StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • People
  • Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does

Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does - Book Report/Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does

Aside from such court cases, there is also an ongoing public discussion of the possible limits for the equality between men and women (Halford and Leonard, 2001; Karsten, 1993). Indeed, as when placed in similar circumstances men and women may tend to behave in different ways, it is necessary to have a better knowledge of existing difference and, also importantly, of sameness between general effectiveness of men and women within the same fields of activity. In this regard, Sarah Rutherford, a consultant specialising in organisational culture and diversity, in her article "Any Difference An Analysis of Gender and Divisional management Styles in a Large Airline" provides results of a very insightful research that explores a specific aspect of the sameness/difference between women and men, namely their managerial approaches, and does so in a specific and at the same time quite representative environment, namely in a large airline. Let us take a closer look at the research of Rutherford, single out important conclusions that she reaches, and try link her contribution with wider debates on management and gender.
Sarah Rutherford opens her article with the general observations about the ongoing debate "as to whether woman manage differently from men and whether this may constitute a reason for womens lack of progress to the top echelons of organizations" (Rutherford, 2001, p.326). In this way, by presupposing the possibility of existence of real barriers for the career progress of women in business on par with men she immediately suggests that the topic of her research may be placed into the wider social context of what she calls "a feminist theoretical framework" (Rutherford, 2001, p.326) that recognises that inequalities exist. At the same time, Rutherford quickly moves on to an assumption that in reality things may be more complex and that it may prove to be quite difficult to clearly separate management peculiarities dictated by individual traits, including the gender of a manager, from those dictated by business function and specifics of an organisation. Also, before detailing the findings of her research the author expands the relevant underlying theoretical base by discussing the very notions of masculinity and femininity as not determinants based purely on biological differences between genders but as socially constructed behavioural patterns. For example, she points out that display of a certain range of emotions that both genders experience is traditionally considered to be a feminine way of reaction, an observation which will be very useful later in the article. So, already in this part of the article we encounter one of the very important points of the author that as far as masculine and feminine social roles have corresponding modes of behaviour, it is possible for men to mimic feminine roles, and vice versa. As will be evident from the authors report of the results of the research, this phenomenon indeed takes place, and, moreover, its usage by both genders is perhaps the most influential factor in the part of management discourse which deals with differences between managerial peculiarities of men and women. In fact, this early observation is very important for wider debates on management and gender as it rightfully broadens the scope of traditional feminist criticism of existing inequalities in treatment of men and women. It does so by pointing out that such strategies as the adoption by woman ...Show more

Summary

One of the prominent developments of the twentieth century in the Western world was the rise and wide expansion of feminist world views. As a consequence of that process, many of the existing inequalities that negatively influenced women in social, economic, and cultural spheres were removed or significantly reduced…
Author : lily02
Review Sarah Rutherfords (2001) article on sameness difference in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Article Review
Carroll and Kareem, M. Shabana, in “The Business Case for Corporate Social Responsibility: A Review of Concept, Research and Practice”, introduces issues of cooperate social responsibility concern by various stakeholders and business community. The articles explore the concern of businesses in pursuing CSR policies and strategies on their financial system.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Article review
40). Three important facts mentioned in the article are first, that children learn through play, secondly, that it is difficult for educators fully to realise the potential of play and thirdly, that self-regulatory abilities impact significantly on learning over the longer term.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Article Review
Google is renowned for its innovations in the field of information technology. In recent years, the company has ventured into creating hardware for that would complement and support its popular software applications. Google’s search engine is its flagship product which is very prevalent across the world.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Article review
This is interesting as it gives a lively opening to the article. The article focus on the cognitive impression of advertisement and the impact it have on the media. The article initiates with an advertisement where a man go for higher studies in France and get his education and marries a Parisienne woman and settles there.
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
Article review
The review seeks to identify the constituents of corporate social responsibility and the ideal protocol of engaging them to acquire the set goals and objectives. Archie connotes several items in the article that are salient to deciphering the desired relevance upon the business environment.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Article review
In the beginning, it was not clear what corporate social responsibility entailed, except for the fact that organizations had a financial obligation to the immediate environment. However, it became clear that social responsibility entailed more than just the financial debt to the community.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Review of Women directors contribution to Board Decision-making
The study highlighted women’s professional experiences, as well as values, preferences, and beliefs, as influencing factors in the decision-making and strategic involvement
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Article Review
Since managers are expected to perform multiple functions therefore having concrete goals and a system of achieving them allows managers to achieve their goals effectively. With sample selected from senior and middle management in hospitality
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Review article
There has been an extensive contention in the definition of the culture of poverty advanced by Lewis (1966). He describes it as a conceptual model that describes a subculture of the western society that has its own unique structure and rationale; it is a way of
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Article Review
Herein, it is highly imperative to understand the main objective of the article i.e. capitalism being on siege as more and more social, economic, and political problems are being given rise by
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation