StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Free Will and Moral Responsibility - Book Report/Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Free Will and Moral Responsibility

Whether David Hume believes that freedom of action is sufficient for moral responsibility has become a point of much contention amongst Hume scholars. Hume's account of moral responsibility is complex. He outlines a remarkably unorthodox framework within which to understand moral sentiments and responsibility. Within this framing he addresses the problem of freedom and offers a distinct account of moral evaluation. The precise conceptual content of this account continues to be a subject of lengthy debate amongst philosophers who understand Hume as intervening as a compatibilist into the free will debate. What his compatibilism means in the context of responsibility is, however, entirely different according to naturalist and classical interpretations. Different interpretative models entail differing conceptions of Hume's theory of responsibility. To ascertain whether freedom of action is sufficient for moral responsibility it is necessary to examine both interpretations. To this end, we must also make sense of Hume's numerous ideas of freedom, his radical conception of necessity and the reconciling project which entails his categorisation as a compatibilist. Only then will it be possible truly to address what kind of freedom, or necessity, Hume understands to be the necessary condition of moral responsibility.
Before we begin an examination of Hume's work it is impo...
Only then will it be possible truly to address what kind of freedom, or necessity, Hume understands to be the necessary condition of moral responsibility.

I
Before we begin an examination of Hume's work it is important first to define the terms of the debate. What is in question here is the relationship between freedom and responsibility - two familiar notions that are, still, heavily disputed. If we are to address the free will debate through the lens of freedom we must see that there are, in essence, two central kinds of freedom: the freedom that 'really matter to us - freedoms from coercion, punishment, constraint, oppression' and what many understand to be the 'illusory freedom of the will' (Kane 2005: 4). It is around these two conceptions of freedom that the debate must turn. Yet, in Hume's work, freedom is relegated to a lesser important role as the definition of the nation and the nation's work is analysed in greater detail. In this sense, he provides a less realistic picture of freedom and disappoints as far as rendering an artistic and creative notion towards duty is concerned.

Equally, we can examine the free will debate through the lens of responsibility. 'Free will is also intimately related to notions of accountability, blameworthiness, and praiseworthiness for actions' (Kane 2005: 4). This constant focus on responsibility is what takes away from the basis of freedom and there is a need for Hume to regard this concept with a greater focus on history and events that have shaped the very conception of freedom.

We constantly question the amount of blame and praise that can be attributed to an agent on account of their actions. This is seen frequently in, for example, the criminal justice system. A ...Show more

Summary

The essay will then examine Hume's accounts of liberty and necessity. Examining his treatment of these concepts in the Treatise and the Enquiry and suggesting why Hume's account is so singular and why it has been influential. This section will deal with the different conceptions of liberty and Hume's idiosyncratic understanding of necessity.
Author : cdouglas
Free Will and Moral Responsibility essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Free Will and Moral Responsibility"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth
Benjamin Friedman’s The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth sets to make amends to this factor, while providing a good analysis to readers. The book sets to enlighten readers on issues of topical significance and in the process gives the reader thought provoking materials crucial for a reflection.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
The Responsibility Revolution
They were also moved by their hopes and aspiration which could only be satisfied at the realization of their goal. So as to cement this cooperation they were governed by a set of rules to maintain the aim. The mission couldn’t be realized without actualizing their effort through work.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Should Americans have free universal health care
It shares the same overall goals as the rest of the health care system do, reducing premature death rate minimizing the effects of disease, disability, and injury. The social health protection provides quality health coverage and financial shield to all citizens of a given country.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Orporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibility can be associated with the economics, social and environmental responsibility.The concept of corporate social responsibility generally involves the social organization and social bodies.Corporate citizenship and following the sustainability in a business are also regarded as the corporate social responsibility.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Moral Problems Among Dutch Nurses
Each section of the article will be looked at in the order in which it was presented, using a critical appraisal checklist to assist the process of analysis. Introduction: The opening statement clearly outlines what the survey was about, and summarised methods, results, statistical analysis and conclusions.
12 pages (3000 words) Book Report/Review
Kantian Moral Theory
This paper will focus on the strategies used for justifying moral theories, as this is generally where the theorists go their separate ways in constructing the supreme principle of morality. As such each theory may yield different answers to the three questions raised under morality: 1) Authoritative question: Why ought I be moral 2) Substantive question: Which interest ought I to take favourable account of 3) Distributive question: Whose interest ought I to take favourable account of
20 pages (5000 words) Book Report/Review
Moral Status of Cloning Humans
The basic motive of this project is to analyze Michael Tooley’s article, “Moral Status of Cloning Humans”. He says that the idea or theory of genetic determinism is not correct, therefore, cloning to produce persons cannot be labeled intrinsically wrong. Tooley further asserts that not only is cloning not immoral, but it can help us improve our lives.
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
The Free Negro in Virginia
Speaking of the American Constitution he hopes that his work would explain the ideas behind the adoption of the 14th Amendment, in 1868, which finally allowed black people to be
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Response to globalization and the moral of The White Tiger
The mind of an individual continues to remain nationalized, notwithstanding one’s deep involvement and attachment to the concept of globalization. The author of “White Tiger,” Aravind Adiga draws inspiration from the plight of the Third World poor. In this
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Education in the moral domain
The overarching purpose of the book is to provide teachers with some practical ideas that they can use to establish a morals centered classroom environment. In addition, the book serves the
6 pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation