StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Moral testimony - Article Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Moral testimony

"Moral experts have no need to seek out others' moral expertise, but moral non-experts lack sufficient knowledge to determine whether the advice provided by a putative moral expert in response to complex moral situations is correct and hence whether an individual is a bone fide expert."1
The acceptance of moral testimony has been challenged on the basis that it does not make knowledge available to the recipient and therefore the use of such a knowledge is illegitimate.Before the reasons for this objection are discussed it is worth noting that little academic attention has actually been paid to the idea of whether or not testimony can be a legitimate source of moral beliefs.2
"we should be open to being persuaded by others, responsive to moral argument; but we should not take their word on moral issues, not allow ourselves to be influenced by the fact that they hold a certain view''.if, on the other hand, reliance on moral testimony is legitimate, there will still be questions about the conditions under which it is so". 3
This means that even though it is hard for us as humans to reject or accept moral judgements and considerations subconsciously , we cannot let these considerations to become a part of our analyses in real life. For example my idea that a certain person is "racist" or a "liar" is based on my own perceptions and experiences. When dealing with this person my prejudices will inevitably suffice (even though in a very subtle manner).However any action by a third party based on my views or "moral testimony" should not be relied upon. Even if my moral testimony does form the basis of another party's reaction or action and it is subsequently accepted Hopkins(2007) believes that there should be a more "solid" reason for doing so rather than my own value judgements.

It has been further suggested that "moral discourse, for some reason or other, cannot meet the conditions necessary for learning from the word of others. Since the epistemology is wrong, there is no knowledge to be had from testimonial transactions on moral matters."(Hopkins 2007). It is for this reason that it is believed that it would be rather "illegitimate" to let other's claims guide one's moral belief. For example as an employer of a person I might be faced with the moral testimony of the hiring committee that this person has "moral shortcomings" but I cannot base my judgement on these moral shortcomings. Firstly because morality is largely a matter of perception and the evidence offered in this regard will also be based on "feelings" or the personal experiences of the moral expert, and not actual evidence of their shortcoming like theft or irresponsibility on the job.
Of course the contrary view in this regards is that in the right circumstances, moral dialogue may meet and fulfil all the criteria of testimonies in general (Hopkins 2007). The problem however remains that moral testimony lies in a standard that only relates to morals and since knowledge is right, testimony does make moral knowledge available. (Hopkins 2007)

For a more profound analysis of this issue it is necessary to delve deeper into what the words "moral" and "testimony" entail in ...Show more

Summary

This essay discusses the philosophical premises, which can lead to either the acceptance or rejection of moral testimony in theory and practice. Academic and philosophical opinion has pointed out a number of objections to this proposition in the forms of moral non-cognition and the problems in the identification and credibility of moral experts or moral authority.
Author : mohrsamanta
Moral testimony essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the article on your topic
"Moral testimony"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Create a moral compass for characters of The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz
Moral compass of characters in the novel The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz is really diverse. Duddy is apt at being good to people. He is driven by the goal of reaching wealth and gaining love of his father and grandfather even through illegal actions. Lennie is closer to being evil, as he flees and betrays his friends and people close to him.
1 pages (250 words) Article
Iterature Review on hospital enviormentally friendly inpacked on employee and/or patients moral/healing process
In a hospital, friendly environment enhances performance of employees and increases patients morale hence increased healing chances. This paper highlights impact of creation of friendly environment in hospital setting to employees and patients healing process.
4 pages (1000 words) Article
The Role Of The Catholic Religious Education Specialist Teacher
Religion teaching is a ministry and not merely a profession because the personal qualities and professional activity of the instructor are intertwined and "rooted in God and relationship with Jesus" (Ferder, 1999:163). The role of the Catholic Religious Education (RE) specialist teacher is a significant one, with the potential for radical, positive impacts on students’ spiritual, psychological, social well-being and life skills.
12 pages (3000 words) Article
Some Moral Minima, ethics and relativism
Goodman (2010) particularly dealt with four ideas respect for life, deference to truth, and abhorrence of theft and rejection of adultery. I agree what Goodman has to say on these specific issues because in no
3 pages (750 words) Article
Literature Review on hospital enviormentally friendly inpacked on employee and/or patients moral/healing process
Basically, friendly environment motivates employees to work while patients healing process is also boosted or increased. Therefore, friendly environment
4 pages (1000 words) Article
The Role of Public Relations Companies in the Wars
According to the report the general roles of public relations today include creating awareness and positive image for customers or organizations; monitoring various media channels on behalf of companies for public comments presented therein; building goodwill in the market; and managing crises that pose a threat to an organization or product.
4 pages (1000 words) Article
Reaction paper for the Article Immigration Quotas vs. Individual Rights: The Moral and Practical Case for Open Immigration
He contended that anyone should be free to enter and live in the United States, except terrorists, criminals, and those carrying infectious diseases. He stressed that a foreigner has the same human rights as American
4 pages (1000 words) Article
Moral Courage
e intricate scam that apparently stole billions of pesos from the Philippine government’s Priority Development Assistance Fund (PDAF), an allocation of money to the members of the Philippine Congress to be earmarked supposedly to priority development programs and projects of
2 pages (500 words) Article
102 exam question 1
The rule of "you scratch my back, Ill scratch yours" tends to apply in this case. Individuals realize that other people also have needs. They may try to satisfy others needs if their own needs are also met in return (Kohlberg,
2 pages (500 words) Article
Thunderstorm
Thunder and its historical contexts sufficiently create the uncommon picture of cultural observation among the Chinese population. Despite the generally unpopular
8 pages (2000 words) Article
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation