StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders

While the ancient Greeks argued that logic, not instinct, was what gave rise to knowledge, most people today use a combination of both. Just as a cop follows a lead on “instinct” or a mother knows her child is sick through “intuition”, humans rely on an illogical gut reaction to compliment logic in the decision making process. Ignoring this gut reaction in favor of pure logic can cause humans to draw irrational conclusions, as is the case with Backlar. Furthermore, ignoring this visceral reaction causes Backlar to defy society’s view of justice in favor one more easily dismissed by logic in her article, and causes her to not only act against her human instinct, but to also practice a lower quality of medicine. Because it contradicts her profession, society’s view of justice, the instinctual feeling of what is right, I reject Barker’s conclusion that the criminally insane should be viewed as felons. In her article, Backlar tells the story of being a naive provider in a criminal psychiatric ward and feeling shocked upon hearing a more senior provider refer to patients as felons. Backlar then goes on to describe her transition from shock to acceptance as she begins to believe this senior provider is correct and that the patients are in fact felons. Throughout the article, Backlar repeats this conclusion, arguing that because the guilty and the criminally insane are all convicted criminals, they should all be given the same level of baseline treatment by the justice system. This conclusion defies Backlar’s medical profession, whose duty it is to treat patients. In any scientific process, bias introduces a systematic error in results. Thinking of patients as felons constitutes judgment of the patients and judging patients introduces a bias into care. This bias will lower the quality of care provided to the patients and will contradict the very reason Backlar is with her patients to begin with. This bias is why some medical personnel working in corrections settings choose not to know what crimes the patients they treat have committed. Viewing a patient you are assigned to treat as a felon introduces a judgment that medical personnel are not called on to provide. The job of any health care provider is to treat the patient. Using logic to formulate the argument that the patients are felons denies the true connotation of the word. “Felon” is more than its dictionary definition; it is a stigma in our society. To refer to a person as a felon is to pass judgment on them, and judging a patient because of his or her personal background would lower the standard of care. It is because of this compromising of the quality of medical care that I reject Backlar’s conclusion that the criminally insane are guilty felons. Beyond the bias that referring to a patient as a felon introduces, calling patients felons is also wrong because it implies their guilt. This argument gets at the root of Backlar’s true question in the article: should the criminally insane be punished or treated? Are the criminally insane culpable or innocent? Instead of choosing from the two options, I propose a third: to not categorize the criminally insane on the basis of their disease state, but on the basis of their individual case. The justice system does not say every drug crime should be ...Show more

Summary

Your Name Date Course Response to Patricia Backlar’s Ethics in Community Mental Health Care: Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorder: Impediments to Assigning Moral Responsibility One of the most interesting aspects of the argument Patricia Backlar makes in her article “Ethics in Community Mental Health Care: Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorder: Impediments to Assigning Moral Responsibility” is the epistemological lineage she draws her logic from…
Author : theaprohaska
Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Criminal Justice
The research centers on the criminal justice organization’s bureaucracy. Overall, the criminal justice organization effectively and efficiently implements the entire spectrum of criminal justice. In addition, bureaucracy maximizes the criminal justice organization’s efficiency. However, the line and staff organization reduces flexibility
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Sentencing of People with Mental Disorders
Sentencing: It is the judicial decision or a formal court judgment pronounced upon someone who is adjudged guilty of criminal proceedings and the punishment that is imposed. It is a well thought out, final act which declares the charged person's period of imprisonment, punishment or fine etc.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Female Offenders and Psychiatric Counseling: Criminal Justice
The prevailing majority of female offenders realize the seriousness of their deeds and the need to be punished for them. However, despite the growing number of female inmates, they remain some of the most misunderstood, neglected and unseen individuals in modern society (Covington 2007).
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Personality Disorders
Psychiatric mental health nurses work in different kinds of settings assessing mental health needs, planning the care of patients with these needs, implementing the plans and evaluating their effectiveness. Even as they work with multi-professional teams promoting recovery for the patients, they often have to connect with them on a one-to-one basis in a meaningful way.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Psychological Disorders
The public was not educated as to tell between mental illness and ordinary sadness and only perceived the extreme behavior as mental illness. Mental illness was associated with a great deal of social stigma and particularly linked with the fear of violent and unpredictable behavior (Phelan, Link, Stueve and Pescosolido).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Stigma and discrimination add to the suffering and disability associated with mental disorders
These discriminations and stigma make it rather difficult for mentally ill people to recover and worsens their pains and suffering.Given the prevalence of mental health conditions in current society, the effects of stigma and discrimination on mental patients can be said to affect a rather large portion of the population
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Mental Health and Mental Disorders
Cognitive theory did much for understanding the mechanisms and nature of mental disorders in general and anxiety in particular. The essence idea of cognitive therapy is to make a persons change their attitude to the things. One of the specialists that base their practice on the concepts of cognitive theory was Albert Ellis.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Personality Disorders and Offending Behaviour
Crime is blamed on nefarious criminal subcultures operating in the shadows of polite society. Crime must be prevented by throwing its perpetrators in prison and throwing away the keys. A careful examination of the relevant literature demonstrates the folly of such myths.
24 pages (6000 words) Essay
Mental Illness and the Criminal Justice System
There is a critical need for alternatives regarding mental illness and the need to shift the responsibility of untreated mental illness out of the criminal justice system, states Faust (p.6). Various aspects of the impact of incarcerating mentally ill offenders on the
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
Mental Health and SES
The perceptions of economic stress among adults lead to emotional depression thus lowering the quality of life among adults (McKenzie & Harpham, 2006). There is a link between the SES and learning disabilities
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation