StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Kantian Argument - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Kantian Argument

Budeau and Marshal Bedau and Cassell Budeau and marshal hold that the death penalty is morally wrong regardless of the crime committed by the offender. Both opponents of the death penalty have suggested that when analyzing whether a certain crime fit a given punishment, one must look at the impact of the punishment. This includes both the criminal and the society at large (Bedau and Cassell 118). The two argue out that capital punishment creates biased sense of security within the society. Community members feel better in the knowledge that the capital punishment is an option for a severe crime regardless of whether it is applied or not. According to Kant’s framework of ethics (to persons), capital punishment reduces the worth of the criminal who is also is a human being. He further states that the rightness or wrongness of an action is determined, not by the consequences, but by their ability to fulfill our duty. Kant argued that the only intrinsic good thing is a good will (Bedan 100). An action can only be judged to be good if it fulfills its duty to the moral law. Kant, unlike Pojman, held that particular types of actions (including murder and the death sentence) were extremely prohibited. Before acting, he proposes that there are two issues one need to ponder first. The first is whether everyone will act the same way you act, and whether one’s actions are in contravention to the goals of human beings. With respect to the theory of utilitarianism, individuals ought to undertake an action because it will produce the most happiness than any other action. The act that the morally right action, the action in which everybody has a moral duty to do, is the one that maximizes utility. Utility comprises happiness, well-being, and welfare. Everybody’s happiness counts equally, thus death sentence should be the last option, provided it is the action that provides the most happiness in the end (Bedau and Cassell 159). Pojman Pojman is one of the major proponents of capital punishment. His views strongly suggest that the death sentence acknowledges the offender’s right and worth as a person. This is because it entails treating him as fully responsible for his actions (Bedan 188). Pojman sets out to offer an argument in favor of Capital Punishment as morally right. He builds upon Kantian’s proposition on the importance of an equal penalty for a wrong committed. He accepts the fundamental position that the availability of the death sentence is critical with respect to the argument of justice. He reinforces his argument a critical premise. This proposition holds that a person cannot enjoy their right to life when they have denied the deceased theirs. Provided that our society treats people as free agents and autonomous, capital offenders are required to bear responsibility for their action. The option of an equivalent punishment for an equivalent crime supports the responsibility of nature and government as a citizenry. MyView Death penalty presents a form of barbaric form of punishment as it is the ultimate denial of human rights. Capital punishment presents a cold-blooded and premeditated killing of human beings by the state. It is not morally correct that the degrading and human punishment be carried out in the name of justice. This is because, as a form of the application of justice, it breaches the right to life as provided in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Amnesty international is ...Show more

Summary

Name Instructor Course Date Death Penalty Introduction There are four acknowledged and the basic reasons for having state authorized punishment (Stearman 34). This includes prevention, rehabilitation, retribution, and deterrence. Of all those, retribution forms the backbone for the dominant ideology behind the death penalty…
Author : edgarsanford
Kantian Argument essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Kantian Argument"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Argument
This paper will attempt to provide a logically sound argument based on various ethical, legal and organizational theories, which will negate the delusion of employee rights to privacy while performing their jobs. Along with these, some managerial implications will also be discussed.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Kantian Philosophy: On Shakespeare's View of Human Nature and Political Reality
In my opinion, Shakespeare’s view of human nature and political reality is in line with Kant’s. Regardless of the different natures of knowledge, history play versus philosophy, the two distinct accounts have shared the same view on human nature and political reality, which is human beings have selfish instincts and have tendencies to abuse their freedom and their power.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Kantian Philosophy
In the book “Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals”, specifically on the preface, it can be seen that Kant’s logic can be drawn from the paradigms of reason and subjectivity, which can be of clash with each other; a possible hindrance to achieving a universal philosophy accordingly.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Death Penalty, Kantian Ethics, and Utilitarianism
Capital punishment or Death Penalty is still retained extensively around the world, especially in the Muslim nations and United States. According to the most recent statistics, 58 countries still retain it while 97 have completely abolished it. Human rights organizations and activists all over the world have been protesting against this punishment and are in favor of abolishing it globally.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Kantian Morality
One of the most attractive aspects of Kantian morality is its simplicity. By this point of the course, the reader should understand that simplicity alone is a bit of a scary metric to seek to objectify and judge a philosophical approach.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Business Ethics 2 page essay
Unlawful discrimination at work place, due to race, color, culture, religion, is prohibited and made illegal in US now. In case of employer's action being challenged under those laws, the employer can show legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons for his decision and thus, he could win even if the decision is an unfair one.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Do we have a moral obligation to vote
This paper will be examining consequential argument primarily, in building a case towards voting or not voting. It will then briefly discuss other forms of argument that may be used
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Kant and plato
It is important to underscore that, for Kant, understanding are not derived from experience. It even precedes the latter because understanding supposedly makes experience possible. In Prolegomena, Kant pointed out that the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Deontological teleological utilitarianism kantian theory
In undertaking the analysis, the research will undertake critical and objective analysis of each of the concepts. There will be some practical examples which will be used to illustrate each point in order to come up
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Utilitarian vs Kantian Views on Hurricane Katrina Doctors and their Patients
This essay will focus on the utilitarian and Kantian views on Hurricane Katrina on the side of the doctors and their patients. For success to be achieved in an organisation, it is important
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation