Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics - Case Study Example

Free

Extract of sample
Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics

This patient is 71 years old and has metastatic lung cancer. She has been very happy, lives by herself and volunteers at a senior center. She has had three years in which she treated her cancer and allowed chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery, after which she became dependent on night time oxygen. Her cancer continues to progress. Her physician wants her to try an experimental chemotherapy that has a 15% chance of putting this cancer in remission. She decides not to do this. She feels she would rather die than go through another treatment, one that will remove her from her home and put her in the hospital for treatment. This paper will discuss this patients decision in light of the utilitarian theory of biomedical ethics."Utilitarianism holds that the best option is the one that does the most expected good. Stuart Mill defines utilitarian ethical philosophy as that which defines a good action as the one that maximizes pleasure and minimizes pain to as many people as possible. In other words, the consequences of the decision should be better than any of the other possible decisions. In this case, by utilitarian rules, there are other people to consider such as children and grandchildren.
The need to prolong life to its maximum accompanies our success with medicine and society's need for a long and healthy life. It used to be that people watched while loved ones suffered toward their deaths with a critical illness. This has been replaced with the philosophy that death should be stalled by using every advanced technology available ...
Download paper

Summary

This patient is 71 years old and has metastatic lung cancer. She has been very happy, lives by herself and volunteers at a senior center. She has had three years in which she treated her cancer and allowed chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery, after which she became dependent on night time oxygen…
Author : jpagac
Download 0

Related Essays

Biomedical Ethics
It will focus on a case study where a pancreatic cancer patient by the name John. H had requested that doctors should not carry out resuscitation, and that they should not continue treating him. However, when the patient becomes critically ill with internal bleeding, he requests the doctors to step in and do something to save his life. This essay will discuss the Hippocratic Oath and the intrinsic values imposed on doctors in dealing with such situations. It will explore the aspect of euthanasia and its interrelation with the Hippocratic Oath where the doctors have to make a decision whether...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Biomedical Ethics!
According to Starson, taking the medication would disrupt him from pursuing his research; being a gifted theoretical physicist, he believed that this research was the only reason he felt his life carried a meaning. In this sense, being unable to carry on with it would simply render his life “useless” and “meaningless.” However, the physician felt that Starson's refusal was informed by his inability to appreciate the value of treatment. Consequently, the physicians petitioned to have Starson's treatment decision transferred to a surrogate. Though the petition was granted, Starson would...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Utilitarianism
The Ethical policy which stated that moral value of an action is exclusively resolute by its donation to overall efficacy. It is thus a figure of inevitably, sense that the moral worth of an action is resolute by its outcome the ends validate the resources. Utility the good to be capitalized on has been distinct by a variety of thinkers as contentment or pleasure though preference utilitarian like Peter Singer describes it as the pleasure of fondness.The theme of abortion is an extremely responsive one. Abortion is critically wicked. The finest way to argue in conflict to abortion is with...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Medical Ethics, Modern Situations
According to Steinberg, "Medical ethics in the modern sense refers to the application of general and fundamental ethical principles to clinical practice situations, including medical research," (Steinberg 1998: 3)....
28 pages (7028 words) Essay
Act and Rule Utilitarianism
Act utilitarianism focuses on the specific act that will bring that good in the end. However, according to the rule utilitarian, this is improbable or even impossible. This begs the question: How does one determine if an act will produce a specific good This is where rule utilitarianism comes into the picture. One first determines what are the rules that if generally followed will produce the best results. The rule utilitarian does not focus on finding the specific act that will produce the best results since any act in accordance to that rule will produce a good.Thus, rule utilitarianism is...
1 pages (251 words) Essay
Biomedical Research Model
The main reason behind the birth of this model was the influence of Cartesian paradigm on medical thought. This model is considered as the conceptual foundation to the modern medicine. There is a growing perception, however, that the biomedical model cannot fully reflect the broad realities of modern health care (White 1988). This paper focuses on explaining why biomedical model is considered to be outdated....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Biomedical Ethics
Traditionally ethics followed two major schools. Utilitarianism, majorly propagated by John Stuart Mill & Jeremy Bentham, suggested that what is moral is what leads to happiness or pleasure. The principle of utility is sometimes summarized as "the greatest good for the greatest number." (Mark Kuczewski, "Methods of Traditionally Applied Philosophy: Utilitarianism")...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!