Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Critical analysis of Qualitative paper - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : osinskijerrold

Summary

Critical analysis of a Qualitative and Quantitative Article Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Introduction A critique is a proficient scrutiny of the flaws and potencies of a particular piece of research. A critique can be done for a range of rationales which include assessing whether this study should be published; presenting useful remarks on the study before being published; or, as the case here, providing familiarityand an opportunity for the up-and-coming scholars to apply their budding research skills (Polit& Beck 2008)…

Extract of sample
Critical analysis of Qualitative paper

Topics and introductions of the articles In Both articles, titles are good title particularly because they are both informatory and refer to the key phenomenon of the study. However, Dietrich et al’s title is goes further to expounds on the key variables.Though they have failed to include the study population,both researches the problems of the research are stated unequivocally and build coherent and credible arguments which have significance for nursing profession.Both Olrich et al (2012) and Deitrick et al (2012) studies have also failed to stipulate the research questions or a hypothesis of the studies and this is also considered as a flaw in the studies. Methods and designs of the studies There is debate regarding whether the standards used for quantitative studies should be used for qualitative research has existed for a long time and will probably continue with the trend (Strauss and Corbin, 1998). The research approach used in the qualitative was the ethnography approach, which means that there was a conscious effort by the researchers in examining and exploring a cultural phenomenon (Bernardo, 2007). ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Critical Analysis of a Quantative Study
When a study is to be conducted, the protection of the human participants or respondents is an issue of primary importance. Essentially, all participants have to be fully aware of their role in the study and what the study is all about. It is important that they are informed of the benefits they can gain from participating in the study as well as the risks that they face. In this particular study by Miyashita, et al. (2006), no particular benefit was provided by the investigators that the respondents stood to gain by participating. The authors also did not provide any risks that the…
A qualitative research critique
Concerning these challenges, there are various guidelines developed in the past few years that can be utilised while examining a qualitative research paper, such as the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) framework (Mack & et. al., 2010). There are various aspects which needs utmost consideration while critiquing a qualitative research. For instance, the coherence of the topic being critiqued should be appropriate for the qualitative enquiry (Boswell & Cannon, 2010). It is also vital for the literature review to be consistent with the methods that has been selected for the study. The…
18 pages (4518 words)
Analysis and implications for practice of qualitative Research Report
The research report was published in 2006. With changing social values and demographics, long-term care demand is also increasing in facilities. The number of patients spending time in nursing homes before their deaths is increasing, and is expected to increase further in the next coming years. Pneumonia is a major cause of mortality and morbidity among residents of nursing homes, which consequently lead to their hospitalization according to Carusone, Loeb & Lohfeld (2006). Therefore, a research to determine the best way to handle pneumonia patients was carried out form the family member and…
3 pages (753 words)
A Critical Analysis of Teaching and Learning
Therefore, good clinical and academic settings are necessary for students to achieve effective learning results. Consequently, present day nursing educators exert a high value and emphasize much on students to learn in a clinical environment (Doenges & Morehouse, 2003). In this respect, this paper intends to outline instances where teaching and learning are effective in nursing environment. Additionally, it also seeks to outline barriers that exist to effective learning and teaching in the clinical nursing environment and select strategies along with their implementation details and processes.…
5 pages (1255 words)
Qualitative vs. Quantitative Research
Quantitative research can be defined as a method of systematic experimental inquiry of social phenomena with statistical, mathematical or other graphical techniques. Furthermore, the prime objective of quantitative research is to generate and to utilize mathematical models, hypothesis and theories among others to appropriately derive accurate findings related to any phenomenon (Sukamolson, 2005). The paper intends to discuss and to differentiate between qualitative and quantitative research. The differences of the research methods will be recognized through the types of questions and methods…
8 pages (2008 words)
Qualitative critique
The study population is well defined; old people with multiple sclerosis (Ploughman et al., 2012). The abstract outlines the purposes, methods used to conduct the study, the results of the data collected, and the conclusions. The abstract in this study is in itself adequate. It presents the whole research from the objectives of the research, through the whole process and presents a conclusion of study at the end. The highlights on the purposes of the study outline what the study is all about, and this is critical in the beginning of any research where the reasons for conducting the research…
5 pages (1255 words)
critical analysis of a qualitative study
The clinical or medical impact that healthcare team members can derive from continued exposure to facial transplantation led to the study. The research problem relates to the fact that no conclusive research explores the personal, professional, and ethical experiences and perceptions of the healthcare team members who have participated in facial transplant procedures, whose attitudes and experiences may consequently influence patient care (Evans, 2013). Therefore, the study seeks to address this knowledge gap using an ethical approach. Notably, we should care about this study as it derives the…