StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state

Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state

Furthermore, it will discuss the relevant concepts in philosophy that will either affirm or negate these suppositions. In order to make this possible, the monist and dualist concepts are also discussed. Some mental states (beliefs) are not identical to any brain state The first argument being focused in this paper is the difference between mental and brain states. As mentioned earlier, these two are different concepts. Many people are confused and often use these two interchangeably. The mental state has a deeper context compared to that of the brain state. This is so because it refers to the state of a person’s thoughts regarding pain or happiness, what a person believes in, and also ideas and aspirations. On the other hand, the brain state refers to the literal condition of the nervous system like a brain activity. According to Adam Sennet (chap. 5), some mental states, like beliefs, are not identical or similar to any brain state. This is because beliefs are not part of any physiological activities of the body particularly inside the brain. the famous philosopher Descartes (qtd. in Carruthers 7) postulated that the mind is not spatial but has the ability to think, while the body is spatial but is unable to think; hence, the body is only capable of biological and physiological activities. ...
nd Y are very similar, then they should have the very same attributes, which is not true in the concept of the mind (beliefs) and the body (brain state). Hence, if X and Y have different attributes, they can never be considered as identical. The differences in the mental and brain states include the argument of certainty (Wright). The mind can be certain about pain or desires but the brain cannot be certain about anything because it lacks a logical attribute. There is a great disparity between the mental state and the brain state as clearly stated by this Law. There are, however, some arguments by other philosophers like Carruthers that the Leibniz’ Law does not apply to mental states including beliefs, pains, and desires. He argues that if X and Y are not very similar substances, then X and Y must have the same intrinsic attributes or properties (Carruthers 8). He believes that the mental state does not have a property of belief. Thus, he sticks to his argument that the two substances are very similar because they are one (Wright). The Monist Concept This concept does not hold the proposition that there are two kinds of substances. It holds that there is only one kind of substance and that the brain and the mind are just the same. There are, however, two separate views about this one substance. These are: materialism and idealism (Carruthers 6). Materialism is an idea that all that exists are material or physical, while idealism is an idea which states that all that exists are ultimately mental. These are the two ideas in the Monist concept and there are philosophers who believe on either one or another but not both. The materialist does not believe that there is such a thing as the mental state and so they are similar or identical to absolutely nothing, because ...Show more


Argumentative Essay Introduction There have been different philosophical theories about brain state and mental state. Brain state refers to the physiological condition of the brain or the nervous system, while the mental state refers to the pains, desires, thoughts, and beliefs…
Author : barry41
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Discuss at least two theories which hold that a mental state is nothing more than some sort of physical state
the human mind. This paper tackles the question on, what constitutes the identity of the mind? What distinguishes mental phenomena from non-mental ones? Or what distinguishes mental states such as beliefs and desires from physical objects such as tables and chairs?
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
An Exposition and Evaluation of Descartes' Arguments for the Claim that the Mind is not Identical to the Body
One is the argument based on a clear distinction between mind and body, and the other is based on the mind’s indivisibility and the mind’s divisibility. Both of these arguments are plausible but several objections to them can be thought of. The first of these two arguments is the argument that can be fittingly called an argument from distinction.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state. Explain why the argument is va
In law and criminology, Leibniz’s Law may state that if Murderer A is identical to Suspect B, then every attribute of A is also an attribute of B, and vice versa (Ruble 24). This paper provides an argument for the claim that some mental states are not identical to any brain state.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Philosophy Functionalism
Behaviorism identified mental states with behavioral dispositions; physicalism in its most influential version identifies mental states with brain states. According to functionalism, mental states are constituted by their causal relations to one another and to sensory inputs and behavioral outputs.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory)
However these efforts lose much of their force, if not all of it, in light of the claim for which I will argue here: If a mental state can be realized by more than one kind of physical state, then any one mental state is not strictly identical to any one physical state;
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
It can be argued that one of the consequences of disintegration in th USSR is the promotion of some hitherto secondary languages to primary status. Discuss this claim in relation to any of the countries in the new Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)
Thus, language became a bone of contention between various ethnic groups in the newly formed states. Dominant ethnic groups pressed their governments to introduce legislations
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
The Case for Mental State in Relation to the Normal Organic Brain and Non-organic Brain
Based on this, I consider my friend as being conscious. The subject of the mental state is as perplexing as it is mysterious. In this case, determining the consciousness of an individual involves a variety of
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Richard Swinburne, in his article Dualism Intact, gives what he calls an improved version of the argument that a soul can exist without a body, and that I am my soul. Paul Moser and Arnold vander Nat, in their article Surviving Souls, consider
Essentially, dualism is the basic observation of humans as being both matter and mind, with a certain degree of incompatibility between matter and mind. Matter is considered as inherently not aware while mind, on the other hand, is
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Two Requirements of Mental State
The paper concludes that the man in the case being analyzed shows some mental states but does not have a normal range of mental states. Materialists believe that mental state is a physical state and can be explained by a physical principle. However, they face the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
In a two to three page paper provide an argument either for or against a person with a mental illness being able to do the job of President of the United States. Make sure to include factual information on the symptoms of the illness, treatment, and medic
To be a president primarily The United States, their humorous tasks that you need to handle. Some decisions have to be made so that the government can run accordingly. Presidency has diverse roles that need a sober-minded person to preside over (Espejo, 2012). The mental
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation