The Critical appraisal of two research articles,critically analyse and evaluate the streights and weaknesses.

The Critical appraisal of two research articles,critically analyse and evaluate the streights and weaknesses. Essay example
Masters
Essay
Nursing
Pages 12 (3012 words)
Download 0
The Critical Appraisal of Research Articles on Health and Social Care Technological and research advancements allow people to secure better and safer health care for everyone to enjoy life with optimum level of health. To fulfil this need, scholars pursue researches to provide reliable information on various aspects of health care to set evidence based parameters on safety of innovations in health care…

Introduction

Critical appraisal is “the process of carefully and systematically examining research to judge its trustworthiness, and its value and relevance in a particular context” (Burls, 2009, pp. 1-8). Its practice in medical field is highly relevant to delineate the useful discoveries from the harmful ones. A quality research is not just one that reflects good composure or format rather it is one that has internal validity which is being free from bias. Therefore, the research must be reviewed particularly in the selection, performance, detection and attrition where bias commonly occurs. Analysis must be conducted from data gathering, collation, down to analysis. In this paper, the author aims to clinically appraise two researches on health and social care. The first is entitled “Efficacy and safety of hyaluronic acid in treatment of leg ulcers: a double-blind randomised controlled trial (Dereure, Czubek and Combemale, 2012, pp. 131-139)” while the other is “The experience of patients with complex wounds and the use of negative pressure wound therapy in a home-care setting (Moffatt, et al. 2011, pp.512-527).” Both are in pursuit of a reliable and sustainable practice caring for patients with chronic wound. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Critical appraisal of the research reports
In the quantitative research, plenty of information was already available and features were classified, counted and statistical models constructed for the study. The qualitative research was subjective and usually related in the participant’s own words and the researcher was not aware of the information he was looking for. The researcher was well aware of what he was searching for in…
Research Critical Appraisal
Moreover, the Special Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children is a program which is in place in the Chicago area and evaluating its possible applicability to the greater population may be a future possibility. Before such possibility can be reached, an evaluation of its current applications must first be carried out in order to improve patient outcomes as well as maternal and child care…
Rapid Appraisal of Articles
323). Data were collected from 85 patients with diabetic ulcers but due to attrition, only 54 patients were analyzed. The result of the study found out that a statistically significant difference (p<0.001) between the gauze and bioactive dressing groups exist as for the number of healed pressure ulcers (p<0.05), indicating that the use of a moist bioactive wound dressing increased the healing rate…
Rapid Appraisal of Articles
1). The study aimed to determine whether using structured, systematic pressure risk assessment tools reduces the incidence of pressure ulcers in any health care setting. Two review authors assessed the eligibility of each study based on the inclusion criteria. The original review found no studies that would meet the inclusion criteria and that there was no statistically significant difference…
Critical Appraisal
Both the researches use both primary and secondary sources thereby developing a holistic understanding to the study areas. Primary sources refer to the first hand subjects of the research, which are the patients of the condition under investigation. From this subject group, the researchers determine the nature of the disease and the manner in which each treatment methodology differs from the other…
Qualitative Research Report Summary & Critical Appraisal
The research article highlights that horizontal violence is practical within nursing placement exercises. According to Bowen, Curtis and Reid (2007), analysis of qualitative data indicates that more that 50% of the respondents have experienced, or at least witnessed this kind of violence in their practices. As a result, the article simulates appropriate and informed recommendation strategies meant…
CRITICAL APPRAISAL
To maintain data untainted in any way, researchers and interviewers need to create questions in ways that would not affect the outcome through preconception of answers from the interviewees (Smith, Flowers, & Larkin, 2009). Using methods least-likely to affect the interviewees by allowing them to be themselves without necessitating them to change their attitudes and collecting data as soon as…