StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Constructive Criticism vs Disciplinary Actions on a Nursing Unit - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Constructive Criticism vs Disciplinary Actions on a Nursing Unit

On the other hand, disciplinary actions are means of dealing with unfavorable job-related behavior, especially those which do not meet with work and performance standards (US Legal, 2012). The primary purpose of these actions is to support the employee in understanding that performance issues for improvement exist. It is basically a way of imposing discipline for the employees (Hessler and Humphreys, 2008). While constructive criticisms provide a means for the employee to re-evaluate his actions and further improve on these, disciplinary actions are imposed punishment for failing to live up to the standards of the practice (Kennedy, 2006). Constructive criticism is more palatable for employees who can choose to consider the criticism as a means of improving their practice; however disciplinary actions are mostly met with disfavor due to its final and imposing nature on the work of employees (Hendren, 2011). B. What are likely outcomes to delivered action? 1. In order to deliver the necessary actions while still retaining employee productivity, it is important to first identify the unacceptable action, specifically indicating what the staff member is doing or is failing to do well (Hendren, 2011). The focus in effect is in the action, not the behavior or his personality. Specifying what the employee did wrong is also an essential part of achieving the best outcomes in establishing constructive criticism (Nursing Times, 2007). It is also important to explain the outcome, which behavior is not acceptable and how the action negatively impacts on productivity and on patient outcomes. Descriptive terms must also be used in order to establish how the behavior is wrong and how such behavior can be changed (Nursing Times, 2007). The expectations must also be indicated and clearly established from the very start. The employee must know what behavior is unacceptable and the various actions which can be applied to improve behavior. 2. Personal feelings must also be set aside when giving constructive criticism. There are various outcomes to delivered action and for employees, their actions may produce unfavorable or favorable outcomes (Nursing Times, 2007). In giving feedback to employees, personal and subjective opinions have to be set aside (Clynes and Raftery, 2008). Saying to the employee that they are “useless” is an unnecessary comment and achieves nothing except feelings of discontent in the employee. It degrades the employee and makes his performance even worse (Nursing Times, 2007). Instead, the focus of the criticism must be on the activity, what was not done, what was done well, and what the criticism would be expected to achieve. The criticism must also be clear and concise, as well as professional, indicating positive feedback with information on how to improve actions and performance (Hendren, 2011). Asking the employee how he feels about his performance is a means of achieving improved outcomes and constructive benefits for the overall nursing profession. The manner of giving the feedback must focus on the problem, not the individual (Hendren, 2011). It must be direct and not contain any mixed and confusing elements. It must also be given in person and in private, preventing any embarrassment for individuals involved. The employee should also be involved in the discussion, allowing him to express his issues with his work, and inquiring about his coping skills and difficulties (Nursing Times, ...Show more


Constructive criticism versus disciplinary actions on a nursing unit I. Constructive Criticism vs Disciplinary Actions on a nursing unit A. Define constructive criticism vs disciplinary actions 1. Constructive construction is an important part of the manager's role…
Author : mrazjade
Constructive Criticism vs Disciplinary Actions on a Nursing Unit essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Constructive Criticism vs Disciplinary Actions on a Nursing Unit"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Disciplinary actions
Even without the interference of these external forces, it is essential that an organization eliminates any form of discrimination from its employment process be it in-house or external so as not to soil the name of the company and drive its image down as a result.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Implenting Dorothy Orem's nursing theory on a psychiatric practice unit
The theory seeks to attest that the patients embrace the desire to presume their personal care, thus the contribution of nurses is considered as a supplementary benefit. This assumption can be used to develop an increased perception of the encounters that define nursing, especially the contributions of the nurses towards the sustainability of the effective patient protection.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Disciplinary Action by the Texas Board of Nursing
An RN is obligated to advance the patient’s best interests without any form of partiality. He or she should espouse kindness and reverence for the sick person, irrespective of the patient's gender, age, citizenship, ethnicity or health status (Law, & Marks, 2013).
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Constructive Trust Law
And when these two words join in a sentence where a level of consciousness is reached to give a righteous decision, then we tend to believe that the judgment is an accurate one. So, what is the definition of trust in a legal context There is a myriad of definitions because each trust case carries its specific characteristics making it a unique entity of its own.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
No Tolerance Disciplinary Policy
These policies may address issues such as sexual harassment, workplace violence, stealing, racial comments or observations, lethargic approaches to work and other activities which may harm the company or any of its employee's interests. Anybody disobeying the policies implemented is usually suspended or fired due to the nature of these policies.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Planning Disciplinary Interview
This case is the first disciplinary issue since the D@W program was delivered. Personally, I do not know the employee. Hence, I had asked for the employee's record to check if he had earlier been involved in any such incident. I found that this employee's record is clear of any untoward incident, and the incident under investigation is the first one in his four years' tenure with the company (Disciplinary procedure, April 2008).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Quality vs. Quantity in the Nursing Profession
Thankfully new trends and policies in education helped augment the shortages created in the past few years. But is there enough run for a patient's health and wealth with the commercialization and the state of the nursing education Sure, there is a global need for nurses - but ought we to sacrifice quality for quantity
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Constructive criticism vs disciplinary actions on a nursing unit
On the other hand, disciplinary actions are means of dealing with unfavorable job-related behavior, especially those which do not meet with work and
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Attorney disciplinary board vs. Moothart
The complaint alleged that Moothart, the respondent, in this case, engaged in sexual harassment with the five women while in the practice of law, which was a violation of Iowa’s rule of professional conduct. The attorney sexually harassed the first woman when he made crude sexual comments about her body.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Disciplinary Procedures
In a typical workplace, there is a lot of interaction among the employees, the executive, and between the employees and the employer. This interaction has mixed results, including improved interpersonal relationships and often, conflict. When there is a difference in opinion and interests, workers may resort to inappropriate methods to settle scores.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment