StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Knowledge Argument - Essay Example

Free

Extract of sample
The Knowledge Argument

(Alter, T) To begin with, Frank Jackson’s Mary leaves her black and white room for the first time to see a red tomato, a blue sky and other colours around her. Up till the time she remained within her confined black and white world, she was under the impression that she had all the physical knowledge in the world, however, since she enters the Technicolor world; she understands that the complete physical truth is not the whole truth. Thus, the physical world does not necessarily determine the complete truth about the world. The very case of Mary helps to divide the knowledge intuition into three parts ranging from the time Mary thought she had complete knowledge and claim over the truth about the world; her learning claim as she understood that there were things she did not know about; and the non deductibility claim according to which if the above two claims are true then when Mary leaves the room, whatever she gains cannot be comprehended by the complete physical truth. Thus, according to this very case laid down by Jackson, it may be proved that physicalism is false, because not all physical facts can be known without knowing the actual facts of the matter and not all are physical. (Knowledge Argument Against Physicalism) If the idea of physicalism were true, then Mary would have all the knowledge and information with regard to colour vision from the human eyes before she left the room. However, till her time there, she was under the impression that the entire world existed only in black

Related Essays

Knowledge Management
This paper is the analysis of the Siemens case study and its knowledge management practices. Two questions are analyzed: (1) knowledge management as human resource management; and (2) the effects of the wrong organizational culture on knowledge sharing. Recommendations to create a perfect knowledge culture are provided.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Try to defend dualism as a viable philosophical position. Entertain objections to your arguments and reply showing how dualism c
So far, three arguments prove the validity of dualism and remain valid despite objections: the Knowledge Argument, the Argument on the Validity of Predicate Dualism, and Descartes’ Argument from Feigning. Metaphysical dualism is the doctrine that there exist two substances: a physical reality and an equivalent spiritual or mental reality.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Knowledge
Name: Tutor: Course: Date: Question 3 Knowledge is a very wide topic that if we started to talk generally about it, it would take several years to evaluate and conclude. Infact, the topic ‘knowledge’ is a recurring topic and for some philosophers, the studying of knowledge as a subject on its own has been in existence for as long as philosophy has been around.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Argument
According to their argument, the minority groups are sidelined in terms of accessing higher education. In terms of progressive development, gaps are still noticeable in respect of education accessed by the males and females. In this regard, it seems the girl child still lag behind when considering right to education for all.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Knowledge is an example of a public good. Analyse this statement, drawing on further research to inform your argument
Comparing Knowledge and Public Goods Suber (2009) describes some of the important arguments that describe knowledge as a public good. Two characteristics of knowledge have led many scholars to argue for its being regarded as a public good instead of a private asset.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Knowledge Encounters
These questions underlie her investigation of St. Elias’ glaciers and the role they play in international imagination at present and in the past. Do Glaciers Listen? Local Knowledge, Colonial Encounters, & Social Imagination contributes to recent discourse into the complex colonial encounter dynamics and the encounter’s aftermath, while also addressing the issue of troubling the divide between nature and culture.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Philosophy - knowledge
This is different from analyzing any other thing. Keeping this in mind, we can identify the qualities and extent of knowledge better than defining knowledge as an independent object. Hence we shall first try to determine the nature and limitations of knowledge, before moving on to the idea of justified true belief.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Argument
In the history of philosophy, Plato is fairly regarded as one of the major proponents of rationalism, while John Locke is among those, who defend their sensual positions and are
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Dreaming argument
The dream argument has two true premises, and logical conclusion, explaining its validity. These also show how sound the argument is, in revealing how one cannot know anything about the world outside
3 pages (750 words) Essay
What does Jackson's Knowledge Argument show
Marys Room was a thought provoking experiment that made attempts to establish the fact that there exist non –physical attributes and attainable
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
or white. When she leaves the room, she intuitively learns about new things in the form of qualia, properties of objects that are in different colours etc, and thus she is able to understand that she did not have access to all the physical truths during the course of her time within the confines of her room. This therefore, helps to prove that physicalism is false by nature. Yet another example has been discussed by Broad as he talks about his mathematical archangel. This creature has been designed in a manner that it possesses all knowledge regarding chemical compounds and thus knows all the physical truths possible about the same. However, the archangel does not know about the phenomenal knowledge of these chemical compounds, for example, the pungent smell of ammonia or the texture of sulphur powder. And thus, with the help of this particular example, the philosopher has argued that physicalism is indeed false because there are more to objects than just their physical existences. (Broad, C. D) Nagel on the other hand, has talked about how a human being cannot imagine what it might be to be a bat. With this very famous example, he has helped man to realise how it is next to impossible to even imagine what it might be like to be someone or something else. A bat has a completely different perception about the physical world around it because of the inherent qualities that it possesses, which are in reality, completely different from the built of a man and the way he carries out his activities in response to the world around him. (Nagel, Thomas) Thus, in conclusion, if one was to regard the very idea of physicalism as true, then one would have to deny the fact that it is impossible to possess new knowledge or information, difficult to comprehend touch, sound, feel and hearing

Summary

Name 11 July 2011 Assignment Physicalism is a philosophical argument according to which every object within the scope of the universe exists only as much as its physical properties; no more and no less. Thus, there are no other things in the universe other than physical objects…
Author : gerhardwisozk
The Knowledge Argument essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation