Works of Karl Marx and Georg Simmel

Masters
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 10 (2510 words)
Download 0
The works of Karl Marx and Georg Simmel shows an ambiguous and complicated relationship when it comes to their discourse on the consumption world. It was Marx who has introduced several concepts in regard to issues such as capitalism, modernity, culture and other socio-economic and socio-political arguments…

Introduction


The so-called "commodity fetishism," as Marx (1976) tell us, is the fact that a "definite social relation between men themselves' assumes here, for the, the fantastic form of a relation between things, [or] to the producers' the social relations between their private labours appear' as material relations between persons and social relations between things." (p. 165) This concept was conceived wherein humans are the real actors whose social relationality was obscured in the reified commodity form. (Brah & Coombes 2000, p. 116)
The concept of "autonomy of objective culture", on the other hand, is Simmel's characterization of the prevalence of monetary relations in modern society. Here, he is suggesting that, paradoxically, it is the fact that money empowers us that accounts for the fragmentation of subjective life and that monetary freedom is abstract and devoid of substance because it becomes alive and valuable only through being incorporated into the substance of real social relations. (Dodd 1999, p. 38) This principle by Simmel is, in a way, an extension of Marx's commodity fetishism to cultural production in line with the idea that objective culture exists in an autonomous realm that follows an immanent developmental logic. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Karl Marx
His father Heinrich Marx was a lawyer by profession and the descendant of a long line of Rabbis. His mother, Henriette Presburg Marx, had a very similar genealogy as well. Hienrich Marx had to convert to Lutheranianism just before Karl was born because Jews were not allowed to practice law at the time. Karl was also baptized in the same church at the age of six in the year 1824. Karl was also sent…
Karl Heinrich Marx
Marx’s theories argue that all societies advance through the language of class struggle: a disagreement between the class that is in charge of controlling the society’s production (ownership class) and the lower class responsible for labor input. He called capitalism “dictatorship of the bourgeoisie” while criticizing the society’s then-current socio-economic status which the wealthy…
Karl Marx
Karl Marx therefore saw religion as the opiate of the masses that was making the poor to have a passive approach to the challenges that they were going through in life. The second idea that I love about Karl Marx is his idea on human history and class conflict. Karl Marx claimed that in the history of human beings, every historical epoch is marked by two classes of people, i.e. the bourgeois and…
Karl Marx
Though earlier works created by Marx seem to be advocating the scientific and technological development by taking it to be beneficial for the growth of human societies through his political ideology (156-7); nevertheless, his later works looks opposing the same partly because of the increase in exploitation of proletariat by bourgeoisie in the wake of industrial developments taking place in…
Georg Simmel and Walter Benjamin
The philosophical and sociological views of Simmel and Benjamin differ from each other in some aspects, but in many points of view they have the same opinions. This paper will demonstrate both authors' positions on modern and post-modern urban experience and a new politics of vision, new understanding of modern city and mass media influence on human life.…
Works of Karl Marx and Georg Simmel
The so-called "commodity fetishism," as Marx (1976) tell us, is the fact that a "definite social relation between men themselves' assumes here, for the, the fantastic form of a relation between things, [or] to the producers' the social relations between their private labours appear' as material relations between persons and social relations between things." (p. 165) This concept was conceived…
Karl Marx and Capitalism
I discuss these points under three areas that form the premise of my argument. The first deals with Marx's Labor Theory of Value in which Marx talks about the distribution of wealth as being unfairly in the control of the capitalist, and the profits being usurped by the provider of capital, leaving the laborer with meager wages that just provide them for nothing more than bare existence. In the…