Preference to Normal over Disabled under QALY Based Allocation

Preference to Normal over Disabled under QALY Based Allocation Essay example
Undergraduate
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 2 (502 words)
Download 0
This paper is aimed at proving that preferring a normal person over a disabled one through QALY tests is just. The above statement might instigate uproar because they say that QALY is biased as they favor younger and healthier people over chronically ill and disabled people.

Introduction

Preference to Normal over Disabled under QALY Based Allocation

Equality states that each human being must be treated equally on all levels and the bias must be minimized to the minimum. However, with the advent of the Modern age, the world has been bombarded with an increase in population and problems that demand a solution and sometimes it is like choosing between the devil and the deep sea.

The probable rebuttal can be explained through an example. If three people have a car accident and the doctor’s can save only one, what are they going to do then? The doctors can come to the conclusion by looking at the health states of the patients. Consider that only one of them is physically fit and is 18 years old, the other is blind and 22 years old and the last one is chronically ill and 40 years old. The doctors need to make a hard choice nevertheless but they have limited resources. Hence, the doctors will try to save the physically fit, 18 years old patient who has a promise to life, the other two patient might not prove to be as beneficial to the society as this patient can be.

Most people would now think that this paper is biased towards the disabled people but actually it is not. This paper lays stress on the fact that there is no comparison between the normal people and disabled ones, just as their no comparison with squash and tennis, though both of them are played in a court with a ball and a racquet. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Topic 4: details for topic4 are in the 'order instructions'
I. The Hollywood Renaissance One of the most striking features of the Hollywood Renaissance was Hollywood’s departure from an attempt to idealize American life and culture. Instead, a majority of the films produced during the era of the 1960s and 1970s appealed to America’s conscience and adapted a social expression. The arts in general gave voice to the socio-political underpinnings of the…
topic6: details are in the 'order instructions'
They gave birth tо many оther artistic mоvements influencing talented peоple and inspired them tо create the real masterpieces. Mоre recently, artistic styles barely last a decade since the speed оf develоpment and grоwth оf a persоn as well as the sоciety as a whоle is much bigger than it was many centuries agо. Mоdernity and alternative art became the cоncept that have generated…
Modern Ethical Theory or Pragmatism ( choose one)
These theories have in turn been relied upon heavily in determining the parameters of ethical and moral conduct across different cultures and under different circumstances. These theories draw from the ideas of great moral philosophers like John Stuart Mill, Immanuel Kant, David Hume among others. Hume vs Kant vs Mill: Their different views on ethics and morality. By giving their views, all moral…
Choose anyone from the list on the link at the instructions section
Their physical identity is similar, such as their dark-brownish skin, rounded full lips, and cheekbones that are prominent. In addition, their main economic activities were hunting, war, fishing and agriculture (Brumble 21). These Indians lived a humble and traditional life for a long time. However, the invasion of America with new inhabitants such as the whites from England, and Africa Americans…
choose from one from attached
Argument or view Kant’s Deontology posits that the best way to act morally to act from duty with the consideration of the highest good, that is, a good without condition which is intrinsically good by itself (Kant, 1780). He formulated his deontological ethics in a categorical imperative of doing good for the sake of good regardless of its consequence (Kant, 1785). Explication of argument To…
Choose
Rawls and Nozick have different conceptions of justice and liberty because of their divergences on deserts, government’s role in ensuring justice, and whether justice or liberty is more important than the other. The paper asserts that Rawls has a more superior theory of justice than Nozick because he relates his theory of justice to liberty and rights and justifies the importance of justice to…
choose one from the order instructions provided
Based on the above underpinning evidence, it is justifiable to strongly say that prostitution ought to be prohibited in our society. Prohibition of prostitution will reduce the high number of incidences of adultery. Prostitution gives men the opportunity to cheat on their girlfriends and wives in an easy. Therefore, if it is prohibited cheating men will suffer extremely consequences since the law…