General Kantian Perspective on Punishment. - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
General Kantian Perspective on Punishment.

In this theory, punishment is not justified by any good results but by the guilt of the criminal and therefore, a criminal must pay for their misdoings in a way that is proportional to the harm inflicted by their wrongdoing. This was very common in many traditions and it is clearly seen in the Jewish tradition in the Bible specifically in the Law of Moses. In the event that a person is tried and found guilty and punishable of a crime, the individual automatically forfeits or suspends an equal value of his or her right to something. Kant contends that the punishment must fit the crime committed and argues that a crime committed to another person is a crime perpetrated to one self. He contends that the most appropriate punishment for a murderer is capital punishment (execution). If a person who has committed a murder is allowed to live, justice is not done and this exemplifies a subversion of justice and the very essence of humanity in the world. ...
Download paper

Summary

A Kantian is a proponent of the retributive theory of punishment that was put forward by the German Law philosopher Immanuel Kant. …
Author : dustylarkin

Related Essays

Kantian Philosophy
In my attempt to delineate what is universal and empirical in Kant’s philosophical though and inquiry, I shall explore the connection between happiness and goodness and provide a logical analysis on my part to clearly show how a certain thing can be empirical or universal. At the same time, I shall work on the idea of reason in influencing how happiness and goodness work in relation to the universal and the empirical. Principle of a good will is important because it determines the extent and the scope of what might be the effect and the accomplishments of it. Having such condition, it can be...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Kantian Sincerity and Professional Ethics
Sincerity makes him weigh his acts according to ethics. Kantian sincerity explains the aspects of sincerity based on good will. This paper intends to explain the essence of Kantian sincerity, and how it can relate to professional ethics and good will. The importance of professional ethics in the life of an organization is discussed, in correlation with Kantian sincerity. The characteristics of a sincere and ethical leader have been described, so as to give the reader an idea as to what is expected of a person who follows Kantian sincerity and ethical guidelines. Kantian sincerity is based on...
4 pages (1004 words) Assignment
Death Penalty, Kantian Ethics, and Utilitarianism
The argument that almost everyone would prefer life imprisonment than execution is often put forward by these people. But I do not agree at all with this argument as it does not hold any weightage in my point of view. ...
9 pages (2259 words) Essay
Kantian Philosophy
Conversely, the standards were either only based on desire and the tools of rationality or were emphasized on sui generis rational instincts. Kant also approved the basic principles described by his predecessors that were an examination of the practical reasons which will disclose the obligation that the rational mediators must rely on to believe in instrumental principles (Guyer, 2006). ...
5 pages (1255 words) Term Paper
Kantian Morality
One of the most attractive aspects of Kantian morality is its simplicity. By this point of the course, the reader should understand that simplicity alone is a bit of a scary metric to seek to objectify and judge a philosophical approach; however, for purposes of this brief response paper, this particular student will seek to weigh and analyze the Kantian approach to morality through the rubric of suitability for worldwide adaptation, rationality, and present a list of positive and negative externalities that necessarily would exist if such an approach were to be adopted wholesale. As a...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Kantian Argument
Budeau and Marshal Bedau and Cassell Budeau and marshal hold that the death penalty is morally wrong regardless of the crime committed by the offender. Both opponents of the death penalty have suggested that when analyzing whether a certain crime fit a given punishment, one must look at the impact of the punishment. This includes both the criminal and the society at large (Bedau and Cassell 118). The two argue out that capital punishment creates biased sense of security within the society. Community members feel better in the knowledge that the capital punishment is an option for a severe...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Kantian Moral Theory
In order to achieve the above task the paper has been divided in four parts. Firstly it is important to identify the methods of justification used by Kant in Groundwork of Metaphysics of Moral. A general overview is also made regarding the value of Kant's work for the researchers in the area of moral philosophy. From that the second part of this essay refers to the theories of justification used by other philosophers, namely Rawls and Hare. This essay would argue that although many of Kant's concepts are used, the extent to which they served as models of theory justification is rather some...
20 pages (5020 words) Book Report/Review
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!