StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Case Study Analysis: Ethical Issues - Essay Example

Free

Extract of sample
Case Study Analysis: Ethical Issues

However, the government changed its laws regarding the rights of minor patients recently; and at present, a competent minor patient has the right to refuse any treatment proposed for him. In addition, parents have many rights over their children, especially when their child is a minor. The case scenario clearly tells that Tyrell is a competent 14 year old boy and he and his parents are devout fundamentalist Christians. They jointly decided to refuse the planned leg amputation and leave his death in God’s hands. Similarly, physicians have also a set of rights over their patients. A physician has the ultimate right to decide which treatment option would be the best for a particular patient. Hence, the case reflects various stakeholders’ rights from different perspectives. 2. From my view point, the rights of Tyrell’s parents should take precedence since US constitutional rights allow parents to make decisions on behalf of their children. “The US Supreme Court recognized that parents possess the requisite knowledge and experience to make decisions for their children” (as cited in O’Connor, 2009). Hence, it must be noted that the parents’ decision is not against Tyrell’s interest. ...
Tyrell does not wish to undergo the leg amputation process and his decision is supported by his parents. Although this decision is obviously likely to threaten Tyrell’s life, the treating physicians do not have the right to overrule the decision made by Tyrell and his parents. Hence, here the health care team

Related Essays

ENVIROMNMENTEL ANALYSIS CASE STUDY
The total sales for the 2010 period amounted to around $405 billion. Total manpower strength of Wal-Mart stands to around 2.1 million people operating along the global sphere. The company was ranked the first by Fortune Magazine in 2010 as the world’s most admired retail company.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Comair Flight 5191: An Ethical case study
Since it is impossible to determine a single factor that resulted in the crash of Flight 5191, the NTSB should look at all the components of the system that were not functioning at their optimal level, and single them out for improvement, starting with the ones that have the most effect. For instance, any design errors of the airport and management issues among other factors.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Ethical case study( The loss of the Shuttle Columbia)
The study critically analyzed the major issues and ethical lapses that allowed the incident to occur. The recommended actions include a culture change at NASA, effective leadership, improved communication systems, stronger regulation and better focus on the research and development of space shuttles.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Application of Ethical Theory to a Case Study Vignette
The author of this analytical essay uses a case study to depict the ethical dilemma. The author of the essay compares different approaches to analyze the sensitive topic of ethical dilemma in business organization. For example, he discusses and compares consequentialist theory and deontological theories.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Business and Society. Business Ethics. Application of ethical theory to a case study
As a means of understanding and elaborating upon this, key factors of the thought process and decision making regime that Tom adopted throughout the case study will be analysed along with the motivating factors that eventually spurred him to represent another individual’s work as his own original.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Human Diversity and Ethical Practice in Mental Health: A Case Study and Analysis
This study will examine coping mechanisms, analyze and diagnose John's case, and conclude with a brief overview of the role of a mental health nurse in the promotion and distribution of health care, with a specific focus on how human diversity should inform and determine the practice of ethical standards in mental health care.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Critical analysis case study
21-28). However, since the PD was not helping his condition that deteriorated gradually, the need for multiple decisions arose among four main components of
19 pages (4750 words) Essay
Ethical case study
According to NASA, pilots, retired pilots and workers at the airport, the mistake made by the pilots of Comair Flight 5191 was not unique and many other pilots had
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
This Case Study Analysis coursework consists in writing an ethical reasoning and critical argument to identify, discuss and address potential ethical issues for a given computing project
Nevertheless, the technological environment created by the development of information technology systems has been confronted by a lot of ethical issues. Ethical issues with regard to information
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
American and Chinese Business Ethic Culture
The American culture of legal universality seeks to establish a business environment where all the players are treated equally, it tends to entrench law into the ethical system, such that the ethical perspective is lost. Owing to the fact that the relevance of ethics in the business environment is to enhance the development of ideologies.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
cannot execute its planned leg amputation process even though this treatment option is obviously better for Tyrell. 3. Normally, a child does not have the right to determine what will happen to him. However, under certain circumstances, the US law allows a minor to refuse any type of medication. The ‘mature minor’ doctrine was evolved as a result of many hot debates over minors’ right to refuse medication. As O’Connor (2009) describes, according to this doctrine, some minors are competent enough to assess different treatment options and make sound decisions; and although courts allow mature minors to refuse treatment options, none of these courts has set a specific age limit above which a child can be considered as a mature minor. Hence, there are still many ambiguities regarding whether or not a child should be considered as a mature minor. According to the scenario, Tyrell is competent, and hence, he has the mental ability to evaluate his health condition and thereby accept or refuse the planned leg amputation process. Ethically, Tyrell must be entitled to enjoy this right. The case study reflects that Tyrell is a 14 years old boy and hence it is a tough option for him to live the remaining life without one leg. Therefore, Tyrell should have the right to refuse the planned amputation and seek for other alternative therapies. 4. If the state of Tyrell’s disease had not intervened by the doctors,

Summary

Case Study Analysis:  Ethical Issues (Add (Add (Add Date) Case Study Analysis:  Ethical Issues 1. The given case study addresses compelling rights of a minor patient, his parents, and physicians. In this case context, Tyrell Dueck (the 14 year old patient) and his parents refuses the medically prescribed leg amputation on the ground of their religious beliefs…
Author : jkunze
Case Study Analysis: Ethical Issues essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation