StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va

Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va

It also provides reason why that argument is valid and explains the resources the monist has at her disposal to undermine our confidence in the soundness of this argument. It also evaluates the response of a monist to the dualist argument that has been provided. The argument for the claim that some mental states are not identical to any brain state is supported by various premises. First, phenomenal properties can only reside in mental substances and not physical objects such as the brain. Second, physical bodies like the brain have spatial properties while minds do not have spatial properties. Third, a mind thinks while physical bodies such as the brain do not think. Fourth, a mind is known to exist with certainty while physical bodies like the brain lack that property. Therefore, in conclusion, some mental states are not identical to any brain state, and a mind is distinct from every physical state. This argument is valid because thinking about things involves intentionality, which is a property of nonphysical things (Mandik). For instance, a brain, which is purely physical, cannot think about things that do not exist in time and space. However, a mind can think about things that do not exist in time and space. Secondly, the brain cannot have intentionality because intentionality is very strange. People also think about things in the far future and distant past via their minds (Mandik). Therefore, a mind is distinct from every physical body, including the brain. Secondly, physical bodies are known via senses, but this senses ca be deceived (Mandik). Something that seems to exist may not exist, in real terms. One cannot be wrong about existence of his or her own mind. Minds are known to exist in certainty while physical objects may not be known to exist with certainty. Therefore, a mental state is known to exist with certainty while physical bodies such as the brain lack that property, and as such, a mind must be very distinct from every physical body, the brain include (Mandik). However, this dualist argument is subject to rejection by proponents of alternatives to dualism such as monism. To undermine our confidence in the soundness of this argument, the monist has various resources at her disposal. First, monism rejects the premise of this dualist argument that the mind is immaterial. Therefore, the question goes, how can a mind, which is considered to be immaterial influence the physical brain (Seybold 89)? Also, how can a non-physical soul or mind affect a physical body, such as the brain (Seybold 90)? Secondly, neuroscience states that the brain is clearly necessary for mental states to occur, but a particular mental state is not identical to a particular brain state. Consequently, some brain state must exist for the mental event to take place, but no particular brain state can be mapped onto the specific mental event in a one to one manner. Monists argue that mental activities emerge from the brain (Seybold 90). Monism agrees with dualism that the mind can, and does affect the brain or the body, but monists reject this argument because it is not explained how the mind can affect the body, if the body and mind are of two different substances, as required in dualism (Seybold 90). Therefore, it is impossible for the physical body to be moved by a mind, which is not part of the physical world, according to monism. It should also be noted that body processes such as thinking require energy and the mind, ...Show more

Summary

Author: Instructor: Date: Some Mental States are not identical to any Brain State Leibniz’s Law is associated with the principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles. It states that anything that is distinct is so different from other things, and that no two objects can have share their properties (Forrest)…
Author : osinskijerrold
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Argument
This paper will attempt to provide a logically sound argument based on various ethical, legal and organizational theories, which will negate the delusion of employee rights to privacy while performing their jobs. Along with these, some managerial implications will also be discussed.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Argument
The claims are strongly supported by warrants, grounds and backings. The warrants, ground, backings of the formal article’s discrimination discussion firmly supports the claims. Thesis Statement The article’s thesis is: The article’s discrimination discussion’s claims, warrants, grounds and formal language have both strengths and weaknesses.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Argument
The problem of mind and body exists primarily because humans naturally desire to place the mental experience of conscious organisms into the organic and scientific categories in which other elements are held. Therein exists a dilemma; it is apparent that all we do is determined and controlled by the mind; however, it would require defining features of the psychological condition that are not explicable on the basis of the human physical operations.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state
Beliefs are said to be an attitude of people wherein they regard something as true (Meijers 2). This paper will focus on the difference between the brain state and the mind state. Also, it will tackle the argument that beliefs are not equal to brain states.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Argument
Violence amongst young people, it is claimed, is becoming increasingly common and hip-hop is partly to blame. However, not everyone sees it quite like that. Despite its negative press, hip-hop has also been seen as a
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory)
However these efforts lose much of their force, if not all of it, in light of the claim for which I will argue here: If a mental state can be realized by more than one kind of physical state, then any one mental state is not strictly identical to any one physical state;
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Argument
The problem of mind and body exists primarily because humans naturally desire to place the mental experience of conscious organisms into the organic and scientific categories in which other
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Argument
Federalism refers to a scenario where partial self governing states operate under a central regime. At this level, the federates and the central government have powers that are dictated by law, and cannot be negated or ignored by either party. Anti-federalism refers to a
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Explain Mackie's argument
As a fact, an omnipotent, omniscient and entirely good being must eliminate evil to extinction. And that the omnipotent is limitless, but if evil exists then God
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Argument
The unjust decision will also be a bad decision, and will deprive Socrates life of value. Firstly, Socrates asks and Crito confirms that unjust thing is unjust under any circumstances, even when responding on injustice. Then, Socrates
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation