Lying v. Misleading

Lying v. Misleading Essay example
Undergraduate
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 7 (1757 words)
Download 0
There is a difference between lying and misleading. Lying is saying something that is untruthful. Misleading is saying something that is technically true, but is designed to create deception…

Introduction

Philosophers have not only tried to characterize the difference between lies and misleading statements, but also have debated over the moral significance of each kind of utterance. Therefore, the two main question s are what speech act is required for lying, as opposed to being misleading; and what is the moral difference between the two acts of speech. One theory, from a linguistic point of view, according to Stokke (2), is that there are different ways of conveying information, which means, in turn, that there is a difference in the speech acts involved in both misleading and lying. When one is lying, the mode of communication is saying. This means that lying requires saying something, and being misleading is conveying information without coming right out and saying it. The example that Stokke (1) gave was a person who is looking forward to going to a party that evening after work. Another person, a co-worker, comes up and says that she doesn't want to go to the party unless person A is going. To which, person A simply says “I have to work.” But person A is actually going to be going to the party. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

The Relation between Appearance and Reality
These two aspects are normative and positive respectively and a number of philosophers like Locke, Berkeley and Descartes have written about them as their main areas of focus in order to decipher what is appearing to be and what actually is in reality. This paper helps to provide an insight into the realms of appearance and reality with respect to the works of the above mentioned philosophers and…
US Supreme Court Case: California v. Greenwood Challenges the Fourth Amendment Privacy of Search and Seizure
Stracner got a further tip from an informant that a load of illegal drugs was on its way to Greenwood’s residence in Laguna Beach, CA. The tip was given to a federal drug enforcement agent in February of 1984 and relayed to Stracner. There had also been complaints from neighbors of a lot of heavy traffic activity in front of the residence late in the evenings. It was noted that these heavy…
Appearance and Reality
These two aspects are normative and positive respectively and a number of philosophers like Locke, Berkeley and Descartes have written about them as their main areas of focus in order to decipher what is appearing to be and what actually is in reality. This paper helps to provide an insight into the realms of appearance and reality with respect to the works of the above mentioned philosophers and…
Bullshit as a Politics of Discourse
2). All throughout his paper, he argues that bullshit has been used in most cases and varies in purpose. Politically speaking, lying and truth can be an issue of public trust and affects the manner of governance. Bullshit can be used in both cases. The bullshit can be considered as a truth depending on the manner of rhetoric. At the same time, it is also a lie which becloud. It can be considered…
Truth as an the inevitable attributes of human nature. Based on Stephen Vincent Benet’s “By the Waters of Babylon”
Truth as an the inevitable attributes of human nature. Based on Stephen Vincent Benet’s “By the Waters of Babylon” …
Truth Telling
There are a number of disciplines that do not encourage lying. Such a discipline as medicine and its related subsets require truthful interaction between doctors and patients in order to achieve the effectiveness of both the diagnosis and treatment. Honesty is a relative concept in the health care ethics. For a long time, medical practitioners had assumed that patients told the truth about their…
Explain and critically assess Frankfurt's distinction between bullshitting and lying
In bullshit there is no knowledge of truth (Frankfurt, 2005, p. 43). A bullshitter lacks proper knowledge to support the statement he makes. The different situations in our multi-agent systems and human culture give strong support for bullshit. This research is meant to analyze particular problems regarding to reasoning in the social context. Bullshit is one of the most salient features in our…