StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Portrayal of guilt and retribution - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Portrayal of guilt and retribution

Thus fantastic elements are added and metaphorically situated within the two stories to stray away from the sense of what is practical or what is practically considered to be "right" and the abundance of fantastic depictions therefore creating a conflict between the self and the society - thus drawing the connection with the Kantian philosophy of the State, justice and moral nature of man.
Kant introduced the idea of "Categorical Imperative"1 and that morality is fundamentally a priori in nature and therefore it claims that one's moral choices are always good as it is grounded in Reason and it is never a matter of choice or personal taste and it is universally seeks to be good and is a truth in itself. Thus the moral a priori truth that it holds all of us under the same universal law of good and bad becomes the apparatus of perception by which we define our acts and how we view guilt and retribution without regard to the relative context from which such immoral acts emerge. Thus, Michael Kohlhaans' guilt exists even when he knows that he acted against a wrongdoing committed against him, who is the actual criminal. This case of denial of justice does not necessarily redeem Kohlhaans from his acts of wrongdoing and even he knows it. This classic idea of moral retribution can be further explained by the idea of morality and duty as proposed by Kant. Does the fantastic elements plan to create the effect of the sense of extreme (arousing the sense of impropriety within the reader itself, who otherwise would sympathize with Kohlhaans') and monstrous betrayal, absurd extent of revenge taken, heavy assortment of passion and desire, and the complicated motifs of human actions that do not necessarily always have simple and reasonable explanations to them - the complicacy of the human mind therefore becomes the subject of these novella where the fight with morality is better portrayed with the use of such fantastic metaphors and symbols or events. Or does the over-explanations used to play truth becomes fantastic to us' Does the restless energy of Kohlhaans' immoral acts and the restless energy that consume the plot of the story create a revenge that is so emphatic and complete that it almost creates a sense of improbability within us' Or does the emphasis on Marquis' innocence (supported by the bizarre reason of the Count being the father of her child) create a feeling of disbelief within us or our suspension of disbelief like that of the Colonel is only justified by the fantastic elements that invade the storytelling' A plot that emerges out of the consequences of the given situation only in Marquise Von O makes the story border on the fantastic Gothic elements that disregards the presence of the universal morality but rather portrays the subterranean forces of human immorality that are fantastically co-existent within us and how we are still capable to dealing with such truths too!

Fantasy also has a strange relation with the use of language that creates such lively details within the reader's mind. In Kleist's work, the novellas slowly become detached from their socio-historical necessity and gradually gather the momentum of a personal nature where the inner tragedies find an objective correlative to the outside reality. Thus, when Kohlhaans enter the tollgate there is a symbolic passage that is undertaken, which ...Show more

Summary

The use of improbable, high, and fanciful rather fantastic elements or dramatic scenes in the portrayal of retribution and sense of guilt heightens the sense of morality in realistic fiction. It was a typical 19th century fiction writer's ploy to add such sense of the division or battle between the good and the evil…
Author : meagan31
Portrayal of guilt and retribution essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Portrayal of guilt and retribution"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Cinematic Portrayal of Iranian Women
Cinematic Portrayal of Iranian Women. There has been immense amount of debate and discussion when it comes to the social status of women in the Iranian society. The substance of this prose will examine the social status of women on a religious and cultural front, but this status will be largely observed through the internationally acclaimed cinema of Iran.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Scapegoat: The Diversion of Guilt and Accountability
Individuals point fingers at times, to avoid fault and culpability. A scapegoat is the one that endures the guilt and blameworthiness for others. It may also be used to define a person that is the object of absurd aggression.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Retribution for Slaves
The most widespread debate that has been taking place in the U.S. is whether the descendants of slavery and the slave trade should receive retributions. Certainly, there are assertions that can be heard regarding slaver outside the United States—particularly as it certainly still happens today—where people are used as a guarantee on debt, forced labor, and chattel slavery.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Guilt The Most Hated Fruit of the Knowledge Tree
Guilt – The Most Hated Fruit of the Knowledge Tree “The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man” – George Bernard Shaw.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Guilt, hopelessness and shame
In his work there exists a variety of themes which indicate just how rich this book is in terms of diversity. Tim brings out the different themes through the use of the various stories, however what stands out is the fact that several themes keep on recurring in the different stories in the book.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hollywood Portrayal of Cancer
These films utilized the theme of cancer to bring to the audience the message of "seizing the day," but not necessarily to educate the audience about the realities of the illness. As will be seen in the analysis that will follow, much of the portrayals of cancer in the aforementioned films are executed with very little details about the illness and were incorporated into the story only as an ingredient to appeal to the emotions of the viewers, notwithstanding the inadequacies of the realism.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Principle of Retribution for International Crimes
For example, Andrew Altman, Christopher Wellman, and Larry May have sought to defend the legitimacy of international criminal law by examining the moral right of international courts to punish certain classes of criminals. (Larry, 2005; Andrew 2004: 35-67; Allen, 2004) Each has offered different arguments to justify "how international criminal prohibitions can legitimately pierce the sovereignty of a state so as to permit an international tribunal, or a court of another state, to prosecute crimes committed wholly within the state's territory." (Elizabeth, 2000; 259) However, each assumes that these crimes should be punished and fail to offer a moral rationale for international justice as suc
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
The Portrayal of Transsexualism in Media
Usually this situation is very traumatizing for the person, when he or he first finds out about his/her illness. Fortunately, the transsexual community exists, where every transsexual can come and get help from people who have the same problems, and from the specialists.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
The Portrayal of Judaism
110) The reason for the unfavorable position of the Greeks was due to the fact of the great suffering they inflicted on the Jews during the Hellenistic period because of their opposition of the
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
White Guilt
n of affirmative action, women and minorities, which mainly included the African-Americans, suffered from racial discrimination, especially in the workplaces. They were disadvantaged as compared to white males. When affirmative action was introduced, the objective was to take
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation