StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Capital Punishment - Term Paper Example

Nobody downloaded yet
The arguments of Pojman, which supports capital punishment, were based on three premises from anecdotal evidence. First, the deterrent effect of an object is increased with the increased degree of fear it can cause to a person. Second, people fear death more than any humane punishment, and third, death penalty is a humane punishment. From these premises, the author concludes that the death penalty is a more effective mechanism to deter people from committing homicide compared to long imprisonment (277). The argument presented was potentially sound since it was supported by coherent reasoning. However, while the first premise is logical, the last two premises have a potential conflict since not all criminals are fearful of death and generally, capital punishment is inhumane. Nevertheless, the author’s conclusion still follows his premises since there is a high chance that potential criminals will avoid committing first degree crime if they are aware that the sentence that awaits them is death compared to long imprisonment. However, it is argued that capital punishment is not an appropriate sentence to major offenders. There is also a strong contention against the principle that the death penalty has a greater deterrence compared to long imprisonment. ...
However, it is argued that life as it is, has an intrinsic value. This makes it unjust and immoral to permit the gambling of the lives of murderers. For the anecdotal argument, one of the premises of the proponent states that the death penalty is a humane punishment. This premise is a weak assumption since it is contended that the moral values of society do not perceive death penalty as acceptable. Thus, killing a person is inhumane. Due to the weak premises of the proponent, it cannot be concluded justly that capital punishment, in contrast to long term imprisonment, has a greater deterrence among potential criminals. A study of Donohue and Wolfers on the homicide rates in US revealed that there is no statistical evidence to prove that the death penalty has a substantial deterrent effect on homicide commission. The findings of the time series analysis showed that as the death penalty execution rose up from 1920s to 1930s, homicide rates also increased while both of the execution and homicide rates went down from 1940s to 1950s (796). Moreover, Donohue and Wolfers also conducted a comparative study between Canada and US to determine if execution rates can significantly reduce homicide rates. The findings showed that both US and Canada showed similar changes in homicide rates amidst country specific legislations that directly affected their execution rates. For instance, when Canada did not conduct executions in 1962, its homicide rates were still close to the US. In a similar way, when US suspended its death penalty policy in 1972, both the execution and homicide rates of US and Canada rose altogether (799). This study supports the argument that capital punishment does not significantly influence homicide rates, ...Show more

Summary

Name of of Professor Course and Course Number Date of Paper Deterrence Capacity of Capital Punishment In The Wisdom of Capital Punishment,” Lewis Pojman presented the contention that capital punishment, in contrast to imprisonment, is a more effective mechanism to discourage would be offenders from committing homicide (Pojman 272)…
Author : gcasper
Capital Punishment essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the term paper on your topic
"Capital Punishment"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Capital Punishment
The study reflects the insignificance of Capital punishment in curbing the rate of crime conducted. The multi facet reasons behind the offenders conducting such crimes should be necessarily studied before confirming the judgment. The societal responsibility in breeding the adolescence and their eventual turning up into criminals cannot be bypassed.
14 pages (3500 words) Term Paper
Criminal Justice
Nevertheless, to some extent, the fear of punishment and retaliation are still major deterrents in the commission of crimes. This paper shall now critically analyze and evaluate the death penalty as a crime control policy. Death penalty is a form of punishment, one which seeks to impose equivalent penalty for heinous crimes, including murder, homicide, and murder/rape.
10 pages (2500 words) Term Paper
Open
Given out in extreme cases and circumstances in the modern day and age, death penalty has clearly divided the American society into two halves with the first half in favor of and the second against it. Both sides present arguments to support their respective cause.
5 pages (1250 words) Term Paper
Should capital punishment be suspended because of racial disparities
A handful of countries have stopped capital punishment since 1900 and by the beginning of the millennium, at least two-thirds of the world no longer impose capital punishment (Hodgkinson and Shabas 1). There is a longstanding debate between the abolitionists or those who seek to remove the death penalty and those who believe in its traditional effect of retribution.
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Death penalty
At the same time many others are of the view that for a civilized society like ours, death penalty is not a fair mean of punishment. Even though America is one of the most civilized countries in the world, death penalty is legal in most of the American states.
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
The Cost of Capital Punishment
Hence, in order to discourage and eradicate the crimes and offences from society, the authorities introduce such harsh sentences, so that the people would not dare to hurt and harm other members of society, and thus avoid breaking of the statutes of prevailing law.
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Juveniles and the Death Penalty: Annotated Bibliography
The Supreme Court of the US banned capital punishment which is directed at underage offenders and this has motivated studies which aim at establishing the societal perception on the juvenile death penalty. This paper presents summaries of various information sources which include credible articles and research papers on the various legal aspects of the juvenile death penalty.
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Capital punishment in the United States and around the world
Those periods were the 1840s, 1910s, and late 1950s. These abolitionists only resulted in severe restriction of the death penalty in 10 states in 1962. However some other things came out of the
7 pages (1750 words) Term Paper
Open
cases and circumstances in the modern day and age, death penalty has clearly divided the American society into two halves with the first half in favor of and the second against it. Both sides present arguments to support their respective cause. Capital punishment has been
5 pages (1250 words) Term Paper
Criminal Justice
This has created two rifts of ideologies as pertains to the death penalty debate. While some argue that certain types of offenders deserve the death penalty, others view
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment