• Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • How does the case of the 'Guildford Four' Illustrate the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the State?

How does the case of the 'Guildford Four' Illustrate the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the State? - Coursework Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
How does the case of the 'Guildford Four' Illustrate the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the State?

The act of judging whether or not a given action is morally right or wrong is considered a very complex situation. Specifically the case of the 'Guildford Four' illustrates the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the state. In judging whether or not human action is intrinsically right (good) or wrong (evil), the role of the public policymakers comes in. As stated by Sir William Blackstone, “It is better to let ten guilty men go free than to wrongly incarcerate one innocent man”. Because of the increasing number of wrongful conviction in UK, developing a set of political rules in the form of law will not always lead to actions that are morally good. One way or the other, developing a set of political rules the the form of creating a legal system may only serve as a scapegoating tactics in the case of the true criminals. As compared to the theory of utilitarianism, the concept of deontology is totally different in the sense that deontology remains focus on judging an action by observing the righteousness or wrongness of an action regardless of whether the end result of the action is good or evil (Nishukan 2007). Instead of taking into consideration the end-result of an action, Immanuel Kant suggest the use of deontology more than the classical utilitarianism since deontology judges moral issues by carefully examining the type of actions being committed by a person ...Show more


In this report,utilitarianism,as proposed by Bentham will first be defined followed by discussing the reasons why “scape goat” objection is considered as a weakness similar to the Guilford Four.As proposed by Mill,the role of utilitarianism in our society will be tackled in relation to how it can provide as a better solution …
Author : miguelconroy
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the coursework on your topic
"How does the case of the 'Guildford Four' Illustrate the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the State?"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

How does the democratic leadership style affect the work environment in school
It has been proven that democratic leadership paves way for a much stronger relationship because it empowers the person to perform better and feel more involved in the project since they have been part of the decision. Though in a democratic leadership, the final decision is made by the higher authority, it allows the people to give their opinions thereby making them feel more involved in the entire process.
18 pages (4500 words) Thesis
Management Accounting
Management accounting is the accounting intended for the internal stakeholders of an organization. It helps managers to take sound decisions for the betterment of an organization. Accounts department, production department, sales department and the business processes are some of the data sources for management accounting.
4 pages (1000 words) Research Paper
How does depreciation accounting help the firm manage equipment investment costs and taxes?
Some Current Liabilities maybe with the inclusion of Advance Incomes, Outstanding Expenses, and short-term creditors among others. (Nikolai et al, 2009 p139) This is a study set out to handle this issue of Current Liabilities in detail. More specifically, the study will seek to answer the thesis question, “How are Current Liabilities of known amounts, Current Liabilities of estimated amounts, and Contingent Liabilities accounted for in financial statements?
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
How can Economic Value Added (EVA) statements be used to improve financial statement reporting, results, and success? What are s
The use of Economic Value Added (EVA) statements enable companies to determine if the company is earning or not. This is determined in the Economic Value Added (EVA) statements by deducting the cost of financing the company’s capital or cost of money from the profit or revenue made by the company.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
How does the western model of Internet Banking apply to Russia?
The research study is described as a process rather than an event to mean that in order for the researcher to successfully achieve the research aim that is set for the study, there are series of tasks that must be performed. There could not be a singular activity that could make the researcher achieve the research aim (Adams and Lamptey, 2009).
16 pages (4000 words) Dissertation
To what extent does strategic management accounting contribute to global competitiveness? Illustrate your answer through an anal
The traditional management accounting is considered to be inadequate with its focus only on the manufacturing and ignores the effect of various other activities. The accounting reports provide incomplete sets of measures. The traditional reporting systems implemented by traditional management accountants include standard cost variance analysis or the budgetary control techniques, which do not focus completely on the processes.
6 pages (1500 words) Literature review
How does globalization affect financial markets.
However, the integration of different marketplaces has made the state of economic and monetary affairs highly complex. Analysts find debatable issues of concern in many economic affairs. For instance, the relationship between the real exchange rate and the external foreign asset of a country has become a controversial issue.
12 pages (3000 words) Research Paper
Creative short story on time travel
During the aircraft invention, I personally thought that it was voodoo magic. According to me, the only things that could fly were birds and angels alone so the creation of flying objects awed me. That however, is not the only thing stirred my adventurous spirit. The past
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Social contract tradition renders man self-directed and free only if he adheres to the popular will dictates. Rousseau disapproves of the social contract tradition on the basis that it just promotes equality and liberty whereas it actually does the opposite of that.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email