StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Disagreements on the Interpretations of the Zhuangzi - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Disagreements on the Interpretations of the Zhuangzi

These differences can be summed up in presenting two modern analyses and interpretations of some parts of the Zhuangzi, with emphasis on the governing forces that shape and control the universe. For writer Erica Brindley, she interprets the Zhuangzi as the driving force and endless source of power that moves the universe and is above even Heaven itself is the Dao ?, which is “an upright way”, “a method”, “a path”, or “a truth”.1 The Dao allows the proliferation of diversity, thus any kind of method is considered acceptable as long as it is in line with the truth, making it a cyclical or a circular concept. Meanwhile writer Michael J. Puett interprets Heaven or Tian ? as the apex in the universal hierarchy and governs laws initiating changes and transformations, similar to patriarchy as a social order.2 Because the two authors read and interpreted the Zhuangzi using two different terms with differing ideologies, there are disagreements between the two, wherein Brindley’s interpretation of the Zhuangzi shows that the universe has a cyclic nature accessible through transcendence, while Puett’s interpretation states that the universal hierarchy is linear with Heaven at the apex, and man must live in balance with it without having to enter transcendence. Comparisons of the Two Interpretations of the Zhuangzi Brindley’s interpretation of the Zhuangzi gives a greater emphasis on the Dao as the all-encompassing, dynamic, unbounded and limitless driving force that shapes the cosmos and initiates its constant transformations.3 This is due to how she explains some ideas in the Zhuangzi using the Dao as the major influence. For example, she interprets the Dao to be impersonal, thus when a person unites with it, the perception of the self ceases to exist and becomes indistinguishable through emptiness, Wu ?. Thus this person does not act of his own accord anymore, because the self is no more. A passage from Zhuangzi mentions the impersonality of the Dao: “The Way has its reality and its signs but is without action or form. You can hand it down but you cannot receive it; you can get it but you cannot see it (Zhuangzi 6.9).”4 The idea is similar to Descartes’ “I think, therefore I am”, but instead it becomes I no longer am, and thus my thoughts are not mine.5 This turns thoughts from something personal to something that is not from the person, thus being impersonal. On the other hand, Puett’s interpretations of the Zhuangzi gives more emphasis on Heaven to be the one governing all changes that happen in the universe, and that humans must strive not to work against it, but rather follow its patterns.6 This is because resisting or controlling these changes makes people resentful, and will turn into an endless cycle of dissatisfaction, whereas allowing changes to happen as fate brings one pleasure and peace. This can be further explained using a passage from Zhuangzi: “Such things from time to time may happen to come your way. When they come, you cannot keep them from arriving, but when they depart you cannot stop them from going (Zhuangzi 16.5).”7 By allowing things to happen according to the patterns of Heaven and forgoing all, man can easily live in peace. Another disagreement between Brindley’s and Puett’s interpretations of the Zhuangzi is on how normalcy or humanity is defined. For Brindley, what the universe creates that man does not see normal are the products of how the Dao allows diversity to exist in the cosmos, while for Puett anything that exists in nature, regardless of whether humans consider it normal or not are still the products of the will of Heaven and are thus “heavenly”. The two texts both mentioned the following passage from Zhua ...Show more

Summary

Various analyses on the content of the Book of Zhuangzi can be attributed to how the original Chinese verses were written, and interpretations of the text will depend on the readers’ experiences, beliefs, and backgrounds…
Author : myrtlefeil
Disagreements on the Interpretations of the Zhuangzi essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Disagreements on the Interpretations of the Zhuangzi"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Book of Dream Interpretations
Mina was willing to do everything in order to find the truth and protect her husband. I think that she is the modern woman – capable and dependable, but at the same time, she retains her charm as a woman. She uses the short hand to write her letters but then decided to type them using a typewriter so that others can read them.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy of Zhuangzi is a form of Skepticism
In his philosophies, he does not organize his ideas systematically and fails to define his terms too. Skepticism is a complicated epistemological position, which any philosopher or researcher can distinguish among its varieties through focusing on the strength and scope of themes.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Ancient Mythology and Modern Interpretations
This story itself was developed utilizing many sources existing in Malory’s day including numerous Norman-French romances and an English alliterative
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Techniques used in landscape interpretations
signs that explain the view, an architect might consider the engineering techniques with which the castle was built, and historians might examine the usefulness of the castle in terms of its location and placement on the path of an invading army. On the other hand, a geologist
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
New Testament 'Queer' interpretations
The term ‘homosexual’ is broadly used to involve both men and women whereby men are sexually attracted to men, and women are find other women sexually alluring. Women homosexuals are also referred to as ‘lesbians,’ both male and female homosexuals
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Interpretations of Tsuru no Sugomori
While the song is titled Nesting Crane, personally I envision someone doing movements in the form of a bird rather than and actual crane in a nest.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Compare and contrast Confucius and Zhuangzi
Confucius took the teachings of the ancient Chinese and moulded them in such way, so as to address the needs of his time. His system of thinking and philosophy came to be known as “Confucianism.” His highly acclaimed teachings influenced the
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Constitutional Interpretations
According to U.S. Constitution Online, the constitution is a brief document and can not be described in detail. There can be its many meaning to different people, even if it is clearly stated it can be interpreted as giving differently. It comes under the governance framework that it vividly narrates and defines the right meaning.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Violence Leads to Disagreements and Development
As a result of this, people are normally advised to desist from acts of violence so that harm is not done to other people. Violent behavior is not only scaring but it is a barbaric act. Things need to be solved in a
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Beethoven Interpretations
began to become more noticeable to him his music became more intense and it was during this period that some of his most memorable and famous pieces were composed. It was during this time that Beethoven wrote the symphony ‘Eroica,’ heralding what could have possibly been the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment