Within the context of brain transplant, a person is only identical to the later person if the later person has the entire body as the earlier person, subsequently, brain rejuvenation results to memory duplication whereby a person’s memory can be used by several other persons. Prior to the suggested “brain rejuvenation” procedure on Nick, Dr. Mathews performed a “brain transplant” operation on Julia North and subsequently the members of the committee agreed that Julia North’s life was saved. Perhaps we may need to understand a few basics and events that led to this case. Before this operation, Julia North was a young woman run over by a car in efforts to save the life of a child who wandered onto the tracks. Mary Frances who was the child’s mother had stroke while watching the events unfold. The two victims were brought to this facility where Dr. Mathews performed his ‘Brain transplant’ operation which the committee approved and agreed that saved Julia’s life. It is also important to note that at the time of accident, the survivor, Julia North’s body was dying and the brain was okay and Dr. Mathews transferred her brain into another body. The committee further agreed that it was Julia’s life that was saved since the survivor had memories of Julia based on the being Julia. While arriving at this conclusion, this committee must have been guided by the sophisticated memory account that provides that when a person is numerically identical to a later person if and only if the person has memories of being earlier person that is so caused in the right way. My objection for this matter rests with Cohen’s views on this matter. Julia North had one up until the time of accident, and another body after the operation. This implies that one person had two bodies. Therefore a person cannot be simply identified with a human body and therefore something must be wrong with the view that the committee had adopted on this case as it implies that if a similar operation were to be carried out on brain transplant, then afterwards this person would be a person with new body since the person with that body has a memory of having a similar case as Julia if caused in the ‘right way.’ Right in this scenario has a particular meaning of interest, and must satisfy three conditions; if a subject experiences some event, this experience leaves a trace in the brain of the event and this trace that has been left is later responsible for content of a memory, then in this way we can say that the memory is caused in the right way. Dear members, we are faced with another problem of a new technique called ‘Brain rejuvenation’ yet to be performed on Nick. While adopting earlier propositions to defend approving Julia’s case we are also suggesting that the same logic as earlier proposed would be applicable and as such the committee is justified in saying that Nick would be the survivor of the operation , and I quote, “Nick would be the survivor of the brain rejuvenation procedure because the survivor would have the memories of being Nick and there would be more than one person of being Nick.” But dear members, Nick cannot be more than one person and this do not seems right. Using the same procedure as advanced in this new ‘brain rejuvenation’ process, the committee has argued that saving Nick’s life will be accomplished by replacing his brain with a duplicated brain from someone else and as such his survival are justified on the premise that the same bodies would be of this new person, say Alex and that Nick would then have Alex’s memories and they remember them in the right way. Premised on the duplication theory, when someone
Cite this document
(“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/nursing/65192-write-a-leyer-to-the-commiyee-saying-why-brain
(Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay)
“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/nursing/65192-write-a-leyer-to-the-commiyee-saying-why-brain.
Cited: 0 times
Dear members, While there exists a general consensus of the benefits of medical transplant towards saving lives and giving persons a second chance in life, it becomes very necessary that advancements in the medical field towards replacement of body organs be examined keenly with a view to determine the issues surrounding such a process…
Numerous researchers and analysts have compiled several articles and reports on the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC). The Joint Intelligence Committee is one of the highest level of conflict resolution by the British government. Other analysts have referred to the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC) as the best thing that happened in the British government.
It describes the least provisions for conduct, and behavioural prospect relatively than precise actions. The idea of system of moral values is towards encouraging the moral traditions inside a career of internal auditing. Internal auditing is an autonomous, intention pledge, a consult action considered towards inserting importance as well as progress the organization operation.
One of the major areas where there has been a significant change is the area of “Audit committees”. Audit committees have come to play a very prominent role in governing the way organizations do their business and report it to the world. In this context, it is very important that we understand the advantages and limitations of audit committees.
“Facebook is a country founded on the fear that undergirds all modern life: the suspicion that everyone you like is off somewhere else having more fun than you are, that you will turn around and miss it. And as it turns out, this is true, because you are spending all your time on Facebook” made me laugh because it reverberates of the irony in the truth.
Our company also has no work to assign to you.
The decision is in accordance with our company policy that demands that any workers who fail to adhere to the code of conduct be suspended without pay for one and half months pending any other disciplinary action. As a
The need of brain communication is mainly to control the biological actions also referred as biopsychology. The forms of communication are mainly different in terms of communication exchange between the neurons and
The first essay I wrote in this course is very different from the essays that I have been writing lately. This is because I am always improving my writing skills. As much as I have developed good writing skills in English, I
I came to USA to further my studies following a scholarship I got after successfully completing my Bachelor of Geography course.
I am writing to inquire about acceptance for (XXXX major name) at (University or college’s name).I am interested in
But it is important that you tell me because I am willing to assist.
It will be imperative if you admit your addiction to the alcohol so that you can be helped. Excessive take of alcohol may cause server
1 pages (250 words)Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you!Try us!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed for FREE!