Critique of a published research paper - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Critique of a published research paper

2004). Title The title of the study conducted by Nick Sevdalis, Andrew N. Healey and Charles A. Vincent (Nick et al. 2006) is well defined, concise and the reader can effectively understand the topic of this study only by reading the title. The title is informative because it is telling us that the subject of this study is which is important information for future researchers (Polit and Beck 2008). However even though I can clearly understand the subject of this study I can understand very little about the character of this study and the methods they used so based on the title I can’t determine if it is a systematic review, experimental study. Researchers Qualifications Nick et al. 2006 have the appropriate professional qualifications for conduction of this study. This is important because of the character of the research method adopted by the authors. Subject of this study is analysis of communication within the operating room and identification of eventual events that may distract the normal functioning of the surgeon, anesthesiologist or other members present in the operating room. In order to achieve adequate and reliable assessment there is a need of professionals, trained to recognize the subtitle communications within the operation room. ...
Download paper

Summary

Critique of a published research paper Study type In this review I will analyze a randomized experimental, mixed design (quantitative and qualitative) study conducted in clinical settings (Shadish et al 2002). It is experimental study because it tries to test a hypothesis on a randomized cohort group of surgeons, anesthesiologists and other staff in the operational room, in clinical settings in one hospital…
Author : nathenwilliamso

Related Essays

Research critique
Prior to its development, only partial checklists were available for qualitative researches. Other methods, which would have been used, for critiquing this research include Bray and Rees model of 1995 and Benton and Cormack model of 2000. These methods have been used prior to the COREQ method and can still be used for critiquing this research (Lee, 2006). The journal featured in the ERA ranking fro 2009. It can, therefore, be said to be highly regarded among numerous published journals. The authors of the report can be identified as professionals in the field. Kate and Jeannie are research...
12 pages (3012 words) Research Paper
Critique of Research Article
Urinary Tract Infection refers to the presence of germs in the urinary tract. It is a very common type of infection like respiratory tract infection. Having a catheter within a urinary tract increases the chances of a urinary tract infection. It also makes it harder to treat the original infection for which catheter was using. Bacteria will grow in it if the urinary catheter is left in place for a long time. A large number of bacteria in the urinary tract may result in a harmful infection. Most catheters associated urinary tract infections are caused by bacteria. Wilson and Jenner (2007)...
6 pages (1506 words) Term Paper
Quantitative Research Article Critique
In relation, this paper will conduct a critique of a study by Maida, et al. (2010) regarding the treatment preferences of patients with advanced cancer. The details of the mentioned study were published in a nursing article in the tenth volume of the BMC Cancer Journal. One of the major problems that became apparent in the article was that the study problem was not explicitly stated in the study’s abstract, and it was not until in the later parts of the Background that the reader becomes aware of the study’s intent to analyze patient preferences on conservative palliative management (CPM)...
5 pages (1255 words) Assignment
Research Critique - Dapagliflozin Trials
This paper reviews various aspects of a medical trial study carried out in Japan. The critique evaluates issues of human protection, data collection, analyses and management as well as the final findings. The study by Boulton et al. (2011) highlights the comparative use of dapagliflozin on two treatment groups consisting of diabetics with type II diabetes (T2DM) and healthy subjects. The research paper was published in the fourth issue of the Diabetes, Obesity and Metabolism Journal in 2011. The main objective of the research was to investigate the tolerability and safety of dapagliflozin in...
4 pages (1004 words) Research Paper
Quantitative Research Paper Critique
200). Analysis Research Problem: The research problem eliciting this research bid was driven by the need to assess gaps in reproductive health services and family planning, which are not yet clearly understood. Unintended pregnancy levels are part of the core indicators of the gaps, and this indicator is important to policymakers and planners. These pregnancies determine the health outcomes of both mother and child, and as such are indicative of the gap in planning. Thus, the research seeks to assess levels of unintended pregnancies so as to understand the gap in planning (Ilene et al. 200)....
3 pages (753 words) Research Paper
Critical thinking skills in nursing students: comparison of simulation-based performance with metrics
The study focused on comparing the nursing students critically in terms of simulation performance basis with metrics. According to the report presented, title of the study is appropriate and none other could suit the study any better. The abstract of the report is quite well composed. It begins by highlighting the main aim of the study which is apparently the establishment of the existing relationship between the metrics of critical thinking skills and performance in simulated clinical scenarios. The background to the study has also been provided. Their study was motivated by the fact that...
9 pages (2259 words) Research Paper
To critique a research paper
Mostly nurses provide care to the patients under the orders or supervision of the physicians and this traditional role has given nurses an image of care providers. However, most of the jurisdictions have permitted the nurses to work independently depending on the settings of their training level. But during the postwar period, the nursing education has been diversified towards advanced and specialized credentials, and this has brought change in many traditional regulations and roles of the care providers (Cornwell and Goodrich, 2009). Being a profession, the main motive of the nursing...
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!