The concept of personhood is complicated. The definition of self and who an individual is can be a very important thing in setting up the framework for ethics and respect for the rights of people. In this paper, I will examine important concepts in the theory of personhood and the prominent debates on the subject…
These debates would be linked to the position of severely invalid persons like persons with Acute Dementia in the ward I did my practical work in. Questions to be addressed include, who are they? What is their position in the society? And what moral and ethical obligations do health professionals like nurses owe to such persons.
In my study of philosophy, I had on question on my mind and this was from my practical work. The question was, what is the position of people with acute dementia. The are seriously invalid and have a tough existence. I therefore began to wonder how their rights to health care accrued and why the state decided to respect their rights as human beings. I began to find out why we are required, as health professionals to take good care of them. I found a lot of answers about the fundamental rights of seriously invalid persons in my study of philosophy and readings on the theories on personhood.
From my readings, I identified that personhood has been debated thoroughly in history. The Founding Fathers of America decided to grant equal rights to all the colonialists to kind of liberate them from the harsh rules of the British colonialists. This became the fundamental principles of human rights which became part of the United Nations' conventions over 170 years after America gained independence in 1776.
Merrill (1998) argues that in the world today, personhood is the basis of rights. She states that “the person is to ethics as the cell is to biology: the minimal basic unit” (Merrill, 1998). Personhood therefore forms the basis for the definition of moral theory. The society depends on the mutual recognition of personhood (Elridge, 1989). Thus, the fundamentally flawed societies failed to attribute respect to the personhood of certain people. Examples include Nazi Germany which killed six million Jews, Gypsies and homosexuals because in their view, these persons did not have rights that guaranteed them life and justice. Aside these people, Germans with acute mental issues like those with down syndrome and acute dementia like those I cared for during my practicals were a blotch to the pure Aryan race the Nazis sought to raise. They were separated and most of them were killed. This is because they were not viewed as humans or persons, under the Nazi philosophy. Also, there is evidence of several people in the Nazi concentration camps being used for experiments like twins, blue eyed person and midgets/dwarfs. This is because such persons were not considered to be 'persons'. Eventually, Nazi Germany was invaded by the Allies and this was seen as a triumph of good over evil. The United Nations was formed in 1945 to protect the rights of people in all parts of the world. In the long run, it is clear that the nations that led the United Nations and Allied course had studied important elements of 'personhood' and that forms the basis of moral ethics today which defines the fundamental rights of patients including people with severe dementia. Locke, who was one of the earliest philosophers whose concepts supported human rights argued that an individual defines himself in a given way. That is what sets the foundation of his identity. Once this is done, the individual is viewed as he defines himself or herself and define him or her as a 'person' (Locke, 2003). Thus, it is more of self which evolves to the person. In Locke's second treatise, it was concluded that a society is a collection of persons (2003). Due to this, persons come together to collectively define the structures of a society. As such, they should have rights in order to live a meaningful life. Kant on the other hand, believed in the theory of individual ...
Cite this document
(“Personhood and Severely Invalid Persons Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/nursing/11879-personhood-and-severely-invalid-persons
(Personhood and Severely Invalid Persons Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
“Personhood and Severely Invalid Persons Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/nursing/11879-personhood-and-severely-invalid-persons.
Abortion is a topical issue within the society and has over the years gained a lot of relevance. Statistics indicate that, in the U.S., close to half of pregnancies registered among American women remain unintended with four out of ten of these pregnancies by age 45 ending up by termination by abortion.
b) From the Method section, list the independent or predictor variable/s and dependent or outcome variable/s. The predictor variable in this case was if the subject was diagnosed with ADHD or not (there were controls used in this study). The outcome variable was the presence or absence of various sleep disorders (termed ‘sleep variables’ in the study), which included disorders of arousal, sleep walking, night terrors, bruxism, motor restlessness (from the sleep interview) and sleep terror, subclinical REM behaviour disorder and CA (from the video polysomnography information).
Is his argument convincing? The rational self and its personal identity are perceptible and what ever is deemed imperceptible under the logic of mathematics sustain moral significance. But must description of persons such as ‘heap’, ‘bald’, ‘tall’ and the like which pertains to ‘personal identity’ be considered vague?
His first ever book, Reasons and Persons, which was published in 1984 is one of the most popular books in this regard which has touched each of the aspects in detail after considering various conditions and possibilities relevant to various aspects of morality.
Moreover, such awareness and concept, when molded together with a person’s familial, religious and cultural backgrounds, makes up the identity of the individual. As a human being, I am aware about my self who, I believe does not only exist but live for a purpose.
What can philosophy contribute to the study of personhood?
Should philosophers seek to provide the necessary and sufficient conditions for applying the concept of personhood, or should we seek to provide a descriptive analysis of the attitudes adopted when we treat someone as a person in practice?
Some are remembered for creating something, or doing something, that enhanced our civilization; while others are remembered for the inhumanness of their acts. The question then becomes, why do these people have their places in our minds instead of someone else Why are they earmarked by society to be remembered when others are forgotten Why are they considered today to have been successful in their works, ingenious in their thoughts, and adept at their skills
This was displayed most notably in the 1973 Supreme Court Decision of Roe v. Wade1 which based its landmark decision not on the issue of personhood, but rather on the viability of the fetus outside of the womb. This decision affirmed the
The author of the essay highlights the fact, the idea is that a person owes its identity and personhood to the soul, reinforcing the principle that human life is sacred, requiring respect and recognition of its dignity. Thus, the soul is, ideally, what makes a human a person as it both breathes life to the human body and gives it the faculty of reason.