StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Moral judgement from utilitarianism's point of view and my own - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Moral judgement from utilitarianism's point of view and my own

In this case, utilitarian reasoning will definitely through many people into confusion and they will find themselves in dilemmas when they are supposed to make decisions especially decisions concerning human life. Here is a case where a runway trolley is just about to kill five people. However, the runway trolley can be sidetracked using a switch and in this situation it will only kill one person and save the rest. As a person making the decision, what is the right thing to do? Because utilitarian theory suggests that, our decision must maximize the overall good, then the switch must be switched in order to kill one person and save the five. However, the big question is whether this is morally right addition to this, utilitarian theory requires that we put the interest of the group first and not the individual. This is because individuals possess a different degree of pleasure and pain. The moral rule for utilitarian are more general than ones specific moral judgment and it`s cannot be equated with any of the ethical principles since it will results to the greatest happiness only to greatest number of people but fails to consider the welfare and happiness of the minority. However, utilitarianism still demands and does all that is required to save the greatest number of lives in the runway trolley incident. It`s better to save and salvage the lives of more people than to only save one live. This will definitely cause lesser pain as far as the number of people that were to be affected by this runway trolley tragedy is concerned. When the runway trolley is sidetracked using a switch and so it kills one person the utilitarianism argument is achieved in full force which, in this case, is the morally right thing to do. However, according to my own point of view, I slightly differ with the utilitarian point of view. While utilitarianism advocates for maximizing the good for the majority, I strongly feel the need and good for the minority can supersede the majority`s need for good. If the son of God was a utilitarian, it would have been worthless for Him to look for the lost sheep and bring it back home. Besides, if the father of the prodigal son in the bible was also a utilitarian, he would have not considered and get bothered bringing his son back home. Well my point is that utilitarianism only does what it takes to scarify the good of the minority in favor for the good of majority which is, in my opinion, is against my belief as a Christian and strong follower of Jesus and His teachings. In the runway trolley incident, they would have not sidetracked the runway trolley using a switch to kill the individual but instead they would have left nature and fate to dictate the finally ending of the tragedy. Although utilitarianism will make many people happy, I will have acted in the interest of many people but what makes other people happy is not what makes me happy. Our degree of happiness is different. Therefore, my own point of view concerning this incident was to let the runway trolley kill whoever it will kill and spare whoever it will spare. This was the moral thing to do in this case according to my moral rule even though the utilitarianism reasoning and advocacy does not require and demands that . Even though the utilitarian point of view requires that pleasure be sought and therefore in this case, it will be ...Show more


Introduction This paper seeks to analyze one good example of a moral judgment both in utilitarian view and my own view. My moral judgment in this paper is course of action that I deem to be more morally correct. In other words, I will simply state my judgment pertaining the specific side regarding the controversy I will argue for while considering utilitarianism`s view point…
Author : ghegmann
Moral judgement from utilitarianisms point of view and my own essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Moral judgement from utilitarianism's point of view and my own"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Point of view
This was made entirely evident as the airplane oftentimes shook and one wondered if the very nuts and bolts that held the jet together would unravel themselves and the very machine crash and fall to pieces over the ocean. The sounds of other passengers seemed to carry exceptionally well, as every unsettling conversation, complaint, and sick passenger could be heard.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Point of View Essay
It is the sight that particularly fills me with feelings of nostalgia. Whenever I stare at it surrounding, I happen to notice the trees beckoning me. As I walk, the leaves on the ground seem to produce the sound that welcomes me back, saying ‘long time no see!
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Point of View Essay
Green long lasting hundreds of years old trees, floating sound of short waterfalls, small self-constructed aqueducts carrying cold, icy and hurtling water moving down the mountains as I touched the water a ray of frost went through my soul. Above all the sun cuddling with clouds, materializing rain drops into rainbow (Law et al., 2007), disseminating colors like shower took my heart that made me feel swimming into this colorful pond of nature.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
View point
There are various kinds of perceptions qualitative perception which is the perception of qualities that we attribute to objects, temporal perception the perception of time, auditory perception how people interpret and respond to sounds. The perception of an individual greatly influences the way he acts and responds to various outside stimuli and the way he puts forth his view to other individuals.(Morgan & King) This is very widely seen in the profession of writers and reporters as they have the power and platform to influence the public by what they say and how they say it.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Humes Moral Judgement Theory
Hume's argument involves the examination of practical reason. Reason is never, according to Hume, the sole motivation for the generation of action. Action is always motivated by personal desires and passions and reason is merely the instrument used to satisfy these feelings.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Point of View Paper
Two Union soldiers would be on the bridge beside him. In the thick foliage by the bridge a cannon should be placed. Farquhar should be shown in a thoughtful manner. The scene would fade into a discussion
2 pages (500 words) Essay
My point of view on assisted suicide
Also known as physician-assisted suicide, euthanasia is a hotly contest issue with proponents and detractors on both sides of the spectrum. The issue of
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Point of View Essay
As I walk, the leaves on the ground seem to produce the sound that welcomes me back, saying ‘long time!’ The few daffodils at the entrance smile at me. The leaves and the remaining trees, as well as everything in the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Point of View Essay
Green long lasting hundreds of years old trees, floating sound of short waterfalls, small self-constructed aqueducts carrying cold, icy and hurtling water moving down the mountains as I
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Point of view essay
I was going home the first time after five years after starting my studies abroad. It was early September and mild humidity could be felt in the atmosphere as I reached the town which came across as a pleasant fact considering the sweltering
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation