StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker - Term Paper Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker

Some scholars suggest that the system has drifted out of control: “Through no planned design or evil intent, our health care system has evolved in ways that better serve a myriad of economic, professional, and political interests than those of patients and families, and the larger public” (Mechanic, 2006, p. ix). Gawande, however, sees a much bleaker picture, and suggests that there are areas in America where doctors and administrators are financially tied into provision, and that this encourages massive amounts of over-treatment, with no benefit to patients. Gawande’s article describes a huge discrepancy in the per capita costs of medical care in two comparable districts, McAllen and El Paso, Texas, while there is no evidence that the higher cost location (McAllen) offers better care or achieves better results. This gives rise to a serious ethical problem: in El Paso patients have much lower rates of access to all kinds of tests and treatments, while in McAllen, they have much higher rates. The variation is due to doctor behavior, and not down to the demographics of the citizens, since the two regions are very similar. This is the kind of situation that led to the passing of the 2010 Health Care Reform bill which aims to extend health coverage to from 83% to 95% of the legally resident population. (Tumulty, 2010, p. 1) Unfortunately, however, huge variation in the way that this money is spent will mean that a fair and equal service is not likely to happen. From the point of view of justice, or fairness, such unequal practices cannot be defended, since all American citizens should have equal access to the benefits of our modern technologies. From a utilitarian point of view, there is a deviation from best practice, since in the McAllen hospitals there is little effort to gain the greatest benefit to patients for the lowest cost. Increasing the amount of testing in order to maximise revenue is the very opposite of ethical behaviour on the part of institutions where doctors earn more for ordering more procedures and tests. Gawande suggests that the problem lies with the structures of delivery, and describes the McAllen healthcare model as “as system that has no brakes” (Gawanda, p. 14). He cites the example of the Mayo clinic, where doctors receive a fixed salary, as a potential solution. Fewer scans are done, and more discussion between doctors takes place to minimize unnecessary treatments, all of which come with risks as well as benefits, and to try to ensure that patients have what they need, rather than what can be sold to them for profit. There is little incentive to cherry pick patients in this kind of system, and hospitals which follow this style find that overall costs are lower, and quality of care goes up. This analysis takes a refreshing look at the way the whole system is set up, and this gives the reader an overview of things rather than just the view of an economist, or a health professional, or an administrator. It highlights the error that patients, and some doctors, often make, in thinking that more testing is always good. The point is to do what is the best for the patient, and not what sustains the system. If there was more of this kind of benchmarking across hospitals with comparable patient characteristics, then perhaps more could be done to eliminate wasteful ...Show more

Summary

Find a newspaper article or scholarly journal article (from 2008 to present date) that illustrates an ethical discussion that involves allocation of health care resources such as challenges that fall within the category of distributive justice. The article by Atul Gawande (2009) in published in the New Yorker raises fundamental issues about the way American citizens receive their health care from their local hospitals and doctors…
Author : denesiklenny
The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the term paper on your topic
"The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

New Media Term Paper
The high technology is a news maker in itself and not just a medium to news making. The latest gadgets are on the top issues that get the attention of many viewers, especially those who desire to be the first in acquiring the latest device in the market. This circumstance has set the trend nowadays that who gets the latest, best and most expensive gadget becomes a popular personality in an individual’s circle of friends and described as adept in high technology gadgets.
2 pages (500 words) Term Paper
Article Review
In order to prove a point, in this age of scientific advancement, it is necessary to present the point of view with relevant facts and data. No one is going to believe the word for granted and scientists are finding it very difficult to convince others, particularly other scientists.
5 pages (1250 words) Term Paper
Prcis of journal article
The change agent is described as “undeserving victims of the irrational and dysfunctional responses of change recipients” (Ford, Ford & D’Amelio, 362). This suggests that change in an organization is dynamic and involves considerable stress stemming from illogical or absurd attitudes from employees or managers who are defiant against adopting a proposed change principle.
7 pages (1750 words) Term Paper
Compare great depression with the last recession of 2008-2009
The great depression and the last recession of 2008-2009 are different in terms of their lasting periods, causes, and effects on employment and world trade. Lasting period: The great depression is one great economic disaster that ever happened in history, making it greater than the recession in the modern times.
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Qualitative research article
As part of going through the main discussion, the article written by Griffiths, Camic and Hutton (2009) entitled “Participant experiences of a mindfulness-based cognitive therapy group for cardiac rehabilitation” will be used in giving out real-life examples to back up the arguments that will be presented in this essay.
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Microeconomics article review
The percentage of the labor force that was unemployed for five weeks or less did not grow much during 2007. Ironically in the aftermath of the recession which occurred between 2009 and 2010 after five weeks of unemployment people looking for jobs ended up filing for more unemployment benefits.
3 pages (750 words) Term Paper
Article analysis
The conflicting contentions of Republicans and Democrats over the way the national health reform should be packaged and implemented actually manifest delaying tactics on the comprehensive
3 pages (750 words) Term Paper
New HIPAA
The Act requires such entities or practitioners to use universal standards and an ethical code of system to process healthcare transactions. The provisions regarding the enforcement of HIPAA, violations
1 pages (250 words) Term Paper
Article Critique
The authors of the study attempt to explicate numerous ways in which narcissism manifests itself in these owners. For this purpose, web pages were collected and then strangers were asked
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Scholarly Article Review
Under the No Child Left Behind [NCLB] Act, schools and teachers are given the accountability of the students’ performance. However the issue of teachers’ shortage has remained
1 pages (250 words) Term Paper
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation