StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Argument on the criteria of personhood & its moral implications - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Argument on the criteria of personhood & its moral implications

"The issue of personhood is one that must be addressed through religious reasoning. Hence, the Lutheran Church in America makes a qualitative distinction between the claims of the fetus and the rights of a responsible person made in God’s image who is in living relationships with God and other human beings. Except in the most materialistic of philosophies, human personhood has a great deal to do with feelings, awareness, and interactive experience” (Mollenkott) However Tooley, like Warren, elaborates more extensive criteria of human personhood. Tooley claims that an organism possesses a serious right to life only if it possesses the concept of a self as a continuing subject of experiences and other mental states, and believes that it is itself such a continuing entity. He further explains that being a person does not imply to have a right of continued existence unless that person possesses the concept of a subject of experiences, temporal order, and the identity of things. He arguments that killing of non-humans i.e., animals is permissible for consumption and leather usage however torturing them for a time is not only an unethical act but also punishable by law so a fetus or a deformed infant is similar to these non-humans as they have no awareness of their self. Both Mollenkott’s and Tooley’s gave the philosophical arguments that only Homo sapiens that possess certain connection with their environment have a full right to life. This argument possesses some logical weakness. ...Show more


Dr. Mollenkott is an American feminist who is notably recognized due to her work in feminist, lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender theologies. Mollenkott presents her point of view which is very similar to the Warren’s Cognitive criteria…
Author : jarod02
Argument on the criteria of personhood & its moral implications essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Argument on the criteria of personhood & its moral implications"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Argument on the criteria of personhood & its moral implications: Mary Anne Warren
The question is that many grown up individuals lack the above characteristics due to different mental deficiencies so should it be permissible to kill them as they are not human beings as per the above criteria?
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The Moral Implications of Oretga and Gasset's Account of Barbarism
Therefore the rise and fall of a society is directly linked to barbarism. The principles of civilization and the principle of barbarism evolves and develops at the same time. The initial period of civilization arises from the core of humanity and it is usually through a method of violence.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Parfit's, the Reductionist and Moral Commitment Argument
In this regard, Parfin’s believe is that the facts concerning personal identity exist in particular facts about the connectedness of psychology and that personal identity could be reduced to the said connectedness. Parfin is informed that his view concerning personal identity is not whatever many individuals perceive about persons.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Moral argument
She wanted a voluntary active euthanasia. Even Mrs. Boyes’ two sons supported this. Dr. Cox believes he acted in his patient’s best interests, but he was treated like a common criminal in the courts. By definition, respected dictionaries, internet search engines, and the opinion of several people all agree that euthanasia is “mercy killing” --- an act of intentionally ending one’s life in order to end insurmountable suffering.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Abortion and Personhood
The long and contentious moral and theological debate over the precise moment when personhood should be recognized is, in itself, perhaps the most compelling argument that incorporating the use of personhood language in the defense of both the right to life and the right to choose perspectives is highly problematic.This was displayed most notably in the 1973 Supreme Court Decision of Roe v.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Are we violating the human rights of patients in a persistent vegetative state
data that would offer clue to the validity of the assumption made, we have looked into an extensive array of Literature sources that contain anecdotal references to different issues connected with this medical problem: the very definition of
80 pages (20000 words) Essay
Abortion and personhood
This was displayed most notably in the 1973 Supreme Court Decision of Roe v. Wade1 which based its landmark decision not on the issue of personhood, but rather on the viability of the fetus outside of the womb. This decision affirmed the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Moral Significance of Personhood
The author of the essay highlights the fact, the idea is that a person owes its identity and personhood to the soul, reinforcing the principle that human life is sacred, requiring respect and recognition of its dignity. Thus, the soul is, ideally, what makes a human a person as it both breathes life to the human body and gives it the faculty of reason.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
The moral diversity argument for nonobjectivism
Moral diversity can be interpreted in different ways through a non-objectivist point of view. Non-objectivism is divided into three basic types: moral subjectivism, cultural relativism and moral nihilism. Moral subjectivism explains that morality is relative to the individual’s beliefs and values.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Argument from moral equivalence
Indeed, if cultural relativity is true, then it means no culture is superior to the other. If no culture is superior to the other also, then no culture’s moral values and codes can be condemned; as far as those morals and values
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email