Euthanasia - Essay Example


Extract of sample

As a means of understanding his argument to a more complete degree, the following analysis will integrate with some of his main points and seek to differentiate whether or not his approach is effective and/or reasonable. Firstly, with regards to the ethics of physician-assisted suicide, this is a topic that Velleman discusses prior to engaging on any other point. Rather than say that this practice is patently wrong in each and every situation, he instead says that there are clear cases in which medical care should be withdrawn so that life can end; however, he makes it clear that he is entirely against any active administration of life-ending toxins or drugs to the patient; viewing this as a clear abrogation of the Hippocratic Oath. . Within such an understanding, the reader can come to full appreciation for how these conflicting responsibilities make the decision of the physician, with respect to aiding in suicide of the patient or not, an extraordinarily complex one. However, given his firm approach to the fact that the doctor or healthcare provider should not actively assist in ending life; Velleman comes down solidly on the side of those that would seek to outlaw the practice of physician assisted suicide entirely; based upon moral and historical interpretations of what the role of the physician/healthcare provider necessarily means. As a means of understanding the ongoing debate that exists with regards to physician-assisted suicide, it is not only necessary to understand and appreciate the level to which the Hippocratic Oath impacts upon the physician’s decision, it is also necessary to understand the debate is concentric around whether or not issues concerning cost savings should be considered, whether or not the ultimate wishes of the patient are primal and supersede all others, whether or not the process itself lens too much of an authoritarian decision-making structure to the physician is, and whether or not such a process actually demeans the value of human life or seeks to promote dignity to such a degree that it elevates the value of human life. These are all cases that Velleman considers and ultimately rectifies these with his views against the “right to die” as he labels it. Most refreshing of all of the views put forward by Velleman is the fact that he is clearly aware of the fact that his viewpoint cannot possibly consider all externalities and each and every situation (Velleman, 1992). As such, he mentions this twice within his analysis; once in the introduction and once in the conclusion. Such an admission only helps to add further weight to the discussion and exhibit the fact that Velleman has thoughtfully contributed to the body of knowledge surrounding the issue; both with respect to the moral and ethical issues that necessarily directly and indirectly impact upon it.It is unlikely the debate’s earning physician-assisted suicide will be answered any time within and your future. Just as it is taken many decades for civil rights to be fully realized within the United States and just as it continues to take year after year to promote a further level of homosexual rights that are comparable to the many heterosexual rights that are currently exhibited within society, it will also doubtless take a great deal of time before a level of liberalization is noted with respect to a societal interpretation of this process. Ultimately, it is the belief of this author that physician-assisted suicide is not a pleasant option; however, in the right situations, it is not only humane but beneficial due to the fact that it allows a dignified and painless exit torments and trauma that many individuals face as a result of illness and/or disease. ...
Download paper


Whereas suicide has been an alternative individuals to into their lives since the dawn of human history, physician-assisted suicide is something of a new paradigm that allows for individuals who are otherwise terminally ill or have little hope of surviving a particular disease or illness to terminate their lives in what has been deemed as a dignified manner…
Author : iritchie
Download 2

Related Essays

The concept of Euthanasia or Physician Assisted Suicide is one such idea which has been subjected to many moral and ethical implications. The word euthanasia actually means “good death” and it is also sometimes referred to as “mercy killing.” It is a practice whereby the life of an individual is ended with the assistance of physicians to end the agonizing state and misery of a patient. The subject has sparked many controversies globally and many nations across the world have taken the bold step of legalizing this practice. Euthanasia is a practice which is mainly for the good of the...
4 pages (1004 words) Research Paper
Euthanasia and our civilization
Right in the beginning, the essay makes a clear understanding of joy and suffering being part of life and it is the duty if the community to provide assistance to those who suffers. Encouraging people to commit suicide is the failure of a society. It is dangerous to allow a physician to decide whether a patient’s life is not worth living. Even after huge advancements in science and technology, we are still unable to unveil the secrets behind birth and life after death. Then the essay provides an example of Oregon, which is currently the only state that has an assisted-suicide law. On January...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Euthanasia Term Paper
The American Medical Association holds that active euthanasia is impermissible due to its involving the intentional ending of human life by another human being and many contemporary philosophers have argued for and against this view discussing the moral permissibility of such an action and some of the most notable arguments come from James Rachels and Thomas Sullivan. Rachels states that a strong case can be made against the American Medical Association’s doctrine and his main point is that passive euthanasia is not always preferable to active euthanasia. He states that in some cases, there...
4 pages (1004 words) Term Paper
Euthanasia Or Abortion
The older concept was never differentiated from suicide and both activities were seen as similar in historic times and the definition assigned to the word euthanasia was very different from current world’s definition. In the Greek period, the act of euthanasia was recognized a means of death which was happy and satisfactory in nature and was hardly ever used and it was not used as a means of assisted suicide or mercy killing as it is use today. The meaning of the concept of euthanasia has experienced various changes in English language. In different periods, in different cultures, the...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
The American Medical Association embraces the belief that active euthanasia is not acceptable due to the involvement of the intentional ending of a patient’s life by another human being. Many current thinkers have argued for and against this view discussing the moral acceptability of such an action, and some of the most notable arguments come from James Rachels. Rachels states that a strong case can be made against the American Medical Association’s doctrine. His main point is that passive euthanasia is not always preferable to active euthanasia: he states that, in some cases, there is...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Euthanasia can be the choice of the an individual and may be unassisted or assisted, by physicians, family, or friends. However, it should be clear that all variations of euthanasia have been deemed illegal in most locations. Suicide has always been a controversial issue. The moral beliefs of certain popular ideologies deem suicide a great sin, which can lead to the mindset that if you suffer greatly then you probably deserve to and when you die, that is when you were meant to. However, that thinking is not shared by everyone and to impose that mentality and force people to suffer until...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!