"preservationist" and "liberationist" - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
"preservationist" and "liberationist"

Looking at this solution with regards to the sedan issue, making moral decisions using the preservationist mode seems to be both plausible and reasonable. As stated by Unger, majority of persons would aid the birdwatcher in spite of any loss financially in order for him not to lose his limb. There is further proof for this sentiment from the class discussion as the majority of the class agrees that, helping the man would be the best solution in spite of the damage that would befall the sedan. Most people would not think twice with regards to aiding the man who is admitted to the hospital; if the man is bleeding in front of them in utter agony. However, when considering the UNICEF envelope, the preservationist solution will not fare so well and the liberationist view is the best. As stated by Unger, many people are likely to throw the envelope away sans any second thoughts. This would be their initial instinctive response, and they would not have any second thoughts (Nadelhoffer et al 42). However, majority would agree that, through the use of moral standards, it is imperative to help those who are hungry in the same way as one would help the man who is about to lose a limb. ...
Download paper

Summary

Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Preservationist and Liberationist Views Peter Unger in Living High and Letting Die presents what are two very different dilemmas of a moral nature. The tow scenarios give us insight with regards to the human condition in a way that humans are responsive to them, rather than simply in their context…
Author : wintheisertaure

Related Essays

Capital Punishment in film “Dead Man Walking”
The film “Dead Man Walking” depicts the appeal process faced by a convicted murderer, and how his crime, trial and acts on death row affect himself, a nun who is working with him on his appeal, and the families of the victims. It invokes some of the hardest and most troubling questions facing society today such as: does the state have the right to kill its own citizens? and ‘is it ever right to kill?’. Philosophers and thinkers have been struggling with these same questions for thousands of years. Somewhat surprisingly in a field where many experts disagree with each other, three of…
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
A Philosophical Review of Nature's and Animal Rights
In contrast, Tom Regan disputes that there is a difference between ‘having an interest in something’ and ‘taking an interest in it’ (Varner, 1998, 55), which then implies that domestic species, being mindless species, have innate biological interests. Regan thus defined biological interest in this way: “the two senses really are logically distinct: A being can be interested in something that is not in his interests, and something may be in a being’s interest despite the fact that he is not interested in” (Varner, 1998, 55). This means that domestic species, having no conscious…
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Major Depression Disorder
Introduction Depression refers to the feeling of sadness, grief and disappointment in many ways. Major depression could at times refer to as clinical depression. Depression drives individuals into constant sense of helplessness and loss of self-confidence. According to research carried undertaken by the National Institute of Mental Health, major depression affects more than 6.7% of the US population under the age of 18 years. The research further unveiled that between 20-25 % of the American population are likely to undergo through periods of clinical depreciation. According to WebMD (2011),…
3 pages (753 words) Research Paper
sermon on mount
‘ To love is to will good for someone’ (Kraut, 3-20) Thus, it is sensible to do all we can to see a different person get and have a good life no matter how great ones life does not seem to be. The need to write on the topic on the sermon on the mount is to clarify various confusions cited by people each time on the relevance of the topic (Prabhavananda, 13). Using different theories of various philosophers is important to create a substantial evidence as well as to leave any unanswered questions answered fully. Some critics have paid tribute to it since it is the best benevolent teachings…
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
the essential characteristics of loving
Consequently, they do not idealize it but rather assess the state of erotic relationships as such in (their) present condition and make the remarks about potential changes. Sigmund Freud is troubled by the level of neurosis in his contemporaries. Though he emphasizes his neutrality as a physician (“On the Universal Tendency to Debasement in the Sphere of Love” 6), the very nature of his text is performative: they are too rich in anecdotes, interesting cases, and witty quotes to be called totally neutral. According to Freud, present society is on the third level of restriction of sexuality:…
6 pages (1506 words) Assignment
Outline and critique the subjective interpretation of probability
In normal conversations, one might say “the storm will hit the city”, usually, the person does not imply that the storm hitting the or not hitting the city is a random factor and that the odds presently favour, such a person in normal conversation qualifies the statement to a degree of confidence. When in a newspaper it is written “the most probable explanation” of the Mother Gaston Boulevard Street in Brooklyn, New York is that it was named after Mother Rosetta Gaston. The statement does not imply that Mother Rosetta Gatson is not favoured by a random factor, but it is pretty much the…
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!