StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Ethics - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Ethics

Since these duties would apply to every rational individual, ethics would prevail as individuals would be acting under universal laws that are absolute, therefore, without events of contradictions occurring (Kay, 2007). This paper will examine Maria von Herbert’s interaction with Kant as seen in the reading by Rae Langton, thus pointing out the problems, with Kantian ethics, their severity and how the Kantian can suitably respond. Firstly, it is crucial to examine the details of the letters and the events that followed in order to chronologically assess the situation and pinpoint the main issues. In Rae Langton’s reading, a theme of friendship between Maria von Herbert, a young Austrian and Kant seems to welcome the reader. Herbert is presented as a keen follower of Kant and even with the on-going enmity between Germany and Austria; she still seems to be devoted to Kant’s ideologies. In the season of autumn in 1791, Herbert wrote Kant a letter disclosing her suffering caused by losing her lover due to revealing certain information to him. Agitated from emotion, she said that she had contemplated suicide but because of Kant’s theory, she had decided otherwise (Langton, 1992:2). Herbert felt that she should confess about a certain truth that she had not told her lover so that she could be at peace with herself. After confessing, the lover turned cold and the love that he had felt for Herbert faded, thus making Herbert miserable. Herbert had fortunately read Kant’s theories and since she was devoted to the Kantian ethics, she had decided not to take her own life as it would be morally unacceptable (Langton, 1992:2). Kantian ethics instructed that every individual was compelled by a duty to do what is morally right despite the consequences. In this context, Kant had argued that committing suicide was going against the categorical imperative, which in itself is a command that demands individuals not to commit suicide (Kant, 1785). Herbert was a staunch follower of Kantian ethics so she felt that it was morally wrong to commit suicide despite the pain and agony she was feeling. Although she had not taken her life, she wanted Kant to reveal to her, the values or worth of living such a miserable life with a lot of emotional pain and no good. She wanted Kant to give her an alternative that could make her feel that her life was worth once again. She also indicated that Kant’s philosophy had not helped her in dealing with her troubles (Langton, 1992:3). The letter evidently moved Kant as it conveyed a theme and a message of truth, virtue and honesty. These were qualities that moved Kant because he believed that speaking the truth was not only an ethical duty to oneself but to others (Mahon, 2009:214). Therefore, he sought a friend who advised him to reply to the letter. Kant talked about the dispute between desiring to keep individuals’ private matters to themselves and the need to openly talk about them especially when in a situation of immense love. Kant said individuals had an inward urge that set limits to excessive openness and allowed them to keep some aspects of life locked within them. Kant simply meant that it was ethically allowed for individuals to keep private matters to themselves but this was supposed to be recognised from lying (Langton: 1992: 3). Kant told Herbert that her lover had every right to be angry with her and she had to face the consequences of being dishonest. Kant declined to talk about suicide because he thought that talking ...Show more

Summary

Shortcomings with Kantian Ethics as Viewed from Maria von Herbert’s Exchange with Kant Introduction Immanuel Kant came up with an ethic theory that was duty oriented, which required people to first determine their duty in order to do what is considered ethical…
Author : jerrod90
Ethics essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Ethics"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Ethics
Personal codes of ethics exemplify a relatively new trend, when reflect the striving of individuals to fix their ethical commitments and beliefs on paper. Any personal code of ethics must include rationale, ethical statement, rules, and enforcement procedures.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
ETHICS
This necessity is not only driven by precautionary measure to prevent the occurrence of less than ideal business practice that would diminish the stature of the business among its stakeholders, but also as a strategic option because businesses that are perceived to be ethical enjoys the confidence of the market and consequently the customer’s patronage and profitability.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Ethics
It requires people to consider if their actions are right or wrong. It also asks people how the components that help them succeed, for example, compassion, integrity, faithfulness, and honesty are relevant in everyday life. Ethics looks at the fundamental principles and basic concepts of human behavior.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Ethics
This led to the standard ethical notions of ethical naturalism which gave rise to the problem of integrating ethics with beliefs about the world and led to the conception of
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Ethics
It is therefore incumbent that the survival be embedded with ethics as basis of establishment. “Computer ethics is not a fixed set of rules which one shellacs and hangs on the
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
ETHICS
Such controversies indicate the numerous ethical dilemmas that nurses and doctors have to deal with in their practice. Ethics in medical practice are meant
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Ethics
Business in itself is amoral that to put ethics in business is an oxymoron because they contradict each other (Crane and Matten, 2006). Business in itself as an
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Ethics
One of the major aspects that are adopted by firms is the code of ethics. This entails a set of principles that guides a firm in its policies and programs. Ethical philosophy is applied in every department within an organization. This paper aims at discussing the ethical
3 pages (750 words) Essay
ETHICS
n than not comes with close contract with deontology that stresses on duty to rules and eventually consequentialism that determines the wrongness or rights from the happenings of a particular action. The approach of moral dilemmas rather than the moral conclusion proves to be a
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Ethics
Since retailing is the last stage of the distribution process, all retailers should adhere to good business ethics as they conduct their business (Robinson, 2009). Ethical practices in retailing
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation