Qualitative Research Critique Table of Contents Introduction 3 Perspective of Qualitative Research 4 Critical Review- CASP Framework 8 Conclusion 29 References 31 Bibliography 39 Introduction Critiquing of the qualitative research needs the implementation of distinct standards as well as criteria…
Author : nyasiastanton
Download 1

Related Essays

Qualitative Critique
1.1 Research aims, purpose and rationale The twofold aim and purpose of this study have been clearly stated by the researcher. The main aim of this research was to study the Korean-American parent’s perceptions regarding common discipline strategies in the United States of America while the secondary aim was to explore the specific discipline strategies used by the Korean American parents. The study therefore aimed at yielding some useful data regarding the differential discipline related strategies used by Korean American parents; to assist the individuals in healthcare sector, especially...
4 pages (1004 words) Book Report/Review
The most common factors causing therapeutic compliance
The study problem is a discussion of therapeutic compliance among patients. This means that the research has to do with pharmaceutical issues. Coincidentally, all four researchers have professions relating to pharmacology. With a research problem that relates to the professional background of the researchers therefore, it was highly expected that the researchers would display personal pre-understandings of the research problem. Reading through the research article however, it can be seen that almost all ideas, findings and philosophical analysis presented in the research work were taken from...
10 pages (2510 words) Research Paper
Critique of a Qualitative Research Report
Introduction The problem is well defined in the introduction and is based on empirical evidence. The problem stated is easy to understand as it is based not on assumptions but on statistical data. The problem taken in to consideration is of medication errors which, though, have been studied before, lack data on which the problem can be fixed of modified. The rationale for the research is based on solid empirical grounds since the gap between the review of the literature is clearly identified. The limitations of the previous researches are also clearly presented making the argument for the...
7 pages (1757 words) Research Paper
Qualitative Nursing Research Critique on the Relationship of Nursing Unit Structure to Patient Satisfaction
Qualitative Nursing Research Critique on the Relationship of Nursing Unit Structure to Patient Satisfaction In the field of medicine, most of the time patients under similar diagnoses may not have similar outcomes. This makes for the uncertainty that is commonly present under medical conditions (Lubin, Smith, Dodson, Spell, & Walker, 2010). What can be certain however is the satisfaction or dissatisfaction of both the patients and the level of engagement of the nursing staff that serves them. In a study conducted by Bacon and Mark in 2009, they were able to make a connection between the...
4 pages (1004 words) Assignment
Qualitative Research critique
In this, research becomes important in understanding safe and best practices (Barker, 2010). Additionally, research reveals information on other factors related to the profession and their effects. This essay seeks to analyze a research done by a group of nursing professionals entitled Men and Infant Feeding: Perceptions of Embarrassment, Sexuality, and Social Conduct in White Low-Income British Men. Just as is with any other profession, the use of current and relevant information in a practice is important. New and relevant information on any practice is only determined through research,...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Quantitative Nursing and Qualitative Critique
This paper approves that the study used co-creation learning process for participants in their DSME program which yielded significant results in proper self-management among parsons with type 2 DM. so, it is recommended that clinicians or nursing staff or professionals who have interaction with DSME education should prefer self-participation and self-involvement of their patients in identifying activities, barriers and possible solutions according to their desires and requirements.
...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Critique of a qualitative research article
4. The study shows no any stated hypothesis. 5. The study was an original one and not a replication of past studies because it was the first study to apply longitudinal and repeated measures design in children. This is unique because previous studies were done through the cohort design. Through the unique approach, the study added new information to what was already from previous studies. First, the study found that self-determined health judgment reduced significantly over the 6 month period after intervention. This decline portrayed a change from intrinsic to extrinsic direction unlike...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!