“The Meeting:” the problem of personal identity.

“The Meeting:” the problem of personal identity. Essay example
College
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 3 (753 words)
Download 0
Harry Vladek is in a dilemma. The reader is deeply moved by his anguished, “I don’t know what to do. I don’t know who to go to.” (Pohl and Kornbluth, 189). He hopes passionately that the school will bring about improvement in Tommy…

Introduction

Harry Vladek is in a dilemma. The reader is deeply moved by his anguished, “I don’t know what to do. I don’t know who to go to.” (Pohl and Kornbluth, 189). He hopes passionately that the school will bring about improvement in Tommy. However, this improvement appears to be on the miniscule scale of drawing a cartoon face or taking “his thumb out of his mouth for minutes at a time” (187). Mrs. Adler cannot promise Harry a cure, or a normal life for his son. She fails to give him a definite assurance that Tommy was “ever going to be like everybody else” . Harry also worries about Tommy’s fate after the demise of his parents. As he picks up the phone, it may be assumed that Harry opts for the brain transplant surgery proposed by Dr. Nicholson. The successful operation will result in the other boy’s brain living on in Tommy’s body. The survivor of the brain transplant is not Tommy Vladek as Tommy’s personal identity is lost according to the theories of self. Harry Vladek subscribes to the traditional theory of self. To him, deciding to allow the brain transplant is equivalent to deciding “to murder my son”.He does not base his idea of personal identity on the Body Theory, which proposes ‘Same body, same self.’ Only if the body is accepted as being the basis of identity can the survivor be his son.Obviously,Harry does not consider the body to be the basis of identity. Harry leans towards the Soul Theory. This maybe because he has religious beliefs, as seen in his considering whether “to talk to the priest” . ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

The Mind/Body Problem
One research line states that some mind-body problems come from artificial intelligence research. One such problem can be solved by the clear knowledge hardware and software interaction and relationship. The other line of research shows that mind-body relation might be illuminated by the study of emergence in the biological systems. Mind-body dualism or dualism is a theory that holds that minds…
Personal Identity and the Self
In addition, the condition has been diagnosed to a significant number of patients found in psychiatric hospitals. MPD, also known as dissociative identity disorder, has many implications as to what it is to be a person at a particular time as well as over a period of time. This essay will seek to discuss these implications, with special reference to “Kim Noble: The Woman with 100…
Personal Identity
Are There Other Features That Need To Be Factored In As Well, Or Instead? Overall, What Factors Are Indispensable For Establishing And Sustaining Our Identity Over Time? The mind deals with many concepts that include our beliefs, desires, sensations, emotions and passions among other things (Wiggins, 2007). The philosophies of the mind involve studies that are carried out to determine the nature…
Personal identity
Basically, the personality identity of a person is totally constituent to the relation of brute physicality and either different bodies or the systems that sustain life although this should be at different time. The body theory states that we usually use human body criterion to identify ourselves time and again. Schick and Vaughn believed that in the case of person changing his or her body with…
The problem of evil
This is not however the case and the controversy induces dilemma on both believers and non-believers. This paper explores the concept of the problem of evil. Concepts of the problem of evil The problem of evil arises from the scope of nature that identifies conflicts in theories in existence of evil and God’s characteristics. This is because a consideration of the nature of God and His power…
Personal Identity & Immortality
Millers main line of argument is that there is a correlation between body and soul and that even if the body dies, the soul may continue to live. Weiroib disputed this by asserting that there is no evidence that the soul exist and therefore we should not easily assume that something we know not of its existence will help us survive after we are dead (Perry 397). Here, miller tries to ask his…
Identity of the Internet
The enlightenment concept identity tells us basically that the real world of physical actual touching of hands and face to face feelings of reactions and transactions, like blowing of the wind against your face as you feel love travel between lovers. The MUD is the "growing to manhood" of this 18th century thinking but variations have result for the better. Just as a man (MUD) is wiser than a…